3 ms·
Wouldn’t it make more sense to properly separate private and public? If hospitals can be either Medicare-only or no-Medicare (using Medicare as the name of a fu
by alkonaut 8y ago
Wouldn’t it make more sense to properly separate private and public? If hospitals can be either Medicare-only or no-Medicare (using Medicare as the name of a future broad/universal system much larger than Medicare/aid is today) then hospitals would chose to be Medicare in proportion to how many are covered. If everyone (including those who chose a private insurance) pays a full insurance premium for the public system on their taxes, the private insurers’ patient lists would shrink very quickly, and so would the number of hospitals that could survive by providing treatment to those patients.
So looking from outside it looks like “hospital prices” is just another one of the problems that would be solved by a tax funded public universal healthcare insurance?
Example (Sweden): I pay a full public insurance through taxes, and I have a private insurance via my employer that lets me cut some waiting times for certain procedures from 90 to 14 days. It’s an expensive way for my employer to make sure I’d be back to work quicker than I would otherwise be. Obviously, this is a luxury few use or need so the number of hospitals that provide this care is extremely limited (a few percent).
- conanbatt 8y agoIf you have public hospitals that are tax funded and private hospitals, you will see that private hospitals will only provide profitable services (cardian, neuro, etc) and give all loss patients to public hospitals (psychiatry, managed care, etc). Public hospitals will have a unreasonable burden of high-cost patients.
- alkonaut 8y agoI think you misunderstood: anyone who uses private would do so while also paying for a full public health insurance. That is, the public system is fully funded regardless of whether anyone wants to operate private hospitals.
- conanbatt 8y agoAh, that would make healthcare a lot more expensive, making people pay twice for the same service.
- alkonaut 8y agoYes - it makes private insurance an added luxury product. This is normally how it works where there is a publicly funded universal system. On the other hand the public insurance covers many expensive things very well (e.g cancer treatment) so the private insurance is for things like getting a knee surgery without waiting time where the public system can have 90 days waiting time. Someone like an athlete wouldn’t want to wait that long but for most people it’s acceptable if it keeps premiums (taxes) lower. The “paying twice for the same thing” is a feature, not a bug. Most people wouldn’t do that of course, meaning they would simply get rid of their private insurance.
- conanbatt 8y agoIt makes it inefficient in economic terms. I think you are attempting to frame it in terms of cost-shifting: making the "rich" pay for "the poor" by paying twice. But when the public hospital is 10 miles away, and the private hospital is 1 mile away, paying twice effectively lowers the access of care to the people that can't afford to pay twice. And then, proximity to public hospitals would be so valuable, that housing prices would icnrease close to the best public hospitals, and the richer will again take profit of it, just like it happens with zone-dependent schools.
- alkonaut 8y agoDoesn't that type of inefficiency already exist when a patient may need (or want) to go to a "network hospital", when there are multiple competing networks instead of one enormous one (that has say 95% of the "market")? > paying twice effectively lowers the access of care to the people that can't afford to pay twice My private insurance that kicks in if I e.g. need a knee surgery with 14 days wait instead of 90, will often require me to fly to a different city, likely even a different country, to get the procedure performed at a specialist private clinic. This care is something completely different to the regular care I need day-to-day for a child delivery, cancer treatment, appendectomy or whatever. As there is so very little overlap I'm also not paying twice. There isn't a private insurer that will offer me cancer treatment, child delivery etc. They don't exist because who would want to pay twice for that?