4 ms·
I'm highly fascinated between Haiku and ReactOS, but I havent had a chance to use both in a while. I want them to become available. I really appreciate that Hai
by giancarlostoro 8y ago
I'm highly fascinated between Haiku and ReactOS, but I havent had a chance to use both in a while. I want them to become available. I really appreciate that Haiku was meant to be a remake of BeOS (iirc) and it does a fantastic job. I feel like we don't do enough OS research like we used to. We've started to dive into making new languages like Rust and Go, but I guess the next wave I'm waiting for is new and interesting Operating Systems.
- blacksmith_tb 8y agoI still have a BeOS 3.5in floppy in a drawer somewhere, so this announcement produced a little nostalgia for ~1999 or so. That said, it's sort of hard to imagine lots of new OSes springing up, they take a lot of care and feeding... I would think the obvious choice would be to somehow to support packages from another OS (say Snap or Flatpak apps from Linux), so that you could overcome the need to port everything (or have no users).
- Koshkin 8y ago> hard to imagine lots of new OSes springing up, they take a lot of care and feeding I imagine the OS inside the Tamagotchi toy would be the prime example.
- sgrove 8y ago> we don't do enough OS research like we used to. I feel projects like MirageOS[0], Qubes OS[1], and unikernels in general are laying a lot of groundwork for interesting new developments in operating systems. And as a bonus, there's a lot more automated work on security and safety! [0] https://mirage.io https://mirage.io (and cool sub projects like running Mirage on a ESP32 with reprocessing to make a homebrew gameboy-like platform [0.1]) [0.1] An operating system that can scale down to tiny platforms could be a lot of fun to homebrew tinkering https://twitter.com/cem2ran/status/1034879037758496772 https://twitter.com/cem2ran/status/1034879037758496772 [1] https://www.qubes-os.org https://www.qubes-os.org
- WrtCdEvrydy 8y agoI wonder if I should start contributing to qubes-os. I'd really like to add something to isolate non-gui projects in docker instead of VMs.
- zamadatix 8y agoIf you're interested in contributing I'd look into it a little closer as I don't think containers align with the security model of Qubes. They'd rather support spinning up single container VMs which run separate Docker instances... probably not even in a Docker swarm due to the security channels that opens.
- Q6T46nT668w6i3m 8y agoI’m stoked that unikernel papers are still popular (and there’s still a lot of unexplored territory), but it’s not exactly a groundbreaking area! I share the original post’s sentiment about the lack of exciting operating systems research around topics outside of the standard areas like file systems, memory management, and security. Especially since these issues, for many people, are secondary to the perceived features of operating systems (like drivers and widget toolkits). I’d love, for example, to see some truly fresh ideas for new or different system calls (in addition to Fuchsia and Haiku).
- willtim 8y agoGenode also (genode.org), which uses a verified microkernel and sandboxes. The focus in this day and age really needs to be on security.
- Thaxll 8y agoUseful OS will probably never append , when you see how long it took to create Linux, thousands of people that worked on it for a very long time and still it's not on part with Windows for desktop.
- Q6T46nT668w6i3m 8y agoTo be fair, most of this work, as is the case for any popular operating system, is mostly drivers. It’s entirely possible to write a succsssful operating system for a narrowly defined platform.
- waddlesplash 8y agoWell, Haiku reuses FreeBSD's ethernet/WiFi drivers, and we will probably wind up reusing DragonFlyBSD's DRM drivers. Most of our time in kernel development is actually spent on the kernel, not in driver development.
- bauerd 8y agoThe point of OS research projects is definitely not creating Windows competitors
- Koshkin 8y agoExcept I wouldn't call Haiku or ReactOS "research projects." Indeed, one of their goals, whether explicit or implicit, is to provide an alternative to Windows on the desktop.
- tialaramex 8y agoRetro computing operating systems. There are a few of these. They're an "alternative to Windows" in the same sense that riding a penny farthing is an "alternative to travelling by bicycle" or sending a telegram is an "alternative to using the telephone". It's just nostalgia. Whether these systems could attract the same development effort (and money, though what if anything Haiku Inc. does with the money is pretty unclear since they're lousy at basic organisational responsibilities of a charity) if they admitted they aren't a serious "alternative to Windows on the desktop" is an open question.
- mmirate3 8y ago> we don't do enough OS research like we used to. Don't worry; once they finish it in a few years, Google's new "Fuchsia" OS will let them take over the world (to an even greater extent than today).
- giancarlostoro 8y agoThat does sound a bit worrisome if it indeed were to become an OS that runs on every platform including desktops. If they ever close source it, then I will be really worried.
- mmirate3 8y agoIIRC, it is intended to replace both Android and Chrome OS. And as shown by the Android Open Source Project, they don't need to close-source it to engage in worrisome behavior.
- mhd 8y agoWe're definitely not doing enough interface research anymore, now that our corporate overlords have decided that "apps" are the thing to aim for, as they're easier to exploit for maximum profitability. At one time, more integrated approaches were considered. It's sad that Unix pipes and all that's wrong with them are one of the few remainders on this particular field. And no, I don't mourn CORBA.