2 ms·
So, essentially, "Look at that skirt! She was asking for it!" Horrible actions don't become less horrible just because you can come up with a facile excuse for
by chc 16y ago
So, essentially, "Look at that skirt! She was asking for it!"
Horrible actions don't become less horrible just because you can come up with a facile excuse for them. $1.5M does not seem like a reasonable penalty, even if she isn't very likable and clearly was not in the right.
- GHFigs 16y agoSo, essentially, "Look at that skirt! She was asking for it!" That isn't even remotely the argument that was made in the comment you're replying to.
- chc 16y agoI think "She brought this on herself" is pretty close to "She was asking for it." And most of the facts in the comment go not toward the severity of the crime she was convicted of nor necessity of such a severe response, but merely toward showing that her behavior was provocative and that she failed to take many precautions.
- awa 16y agoShe was actually violating a law and hence your quote doesn't make any sense (Apart from adding sensationalism) in this story.
- chc 16y agoMy point is that many people violate laws every day without receiving such an absurd punishment. The fact that somebody violated a law does not give society — much less the recording industry — a right to do whatever it wants with them.
- darklajid 16y agoI'm with you on that "that's an interesting argument" train of thought, but you ruin the argument if you pull it down to this level. Most people react _very_ emotional (and - for the most part - this is probably a really good thing) if you bring in arguments about sexual abuse (bonus points for minors). Let's try to stop these comparisons. They are kind of like Godwin's law, killing the discussion in the process. In fact - did already someone name this fact before? Can I claim? ;)
- chc 16y agoThat's a good point. I hadn't intended for the argument to have such a strong emotional overtone. It just occurred to me as a known-to-be-invalid argument that the comment resembled very closely. I'll keep your law in mind from now on.