This is a new low for IBM. If they had actually produced the system they are describing, they would bring a person to debate the machine in real time, and they

This is a new low for IBM. If they had actually produced the system they are describing, they would bring a person to debate the machine in real time, and they would have an uncut clip of that happening, because it would be an absolute technical marvel. Obviously I can not prove that they haven't developed a miracle device which can construct complete arguments and theories in real time, but if they had done, they'd've shown something more convincing.