4 ms·
Jeez. This article really highlights the abuses on which Amazon (and other similar jobs, think Uber, Foodora or whatever) are built upon: > feigning nonchalanc
by mschuster91 8y ago
Jeez. This article really highlights the abuses on which Amazon (and other similar jobs, think Uber, Foodora or whatever) are built upon:
> feigning nonchalance as I handed a cup of urine to the attendant and bid him good day.
I consider mandatory drug tests a massive invasion of privacy that only persists because workers don't (really) have the ability to shop around employers who don't do them. Besides they're only screening for illegal drugs but don't care about the really dangerous things (a lack of decent sleep being the worst).
> An honest recounting of this job must include my sometimes frantic searches for a place to answer nature’s call.
This is dehumanizing. This could be easily solved by requiring employers to provide e.g. these tiny camping toilets in the van - they don't take up much space (one parcel, maybe), and a "seat" can easily be fitted by rearranging a couple of rack plates without losing storage space.
But the biggest issue is this:
> Before it was taken out of service for repairs, I was often stuck with a ProMaster that had issues: Side-view mirrors spiderwebbed; the left mirror held fast to the body of the van by several layers of shrink-wrap. The headlights didn’t work unless flicked into “bright” mode, which means that when delivering after dark, I was blinding and infuriating oncoming motorists. [...] That’s when I heard a thud-thud-thud from the area of my right front tire, which was so old and bald that it had begun to shed four- and five-inch strips of rubber, which were thumping against the wheel well.
This is illegal and dangerous, both for the driver and for all people, animals and property around them.
All the "cost cutting" of Amazon doing deliveries instead of UPS, Fedex etc. does have to come from somewhere, and here it is done on public safety. I'm fine with competition, but not if public safety and worker/human rights are sacrificed for short-term profits for Jeff Bezos.
And what's the biggest issue: as a consumer, you do not have a choice when it comes to shipping - I'd gladly pay 1€ more a package if that would ensure that the delivery of my parcel is at least not outright exploitation, but Amazon (or any other web shop, food delivery service or whatever) do not offer this option, and are thus limiting the consumer power over where to shop based on moral ground.
- Spooky23 8y agoThis is normal for a lot of the workforce. The poor maintenance, etc, is just evidence of an awful company that doesn’t give a shit. There are many like it. The driver is the only person effectively held responsible for those defects, so awful motor carriers tend to only attract awful or desperate drivers.
- mschuster91 8y ago> This is normal for a lot of the workforce And that's the problem. While we tech workers mostly have the luxury of shopping around employers, sometimes even based on the food in the cafeteria, much of the "lower" levels do not have the free market where both sides are on relatively equal footing. There's always someone desperate enough to put up even with illegal stuff (e.g. unmaintained vehicles), so if a poor(ish) person has the choice between either doing that job or not being able to make rent... This should not be "normal". Especially when laws are being violated. It is also a violation of any free market principle if (big) companies can outright ignore laws that everyone else honestly follows. Hard to compete when the other side operates unfairly. > The driver is the only person effectively held responsible for those defects, so awful motor carriers tend to only attract awful or desperate drivers. In Europe, for the big rigs also the transportation company owning the truck can and will be held liable. This holds true for both driving times related stuff (e.g. when the police can prove that the travel plan cannot be followed without the driver breaking the law) and vehicle safety (blown tires, overloading, rust, broken brakes, ...). Sadly, small trucks and delivery vans are exempted from lots of the rules :/
- dsfyu404ed 8y ago>The poor maintenance, etc, is just evidence of an awful company that doesn’t give a shit. There are many like it. You're confusing "doesn't give a shit" with "our margins are too thin to afford any shit". Most of the "sketchy" landscapers, dumpster/trash companies and dirt haulers near you are in the latter camp. Downtime has a massive opportunity cost. Businesses are not running bald tires because they want to but because if their mechanic staff was four people instead of three that would give them no margin and you need a margin to survive.
- Spooky23 8y agoBusinesses running bald tires are just squeezing whatever pennies they can, out of need or greed. It’s easy to fall into the trap of feeling bad for these companies. Do not. Putting lives in danger to stay solvent means you cannot afford to be in business and need to go away.
