4 ms·
Let's call it for what it is: poor planning and management by both the state and local government and some of the world's biggest companies which have absolutel
by manigandham 8y ago
Let's call it for what it is: poor planning and management by both the state and local government and some of the world's biggest companies which have absolutely failed at anything resembling civic duty.
There needs to be proper leadership that understands how people live and work to build a city that can cater to everyone outside of the upper/middle class at major companies.
- malmsteen 8y agoOr people should move and not do drugs. Oh right no its the government that is responsible of that. Move to france. We have free healthcare and few opiod medications.
- testfoobar 8y agoAllocating social resources to address social needs is the foundational purpose of government. Voters elect governments to focus, prioritize and implement solutions. Ultimately any failure falls at the feet of voters.
- manigandham 8y agoI think we all know that it's just not that simple. There are too many things to vote for which is half of the reason for delegating to officials in the first place. However there's no real way to know what people are going to do in office and it seems they are increasingly unpredictable and ineffective, led astray by apathy and greed rather than any duty to the people. A large part of it is likely the vast isolation they see from the actual issues. More skin in the game would greatly change things if they actually had to face these problems themselves instead of just answering public feedback with empty platitudes.
- tresil 8y agoI don't know if it's wise or helpful to lay this at the feet of government and big companies. They are big beasts that do well with defined budgets and defined directives, but they rely on their constituents and shareholders heavily for both of those two things. While that may not seem ideal, it's practical and what we have always seen in reality. I think many in government knew this was going on, and becoming an increasing issue/epidemic in recent years, but until the public becomes outraged and is willing to support a big shift in policy and budget, what they can do is limited. It might be some of the people in government that we should feel most sorry for - they've been witnessing it for years and voicing concern, but few in the public will listen or do anything about it. Perhaps I'm being too generous, but I see government and big institutions as behaving very much like computers, with much less intelligence and autonomy than the general public might think.
- azinman2 8y agoThe public is outraged. That’s why prop C with a 300MM blank check was passed.
- gamma-male 8y ago60% vs 40% at that. Thank god.
- manigandham 8y agoIt's incredibly obvious that housing, homelessness, and general city livability are major problems in SF to everyone, even passing tourists. How much clearer does it need to get? Government officials are constituents too and they should be able to figure this out even without any public feedback. This is their job. Ignorance and apathy have no place there and they would be fired in any other industry for this kind of incompetence. Unfortunately they're also in charge of any rules around accountability.
- tresil 8y agoSo admittedly I'm not a resident of SF or California, but to address the first item on your list, housing - if it's a major problem identified by everyone, why haven't the public voted in line with that assertion? https://sf.curbed.com/2018/11/8/18075464/yimby-sf-election-vote-2018-trauss-housing-development https://sf.curbed.com/2018/11/8/18075464/yimby-sf-election-v.... And trust me that's not the first group to try do something like that. For years voters have been turning down similar initiatives to ease the housing problem there. I still hold my point that the public may get "outraged" or whine about the problem, but they won't act or vote in alignment with that outrage until it actually impacts them. The homeless/opioid epidemic finally crossed that threshold and so they did. But that just proves my point that it's the public that must act/vote and see themselves as the responsible party, and not wait for the government to solve everything.
- manigandham 8y agoThe government is the people. At some point, the officials need to just get on with it. The reality is fine-grained democratic voting on every issue does not scale to today's world. People do not have the time, attention, education and understanding to vote properly on everything, and when you add in personal biases, lack of risk management, short-term outlooks, majority power, and special interests; things break down completely. Many of these things which could improve civic life do not really need a voting process. It's not a system for the people (not anymore) but stays around because it removes accountability and provides regulatory capture for the few who profit. Of course, as you say, the very people who do not take action are the ones that need to take action for this to get better. I do not have an answer for that.