3 ms·
Sounds pretty much like how human debates are already structured: 1. Grab key points from influential books and articles to create templated responses 2. Do n
by rchaud 8y ago
Sounds pretty much like how human debates are already structured:
1. Grab key points from influential books and articles to create templated responses
2. Do no original research and thus be completely unable to rebut criticisms of the source data or analysis
3. Counter #2 above by falling back on crowd-pleasing templated responses, forcing the moderator to move the debate along
4. Never, ever concede anything, because "debates" are no longer about listening to an argument and carefully considering their merits, it is a time-boxed verbal combat sport where there must be a winner and a loser.
- tw1010 8y agoYou think you're getting closer to the truth by being cynical, but what you're really doing is overshoot the target so far that you're basically just as far from the reality of debates as the uncynical view is.
- dfxm12 8y agoWhat is the reality of debates?
- kiriakasis 8y agoI think that was an intentionally terrible response meant to illustrate the efficacy of the list.
- wetpaws 8y agoI see what you did there
- jimmaswell 8y agoIt sounded spot on to me, at least in terms of the kind of "debate" seen on news stations.
- iseeyoubydesign 8y agoits still the best way we have ... its the process of spectating the debate that the viewer can consume two opposing sides and then make a decision. To think that a debate itself could actually create truth is to give too much faith in the skill and equal skill of either debater. And in reality, no subject is completely one sided in its conclusions, it healthy to be able to make peace with paradoxes and contradictions. Requiring a "only one right way" standpoint is dogmatic, stubborn, and mentally weak. A good debate gives the viewer a strong mind by being able to hold opposing views simultaneously.
- aperrien 8y agoI don't believe that a debate is a place for "original research". Especially given the time constraints of most debates.
- kiriakasis 8y agohere original research would mean being able to argument with more than an "ipse dixit".