- 8y ago
- CydeWeys 8y agoDrug screens for commercial drivers are federally mandated. That requirement doesn't seem to be going anywhere anytime soon (though maybe if marijuana becomes legal nationwide that will no longer be part of the test). Agree with the rest of what you're saying though.
- pageald 8y ago>(though maybe if marijuana becomes legal nationwide that will no longer be part of the test) The test isn't going anywhere until there's a reliable field sobriety for weed. Companies don't want employees operating heavy equipment stoned, and unfortunately there's no way to test that somebody smoked in the last day or two, only that they've smoked in the last X weeks/months, depending on their habits.
- sigstoat 8y ago> unfortunately there's no way to test that somebody smoked in the last day or two, only that they've smoked in the last X weeks/months, depending on their habits. no non-invasive ones, anyways. :( blood test does fine for checking whether you're high at the time of draw.
- bdcravens 8y agoPerhaps the technology will develop that enable finger sticks similar to those diabetes use, or transdermal readings.
- mlevental 8y ago>And what's the biggest issue: as a consumer, you do not have a choice when it comes to shipping - I'd gladly pay 1€ more a package if that would ensure that the delivery of my parcel is at least not outright exploitation, but Amazon (or any other web shop, food delivery service or whatever) do not offer this option, and are thus limiting the consumer power over where to shop based on moral ground. i see this claimed very often by the same people that laud the free market. realize the irony: if ethically sourced good were desired then Amazon would indeed offer this option. in fact they are a luxury good (read: small minority) and so to first approximation you're the only person that wants this.
- zdragnar 8y agoAmazon doesn't give me an option for who ships packages I order from them. It's a fairly round-robin distribution of fedex, ups and usps to where I live out in the sticks. If there was an option to pick your carrier, with say a list like such: * USPS * Fedex * UPS * Amazon Logistics * DHL * Living Wages Carrier Inc I could then direct my money to go towards the companies I favor. That would be a free(er) market, so to speak. There's no irony involved here. Then again, I'd probably just pick UPS anyway, since Amazon doesn't have delivery drivers that come out this way.
- masonic 8y agoYou, knowing these effects, have the option of not buying it on Amazon in the first place
- mschuster91 8y agoNot really, Amazon having crushed many brick-andmortar stores...
- masonic 8y agoYes; now, think carefully exactly how that happened.
- 8y ago
- dsfyu404ed 8y ago>This is illegal and dangerous, both for the driver and for all people, animals and property around them. As someone who has worked as a delivery driver and is far more familiar with the vehicle inspection program in my state (yes, I know it's different for heavy trucks) than someone who has never worked as an automotive mechanic should be I wholly disagree. Vehicle downtime is enough of a PITA that anyone who can avoid it does, especially in a commercial setting. The regulatory compliance stick adds nothing positive you consider the .gov being able to swoop in find some violation over which they can screw any given operator a positive. Whatever handheld electronic device is telling the delivery driver where to turn is a far bigger danger to the public than four bald tires. Drivers who are always in a rush and don't have time to do more than the bare minimum strapping down cargo or route planning are also a major source of accidents and near misses. Mechanical failure is a cause of a negligible fraction of accidents. It's really nothing to be worried about from a safety point of view.
- magduf 8y agoI think it's also telling that many (most?) states do not have vehicle inspections. Are the accident rates any higher in states that don't than in states that do? I don't think so.
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoThis is exactly what I wanted to say but wasn't going to put so bluntly. For private vehicles inspections are just a money wasting government program to make the government feel good about how much it's protecting people while not actually protecting people much per dollar. For commercial vehicles I think the situation is not so cut and clear but I think we could do with less inspections and more roadside enforcement.
- magduf 8y agoI agree completely. For private vehicles, there's just no evidence showing that these inspection programs improve safety at all; almost all private-vehicle accidents are caused by driver error, after all, since we as a nation absolutely refuse to require any kind of real driver training, and also refuse to enforce any real driving skills, and only focus on "speeding". Commercial vehicles are a little different I think, since 1) the drivers actually are skilled for the most part (far better than private vehicle drivers at any rate), and 2) they get a lot more use, and so have more maintenance issues. Retread tires, for instance, are a big issue with them, and really should be banned as they are in other countries. They can cause the truck with them to crash, and they can also cause other vehicles to crash by being a road hazard.