3 ms·
1. Universality of transposition: These conventions apply wherever people use western instruments. 2. Alto sax is always in the key of E flat. That means the
by tomcam 8y ago
1. Universality of transposition: These conventions apply wherever people use western instruments.
2. Alto sax is always in the key of E flat. That means the note called A flat played by an alto sax would be C on the piano. Likewise tenor is always in the key of B flat. A huge advantage to this arrangement is that the fingering is the same no matter which instrument you are playing; that means it is up to the composer to transpose notes as appropriate. The saxophone family is amazingly cohesive and consistent because Adolphe Sax invented it in one fell swoop.
3. Well-trained classical musicians can transpose at will. I read a story by the composer/pianist Andre Previn whose touring orchestra was late to a concert hall due to the bus driver getting lost. He was playing the piano in a concerto. What he didn’t know was that the entire piano had detuned up half a step. It meant that The moment he sat down to play a concerto in C minor he was therefore playing in C sharp minor. The orchestra caught this immediately and everyone transposed up for the rest of the concert – on the fly.
Edit: I mysteriously screwed up keys of alto and tenor sax, both of which I play. Idiocy caught by klez and duly corrected.
- klez 8y ago> Alto sax is always in the key of A flat. That means the note called A flat played by an alto sax would be C on the piano. Likewise tenor is always in the key of E flat. Uh? Alto sax is in Eb and tenor is in Bb.
- tomcam 8y agoThanks for the correction. I play sax. You are right of course. WTF is wrong with me?
- toolslive 8y ago2. same fingering... So the C written conveys more a fingering than a pitch and the actual pitch depends on the instrument at hand. 3. Lovely anecdote, but wasn't it simpler if the pianist transposed ?
- njonsson 8y agoSimpler, yes, in the sense that just one instrument (the soloist) would have to play notes they were not prepared to play. But a concerto (typically a long piece for one or more solo instruments accompanied by orchestra) showcases the solo instrument, both by exposing it and by demanding much from the soloist’s technique and interpretive powers. It’s a shorter order for the orchestra to adapt than for the soloist to do so.
- yesenadam 8y agoAlto sax is always in the key of E flat. That means the note called A flat played by an alto sax would be C on the piano. This corrected version still isn't right...
- rewgs 8y agoYeah, that's a pretty confusing way of saying that, regardless of the key, the Alto reads a major 6th above concert.
- yesenadam 8y agoIt may be confusing, but mainly it's wrong. I find yours a very confusing way of saying it. Hard to parse. As a way of explaining to someone who didn't already know it would be useless, I imagine. The point[0] is: Instruments in Bb: They play what they call a "C" and it's actually a Bb. To produce a C they have to play a "D". Instruments in Eb: They play what they call a "C" and it's actually an Eb. To produce a C they have to play an "A". [0] I only bother writing this because the wrong thing has been written on this page a few times, and not corrected so far.