4 ms·
How is that any different from previous bear markets? I swear I remember reading the same analysis in 1987 after the crash. Human behavior (even human-program
by ajross 8y ago
How is that any different from previous bear markets? I swear I remember reading the same analysis in 1987 after the crash.
Human behavior (even human-programmed behavior) is pro-cyclic. Everyone wants the same stuff and makes the same decisions with the same input. I don't see anything notable about this market cycle as compared with previous ones at all, only the jargon is changing.
- module0000 8y agoIt's not any different other than the speed it happens at. 20 years ago it would have taken minutes/hours for some of the drops we've seen to materialize. Now you can watch the NQ drop 100 points in less than 5 minutes, 20 years ago that would have taken hours, possibly all day. People had to wait on quote services via satellite, telephone calls to their floor traders, or actually be in the pits during the selloffs. Now it only takes us a couple seconds to connect our device of choice to our trading platforms. Market makers stop providing liquidity during these sell-offs much faster than they could 20 years ago.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> 20 years ago it would have taken minutes/hours for some of the drops we've seen to materialize. Twenty years ago was 1998. Ten years before that, Black Monday was faster and more vicious than anything we've seen since. It remains "the largest one-day percentage decline in the DJIA" [1]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_Monday_(1987) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_Monday_(1987)
- module0000 8y agoBlack Monday is the edge case
- jm__87 8y agoNot really sure what your point is. Cycles always happen for the same technical reason - more buyers than sellers lead to rising prices and more sellers than buyers lead to falling prices. Understanding what leads to these imbalances in buying and selling is the more interesting and more difficult part and the details tend to be a bit different for every cycle. Most people find these details interesting and for some people, it is their job to understand these details. The abstract idea that herd behavior is what moves markets is not that useful unless you understand exactly which herds are moving which markets and how they make their buying and selling decisions.
- ctlby 8y ago> more buyers than sellers lead to rising prices and more sellers than buyers lead to falling prices That's not how any of this works. Every share bought is a share sold by some counterparty. Buyers and sellers are always in equilibrium.
- module0000 8y agoThe person you're replying to is telling you the truth - imbalanced delta for buyers or sellers means rising or falling prices. There is no magical equilibrium, and if there was, there would be no profit. To explain it a step further... at this moment in time, every private and institutional investors stopped selling APPL...I can still buy a share, likely thousands of them... from the market participants that are always there: market makers. When you make a "bad call"(like selling into a rally), a market maker is likely on the other end of your trade, and they will profit from your "bad call". Now the inverse also applies, often times a market maker is taking the other end of your trade that is a good(profitable) trade for you. The market maker isn't losing though, they are just playing the odds. They are convicted that for every losing trade they take out of obligation(as a market maker), they are going to take 2 or more winning trades. They also operate with trade costs much lower than you or I(ie retail investors) have access to. That was more reply than I originally intended to write...but you have to understand this(or fail at profitable trading). There is no equilibrium, and there are parties(market makers) ensuring that there never will be. That is their job, to create a state of constant liquidity, even if buyers and/or sellers individually are unwilling to play.
- ctlby 8y ago> There is no magical equilibrium Your understanding is exactly backwards. Market makers provide the "magical equilibrium" by bridging supply and demand across time. > and if there was, there would be no profit. Wrong again. Even with infinite shares on the bid/ask, there's still a spread for market makers to collect. More generally, what exactly do you think your comment proves? If a retail investor buys the sole 100 shares at top-of-book, the price (mid) moves up, but there's one buyer and one seller. Where's the "delta"? And if a big hedge fund buys 100,000 shares from 10 market makers... 100,000 shares demanded and 100,000 shares supplied. Magic! You're arguing against an accounting identity. I know what you're trying to say: what moves prices is relative eagerness of buyers and sellers. You're just too inexperienced to be able to explain it.