3 ms·
Is this not a rephrasing of the GP's position? To "signal something, not to inherently accomplish something" is to be insincere in one's virtue (and therefore,
by woodruffw 8y ago
Is this not a rephrasing of the GP's position? To "signal something, not to inherently accomplish something" is to be insincere in one's virtue (and therefore, at least on some accounts, to fail to act in accordance with virtue).
Edit: That probably sounds more confrontational than I mean it to be. Rephrased: I think 'claudiawerner nicely exposes some of the flawed reasoning behind characterizations of "virtue signalling." What advantage in understanding do we gain by divorcing "signal" and "accomplishing something" that is not covered by either (1) (unsubstantiated) insincerity, or (2) sincerity that we don't find objectionable (the "Alternatively" clause)?