3 ms·
The concept that artist should come up with new ideas and create something new is narrow. Seeking perfection in somee restricted style and going deeper instead
by nabla9 8y ago
The concept that artist should come up with new ideas and create something new is narrow. Seeking perfection in somee restricted style and going deeper instead of different is also creativity.
The way I see Bach is that he mastered, refined and perfected the style. People who came afterwards had no choice but do something different. Others are climbing different peaks because Bach stands at the top of Mt. Baroque.
Mozart and Beethoven are geniuses. They started something that has been never perfected. Bach's music does not feel like a work of genius, it feels goodlike and nonhuman.
- zozbot123 8y ago> The concept that artist should come up with new ideas and create something new is narrow. Seeking perfection in somee restricted style and going deeper instead of different is also creativity. Very true. Indeed, all of these most creative, "genius" composers were very much standing on the shoulders of giants: Bach draws plenty from e.g. Corelli, A.Scarlatti and Vivaldi, while Mozart, Haydn (why forget him?) and Beethoven were in turn perfecting the "modern" style that much music of the 18th century had been written in throughout Europe.
- bane 8y ago"Now there is music from which a man can learn something." - W. A. Mozart (on hearing Bach motets in Leipzig)
- PavlovsCat 8y ago> The concept that artist should come up with new ideas and create something new is narrow. I think it can even be stifling. > The ceaseless, senseless demand for original scholarship in a number of fields, where only erudition is now possible, has led either to sheer irrelevancy, the famous knowing of more and more about less and less, or to the development of a pseudo-scholarship which actually destroys its object. -- Hannah Arendt I guess it's different for different people, but I find myself agreeing with these two things I came across recently: Stephen King: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l8TkQvdJVbc&t=7m05s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l8TkQvdJVbc&t=7m05s Chad VanGaalen: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t4z2wSMp81Y&t=9m40s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t4z2wSMp81Y&t=9m40s Like, just do it... pursue what you find interesting, follow your inner voice. If you want to do something that's been done, but you haven't done it, do it! Maybe it will lead you to something original even, and if not, so what. That's not advice, but it does work for me, so if anyone feels like it works for them, I would "advise" them to not be put off by people telling them they're wrong with some kind of formula.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- gjm11 8y ago> Bach's music does not feel like a work of genius Speak for yourself. > Mozart and Beethoven Both geniuses, for sure. But they didn't create the styles they composed in any more than Bach did. There was _classical_ music (in the sense in which Mozart is "classical" and Bach and Brahms aren't) before Mozart. Some of it was written by Bach's sons, in fact. There was quite Beethoven-like music written before Beethoven -- most notably by Haydn, who to my ears is much more Beethoven-like than Mozart is. None of that detracts from the greatness of Mozart and Beethoven -- or of Bach. Artists don't exist in isolation, even if they're geniuses.
- j7ake 8y agoThe size of Beethoven’s concertos and symphonies are so much bigger than any that Haydn wrote that I find it difficult to have Haydn sound anything like Beethoven .
- radicality 8y agoI think when the parent said 'does not feel like a work of a genius', he was saying that it's 'non-human, god-like (typo?)'. The parent likely meant it's above genius which can only be human.