3 ms·
Li-Ion is hard to beat now in places where strong discharge occurs every day, but even a more pricey cell with lower self-discharge rate and longer life might b
by squarefoot 8y ago
Li-Ion is hard to beat now in places where strong discharge occurs every day, but even a more pricey cell with lower self-discharge rate and longer life might be at the end of the day more economically feasible than Li-Ion in some areas since the guy climbing up 100 sensor poles to swap exhausted cells will likely cost more than the different technology.
When doable I recover working cells from old laptop battery packs, to use them in non critical applications with protected chargers (laptop cells rely on the pack circuitry for protection).
Last year I recovered all cells from two new packs that failed to charge because of a failure of the old laptop I bought them for. So I recovered all cells, put them in my charger at a slow 500mA charge (don't use fast charge if not needed, it shortens the cell life) and did a few cycles to test their capacity which was fine. Then I put them in their safety bag and pretty much forgot about them because I was reorganizing my lab. A few weeks back I saw the safety bag and recalled about the cells, so I put them in the charger and tested them: about half of them were dead and all attempts to recover them failed. Of the remaining half some were dangerously close to excessive self discharge but still recoverable and the remaining ones were still fine. In the end all working ones were recovered, but I lost about half of the cells I had; one year of storage albeit in proper environment, no excessive temperature and no load, was enough to kill essentially new cells.
Had rechargeable Li-Ion a shelf life comparable to primary Li-Ion cells, it would make them suitable for almost every use, but as of today they sadly aren't even close to that.