3 ms·
How is an upgraded GPS satellite a “national security” mission? Yes, I understand that precise and reliable global navigation is essential to fighting wars and
by sneak 8y ago
How is an upgraded GPS satellite a “national security” mission?
Yes, I understand that precise and reliable global navigation is essential to fighting wars and guided weapons, but such uses pale in comparison to the billions of people who rely on GPS every day to do non-war, non-USA stuff. It is neither national nor security.
Or do they just mean “in the role of defense contractor”?
- xrayzerone 8y agoWhat are you talking about? US-launched GPS satellites are owned and operated by the USAF, which last I checked, is a national security outfit.
- dang 8y agoPlease drop acerbic swipes like "What are you talking about?" from your comments here. Your comment would be much better with just the second sentence. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- briandear 8y agoThe reason GPS came to exist is because of the US military. That billions use it now for other purposes is a happy side effect. Also it is very much “national” as the US taxpayer pays for the GPS system billions of people use for their non-war, non-USA stuff. And it’s definitely security because if that GPS system were to go down, there’s be a serious and immediate economic effect. Protecting and improving GPS is every bit “national security” as building a tank. National security is more than just waging war; it’s the promotion of stability both political and economic across the world.
- peter303 8y agoMy neice once missed work when her phone broke and she hadnt learned they way there. I imagine there would be thousands if not millions in a similar situation should GPS go down.
- Phlarp 8y agoGPS is lofted and maintained by the DoD. It's primary purpose is military. It would not exist as a free service without DoD's investment. Other satellite constellations with far fewer sats cost considerable amounts of money to use, and few of our modern applications for GPS would be very appealing at $xxx a month. Civillian GPS is a generous charity from US taxpayers to the rest of the world
- sneak 8y agoNo, its primary purpose is civilian. Its original and occasional purpose is military, sure, but as I mentioned, it is used far more widely now, by several orders of magnitude. Its military applications are so eclipsed now by non-war-related uses that the military origins are practically irrelevant.
- Phlarp 8y agoCivilian use is wide yes, but this is only because it is provided for free by DoD. None of those uses would be economically viable if they had to bear the costs of developing, launching and maintaining the system. Keeping track of the boats and missiles pays the bills. Everything else is just a happy accident of zero marginal use cost.
- sneak 8y agoIt’s not provided for free by DoD. We pay for it with taxes. Civilians do indeed bear the cost in full. I am not sure I understand where you are going with this. Doing war stuff with GPS does not generate any revenue. It costs American citizens the same amount of dollars regardless of whether it is used for war or not. It’s not national, and it’s not security.
- Phlarp 8y agoMost of the world does not pay US taxes, it's completely free to them. At this point I just assume you are trolling.