3 ms·
> Bach's music does not feel like a work of genius Speak for yourself. > Mozart and Beethoven Both geniuses, for sure. But they didn't create the styles they
by gjm11 8y ago
> Bach's music does not feel like a work of genius
Speak for yourself.
> Mozart and Beethoven
Both geniuses, for sure. But they didn't create the styles they composed in any more than Bach did.
There was _classical_ music (in the sense in which Mozart is "classical" and Bach and Brahms aren't) before Mozart. Some of it was written by Bach's sons, in fact.
There was quite Beethoven-like music written before Beethoven -- most notably by Haydn, who to my ears is much more Beethoven-like than Mozart is.
None of that detracts from the greatness of Mozart and Beethoven -- or of Bach. Artists don't exist in isolation, even if they're geniuses.
- j7ake 8y agoThe size of Beethoven’s concertos and symphonies are so much bigger than any that Haydn wrote that I find it difficult to have Haydn sound anything like Beethoven .
- radicality 8y agoI think when the parent said 'does not feel like a work of a genius', he was saying that it's 'non-human, god-like (typo?)'. The parent likely meant it's above genius which can only be human.