8 ms·
Mom Lets Her Kids Walk to the Bakery Down the Block. CPS Chastises Her
- rayiner 8y agoThat nosey neighbor should be tarred and feathered.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- dang 8y agoPlease don't do this here.
- quaunaut 8y agoIt's worth noting, this is in Canada. Laws are different everywhere. I know that in most of the US, CPS will not come out for a single complaint, not ever. It has to be multiple, repeated complaints, and the vast majority of the time, it needs to be more than a kid walking down the street- generally, CPS has more than enough real child abuse cases to deal with that they don't have time to pick up the odd stuff. Not saying this didn't happen, but that a localized context matters to these things.
- rayiner 8y agoThat’s not true. In Montgomery County MD recently there was a case where parents got in trouble for letting their kids (like 5 and 7) walk to school less than a mile. (One reason we don’t live in Montgomery County.)
- zdragnar 8y agoI don't know which most of the US you're describing; if anything they err on the side of over-investigative around here.
- kardianos 8y agoThis is not true in the US.
- jnbiche 8y agoThis is not true. CPS comes out all the time for ridiculous things like 8-year-olds walking alone in a neighborhood (first time). Read any parenting blog. We really need a law like Utah's in every state.
- seattle_spring 8y ago> We really need a law like Utah's in every state. That's a phrase I thought I'd never read. Utah has some of the most outrageous nanny state laws, worse than stuff I could even dream up.
- jnbiche 8y ago> Utah has some of the most outrageous nanny state laws That may be so, but it's irrelevant to the fact that this particular law is both wise and greatly needed.
- usaphp 8y agoIt is kind of dangerous for a 3 year old to go, 3 year olds like to run especially when they are with siblings, and they can easily end up running on a road, and then someone who hit them on a car will have to live their whole life with that tragedy...
- 21 8y agoMaybe, but according to the article until they are 12 it's not legal. In some countries, you need to drive you kid to school until they are 14.
- ksdale 8y agoAccording the article it does not say it’s illegal, it says you have to make reasonable provisions for their supervision and safety if they’re unattended. That strongly implies that it is ok under certain circumstances to let children under 12 do things alone, else it would just say that it’s illegal to leave children under 12 unattended, period. I think a lot of people would argue that watching the kids until they’re practically in the door of the bakery constitutes a reasonable provision of safety and supervision.
- chrisseaton 8y ago> you need to drive you kid to school until they are 14 As in you aren't even allowed to walk with them to school, you have to drive them in a car? Why's that?
- rayiner 8y agoMy 3 year old never ran into the road, and as a six year old she would keep a tight leash on her little brother if he ever tried to do that. I’d for sure let them walk down a residential street by themselves.
- usaphp 8y agoSure, in a calm environment. But when kids start having fun together - they lose control of the boundaries and can inadvertently run on the road without even noticing it.
- bradenb 8y agoI wonder how we got to this. I'm all for parents being protective over children that aren't theirs, but when did we develop the entitlement that we should police the parents of other children? Obligatory "When I grew up...": When I grew up (I'm 32), there were still murderers, kidnappers, drug dealers, gangs, etc. My parents and the parents of all my friends let us roam free from the minute we finished our chores until dark. They often let us decide for ourselves how we wanted to get our lunch, dinner, snacks, etc. We could choose our own transportation, our own paths. I treasured that freedom. What's crazy is that it's my same generation of parents that now seem to be doing the policing. I had "heard" of this happening around me, but I was still dumbfounded when it first happened to me. One Summer, my 6 year old was playing in the front yard. My wife was sitting inside on the couch in front of the window so she could keep an eye on her when suddenly the neighbor walks up to my daughter, grabs her hand and brings her to the front door. "Did you know your daughter was playing outside alone?" in a very accusatory tone. This isn't a call to CPS, but it still made us feel both angry and ashamed. As a Utah resident, one thing I'm happy to see is the new "Free Range Parenting" law [1]. I still think it's crazy that it was needed, but I think in today's parenting culture it really, really is. [1] https://abcnews.go.com/GMA/Family/utahs-free-range-parenting-law-now-officially-effect/story?id=55021088 https://abcnews.go.com/GMA/Family/utahs-free-range-parenting...
- bittermang 8y agoJust as a counter to your anecdote. I'm 35. My mother wouldn't let me so much as cross the street. I live in a small rural town with little to no crime.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- icelancer 8y agoGreater access to television and the evening news ritual did us in. Watching constant daily reports on murders and robberies in your city tends to cause people to think that the sky is falling, when of course, crime has been collapsing since the 1990s. [0] In fairness to the current generation of parents in their late 30s to early 50s, violent crime spiked dramatically in the 1990s and has only recently returned to 1960s levels, and people cement their worldviews in their teenage / early 20s and rarely change their minds afterwards. So as faulty of a process as their reasoning is, they did grow up in a generation of the most violent crime our nation has dealt with in recent history; add that to the media frenzy (and that weird obsession / fear of satanism in the late 90s too) and you get a generation of overprotective parents. [0]: https://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2017/dec/04/jeff-sessions/violent-crime-some-still-well-historical-highs/ https://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2017/dec...
