4 ms·
I'm a long time jazz bassist. I don't play in NYC -- that's another world that I know little about. But in a mid sized city, I can keep up with anybody playing
by analog31 8y ago
I'm a long time jazz bassist. I don't play in NYC -- that's another world that I know little about. But in a mid sized city, I can keep up with anybody playing standards or written material. I do play with musicians who have paid their dues in the big cities, so I know what they are capable of.
Being able to transpose while sight reading melodic lines or chord charts is pretty rare, and seldom happens. I can play in any key if I know the tune, i.e., most standards, because I've internalized the harmonies. I can make you think that I can transpose because I know more tunes than you'd expect from an amateur. The people who can transpose complicated written lines on the fly are mostly academic classical musicians by day.
But actually, jazz musicians are losing interest in the old game of trying to stump one another on the bandstand. I hold my own when it happens, but it's really not serving the music or the audience, and is something I associate with players who are past their prime. Nobody's forgotten the standards, but the bright young players are doing more with original compositions and arrangements.
- rewgs 8y agoMy experience is mostly in NYC, so I can speak to that. Our experiences sound basically the same, though I can confirm that NYC generally expects a level of proficiency higher than just about anywhere else. Yeah, I am so happy with about the last +/- decade of jazz's development. The crusty OG's yelling "get off the bandstand!" are dying out, and like you said, there's so much more focus on original compositions, and thus actually having rehearsal time (instead of just showing up to a gig and being expected to read everything -- though that's still super common, even with originals, in NYC. That was why I got work: I'm a guitarist who's a good sight-reader) And there's much more support amongst the players (albeit above a certain level of expected proficiency -- you gotta "join the club" still). Overall it's nice to see. Much more positive and supportive while making (IMO) way more interesting and better music, pushing the genre forward rather than wallowing in dick-measuring contests.