4 ms·
> Likewise, Benjamin has been called right wing and an alt-right sympathizer by multiple news outlets. He rejects those characterizations, calling himself a “cl
by eesmith 8y ago
> Likewise, Benjamin has been called right wing and an alt-right sympathizer by multiple news outlets. He rejects those characterizations, calling himself a “classical liberal.” However, a recent Southern Poverty Law Center report revealed he has been a stepping stone for some white supremacists on the path to radicalization. The Right Stuff, an unapologetically racist, antisemitic blog founded by white supremacist Mike Peinovich, hosted a poll asking users who their biggest influence was in coming to the alt-right. Multiple respondents named Sargon of Akkad. And for someone who says he’s not a part of the alt-right, he’s been spending a lot of time with them lately. He’s appeared in videos with alt-right figures like Millennial Woes and Richard Spencer, giving those men a platform to reach his nearly 800,000 subscribers in the process. - https://www.splcenter.org/hatewatch/2018/04/25/milo-yiannopoulos-will-speak-cal-poly-campus-already-tense-string-racist-incidents https://www.splcenter.org/hatewatch/2018/04/25/milo-yiannopo...
- darkpuma 8y agoWhile an effective indictment of his moral character, that's not him advocating genocide, which is what I was responding to. I never claimed he's a good person.
- furgooswft13 8y agoIt's so hard to trust anything these days, much less the SPLC... > Mike Peinovich, hosted a poll asking users who their biggest influence was in coming to the alt-right. Multiple respondents named Sargon of Akkad. I can't find the actual poll in question, but from the SPLC's own analysis, Sargon was mentioned a grand total of 3 times in a thread about what brought people to "the movement" on The Right Stuff forum. I guess that counts as "multiple". Regardless it was a very small sample size collected from an explicitly white nationalist (I assume, I'm just taking SPLC's word for that one) message board. Likely most of the people who still follow Sargon have not gone down the racist rabbit hole and just consider themselves skeptics, but hey they found 3 so... But this part is downright slanderous, or liable (not sure which, need to watch the Spiderman movie again...) > And for someone who says he’s not a part of the alt-right, he’s been spending a lot of time with them lately. He’s appeared in videos with alt-right figures like Millennial Woes and Richard Spencer, giving those men a platform to reach his nearly 800,000 subscribers in the process. While factually true the implication is clearly that he appeared with these figures to promote their ideas, not debate them, which is what actually happened. When paired with Spencer Sargon so vehemently disagreed with him that he kinda made a fool of himself, as at least Spencer remained calm throughout. I don't really care to defend Sargon and don't watch/listen to most of any of the content he produces. I do follow the tea leaves though, and from what I've gathered, while certainly anti-PC/feminist/social justice/progressive etc., he's no racist. I mean I could be wrong because as I said I've not listened to much of him, but I'm certainly not going to take the SPLC's word for it.
- eesmith 8y agoYou write "he's no racist". The SPLC did not say he is a racist, did they? I didn't see that in the text I mentioned, but perhaps they said it elsewhere? If not, then you don't need to take their word for something they didn't say. They did make an association between him and racism, so let's examine that connection. This thread exists because of an NYT article about an action by Patreon where Patreon, at https://patreonhq.com/hate-speech-on-patreon-a9026e52c2cf https://patreonhq.com/hate-speech-on-patreon-a9026e52c2cf and mentioned elsewhere in this thread - says he "used racial slurs to insult others and specifically linked those slurs with negative generalizations of behavior, in contrast to how people of other races act." You can confirm that those are some pretty racist statements. Now, I know that some people demur stating that someone is a racist for doing racist things. Are you making that distinction? Even if you don't think he's a racist for making those comment, it is enough to support the SPLC association of him with racism, yes? If not, why not?
- furgooswft13 8y agoWhether they wrote "he's a racist" or not they are heavily implying it by associating him with racism, as you just did, and the alt-right. I don't see a meaningful difference, especially given the source. Also I was talking about the quote from GP, in which this association is made on much flimsier and misleading evidence than this incident. The SPLC quote combined a wild extrapolation with a lie of omission that would have completely changed the narrative. As to your question, it seemed to me he was simply using the alt-right's own language against them in an ironic or sarcastic manner, and does not at all want to be associated with them. You could counter that he simply does not like their tactics/behavior but agrees on principal. Personally I'd need to see more evidence (clips of him speaking with relevant context) to come to that conclusion. As I said I could be wrong, I'm not about to subject myself to hours of political ramblings (which seems to be most of his content) to find out, I just like to not assume people are racist hate mongers because a few news sources say so with subjective tidbits. But mostly I wanted to point out that the SPLC is not an honest or trustworthy source.
- eesmith 8y ago
- acqq 8y agoDo you think "Southern Poverty Law Center" has only valid evaluations of who is "racist", i.e. do you think that they can't be wrong? https://friendlyatheist.patheos.com/2018/04/19/the-splc-has-removed-its-controversial-page-listing-anti-muslim-extremists/ https://friendlyatheist.patheos.com/2018/04/19/the-splc-has-... "Ayaan Hirsi Ali" ... "is the Somali-born activist who was a victim of faith-based genital mutilation. Her friend, director Theo van Gogh, was murdered by a Muslim extremist who then stuck a knife in van Gogh’s body with a note that said Hirsi Ali was next. She has since written two memoirs and a book offering ways to reform the faith." She was listed on the Southern Poverty Law Center's "page listing “Anti-Muslim Extremists”." I'm absolutely sure Southern Poverty Law Center was wrong there, similar but even worse than calling Salman Rushdie an anti-Muslim extremist: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ayaan_Hirsi_Ali https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ayaan_Hirsi_Ali
- eesmith 8y agoOf course not. One need not look further than https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Southern_Poverty_Law_Center#Controversies https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Southern_Poverty_Law_Center#Co... to find examples where they were not only wrong, but said they were wrong. Do you only take input from organizations which are perfect?
- acqq 8y agoI don't find relevant the inputs of organizations which exactly in the cases I'm familiar with get it completely wrong. And I invite others to familiarize them with the case and question these too. How SPLC characterized Hirsi Ali is a good example of complete wrongness, enough to discredit their real understanding of the topic they purport to be able to judge.