- sys_64738 8y agoThe busy body who was "following closely behind them" sounds like she could have been a kidnapper. The parent should have called the police on that person.
- raverbashing 8y agoYeah, maybe they should consider legal action against this person as well. (Not surprising this is Canada t.b.h. this is the country where it seems people can't follow common sense in place of procedures and where people are too worried about anything that "might be dangerous") And of course kids die because of such stupidity https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/ottawa/ontario-mom-urges-schools-to-let-asthmatic-kids-carry-puffers-1.2455861 https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/ottawa/ontario-mom-urges-scho...
- otoburb 8y agoThe Ontario law preventing children from carrying and administering their own medication was changed in 2015[1]. [1] https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/ontario-law-passes-to-let-asthmatic-kids-carry-inhalers-in-school-1.3055534 https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/ontario-law-passes-to...
- raverbashing 8y agoGood to know, still it's sad that this was an completely preventable death
- petermcneeley 8y agoYou can see the social erosion when you compare to a more coherent society like say japan. https://www.citylab.com/transportation/2015/09/why-are-little-kids-in-japan-so-independent/407590/ https://www.citylab.com/transportation/2015/09/why-are-littl...
- icelancer 8y agoThese posts rarely point out incredibly strict immigration policies and the stark racial makeup of the countries that rely on group dynamics for rather inconvenient reasons. When you have a largely homogenous population that has been stable over decades - centuries in the case of Japan - then these types of relationships evolve.
- ilikehurdles 8y agoIt has nothing to do with immigration. I was out walking to school, going to the bakery, sledding, etc with friends in Germany throughout the 90s from like age 6.
- usaphp 8y agoHey, I was at a war and did not get injured, now I am totally sure no one ever gets injured on wars, because I was not injured! Hey I drive my car for 30 years without a seatbelt and was never injured, it surely means that seatbelts are useless and you can’t really get injured in a car, so why even bother with protection?
- ilikehurdles 8y ago> Hey, there's this deep issue that involves comparing how several vastly different nations with complex histories approach a problem. Let's take a shortcut and blame everything bad on race and immigration, because that's what we've been doing for hundreds of years and why should we stop now!
- icelancer 8y ago
- ams6110 8y agoI biked all over my Midwest USA neighborhood, to and from school, and beyond from the time I was about 8, maybe even younger. This was in the 1970s. It would have been unthinkable for anyone to be overly worried about it, much less report it to the authorities, because that's what almost all the kids did.
- sverige 8y agoNot only did we go all over our little town by ourselves, if we did something we weren't supposed to be doing, someone would call our parents. Not the cops, not CPS, our parents -- which was far worse.
- usaphp 8y agoThe kid in article was 3 years old. There is a big difference between a 3 year old kid and an 8 year old.
- ibash 8y agoThe kid in the article was with their 7 year old sibling and within sight of their parent.
- Reedx 8y agoFor anyone curious in an in-depth look at how we got here and the unintended consequences, check out Jonathan Haidt's book "The Coddling of the American Mind: How Good Intentions and Bad Ideas Are Setting Up a Generation for Failure". This gets into what happens when these kids leave home and no longer have parents bulldozing their path. Here's a short talk from the same author about how overparenting backfired: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2aMAJYtRPPM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2aMAJYtRPPM "In the mid-'90s there was a sharp shift to overprotective parenting. In previous generations, kids were allowed to out of the house unsupervised from age 5-8, which has now become age 12-16. As a result, their independence, resilience, and problem-solving skills suffer."
- CorvusCrypto 8y agoThis is kind of a grey area it seems. Manitoba IS one province that specifies a legal minimum age of supervision (12) but it applies only to being left at home or in a car (edit: I was wrong about these specifics. They leave it more generalized in the actual law) and is still left with a clause about "unless reasonable situations exist". Meanwhile the age to allow kids to walk to school, while unofficial and no limit exists across canafa, seems to be 9 years by majority opinion agreements. Sounds like this social worker stepped out of bounds. If Canadian government is by and large okay with kids walking to school themselves at 9, surely walking a block with a 9 year old is reasonable enough. It's clear the parent was still aware of where they were so I'd say it's an arguable case, but IANAL. Tbh I don't know if this is just one isolated case, but it kinda sounds like it. Edit: here is the law and I linked the subsection that is relevant. It more clearly states what I paraphrased above. https://web2.gov.mb.ca/laws/statutes/ccsm/c080e.php#17(2) https://web2.gov.mb.ca/laws/statutes/ccsm/c080e.php#17(2)
- upofadown 8y agoThis was a pretty big story at the time here in Winnipeg. The context is that CPS has a bad rep here. Note that they took a whole month even to follow up on the complaint.
- eftychis 8y agoTwo comments: i) The term reasonable, I wishfully think, covers this particular incident. I don't think the average family in Canada worries about kidnappings, robberies etc. ii) How are you expecting kids to grow, and what is the lesson, if you are the watchful un-trusting guardian for even simple tasks for a big fraction of their non-adult life? (P.S. I remember everyone walked back from elementary school, we ran errands for our parents, ... Any different experience?)
- toofy 8y agoDo we have any studies done yet which show whether or not this is a growing trend or just random isolated incidents in countries with millions and millions of families containing children? In my region and places I travel I see children walking around everywhere and there don’t seem to be armies of CPS workers stalking them. I guess I’m just wondering if this is an actual trend or just more outrage_porn attempting to get people riled up about how the millennials are killing childhood or whatever.
- dorchadas 8y agoIt's odd, as I see it where I live, but not my hometown. The funny thing is, I live in a bigger town (~70,000) than my hometown (~3,000) is. The children of our neighborhood there (a set of four streets) all are out all the time during the summer, often unsupervised and with younger siblings. They'll play up and down the streets, and talk to anyone they see walking and wave and such. They're very street aware too. It's actually nice to see, as my hometown is not like that at all. Parents often won't even let their kids go to the park playground while watching an older (and sometimes younger!) sibling play ball. That's despite the fact there's other parents over there, and it's fairly small so everyone really does seem to know everyone. A family friend has gotten criticized for letting their kids walk from their house to their grandparents, which wasn't even a mile on back roads. They also let their son ride his bike to the park often (2 miles, perhaps), and got criticized for that. It's really weird to see the contrast in the two places.
- oftenwrong 8y agoIf you are curious about the Utah law mentioned, you can find it at https://le.utah.gov/~2018/bills/static/SB0065.html https://le.utah.gov/~2018/bills/static/SB0065.html The definition of "Neglect" it uses: >285 (35) (a) "Neglect" means action or inaction causing: >286 (i) abandonment of a child, except as provided in Title 62A, Chapter 4a, Part 8, Safe >287 Relinquishment of a Newborn Child; >288 (ii) lack of proper parental care of a child by reason of the fault or habits of the parent, >289 guardian, or custodian; >290 (iii) failure or refusal of a parent, guardian, or custodian to provide proper or necessary >291 subsistence, education, or medical care, or any other care necessary for the child's health, >292 safety, morals, or well-being; >293 (iv) a child to be at risk of being neglected or abused because another child in the same >294 home is neglected or abused; or >295 (v) abandonment of a child through an unregulated custody transfer. >296 (b) The aspect of neglect relating to education, described in Subsection (35)(a)(iii), >297 means that, after receiving a notice of compulsory education violation under Section >298 53A-11-101.5, the parent or guardian fails to make a good faith effort to ensure that the child >299 receives an appropriate education. >... >309 (c) "Neglect" does not include: >310 (i) a parent or guardian legitimately practicing religious beliefs and who, for that >311 reason, does not provide specified medical treatment for a child; >312 (ii) a health care decision made for a child by the child's parent or guardian, unless the >313 state or other party to a proceeding shows, by clear and convincing evidence, that the health >314 care decision is not reasonable and informed; >315 (iii) a parent or guardian exercising the right described in Section 78A-6-301.5; or >316 (iv) permitting a child, whose basic needs are met and who is of sufficient age and >317 maturity to avoid harm or unreasonable risk of harm, to engage in independent activities, >318 including: >319 (A) traveling to and from school, including by walking, running, or bicycling; >320 (B) traveling to and from nearby commercial or recreational facilities; >321 (C) engaging in outdoor play; >322 (D) remaining in a vehicle unattended, except under the conditions described in >323 Subsection 76-10-2202(2); >324 (E) remaining at home unattended; or >325 (F) engaging in a similar independent activity.
- marcuskaufmann 8y agoAs a German I can't stop laughing about this. It's hilarious to me. If you are curious then see for example the following videos of an New Zealand living in Germany talking about differences in parenting. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vLWFHlPF_g8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vLWFHlPF_g8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0EpRFqWlVl4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0EpRFqWlVl4
- ashelmire 8y agoI biked around my neighborhood as young as 7, to the store a few blocks away, without any problems or hyperconcerned adults around. And the crime rates were higher at the time...
- Overtonwindow 8y agoAt five and six years old I was running around in the woods, playing far from home. In my opinion we’ve allowed the government to dictate how we are to raise and protect our children. The only way to solve this is to continually push to remove the government’s authority To dictate how parents should raise their children.
- Markoff 8y agofor all people saying what they were doing when they were young while crime rate was higher - was also the traffic higher or lower? it's rhetorical question, I have zero worries about kidnappings and other reasons regarding my children but when i see how are people driving and how big it's the traffic i am worried at what age i will let my children walk by themselves i was actually thinking about letting my 3yo go to kindergarten by himself as teaching him independence since it's like 100m walk, but there is one road to cross and most importantly he is too weak to open door on both buildings, will see if he will be stronger by age 5-6 :)