4 ms·
> Author: Michael Shellenberger That is already telling. A registered lobbyist... The two claims he makes: 1. PV modules are made of Cadmium Cadmium cells m
by baybal2 8y ago
> Author: Michael Shellenberger
That is already telling. A registered lobbyist...
The two claims he makes:
1. PV modules are made of Cadmium
Cadmium cells make less than 1% of the market, and they are a failed, dying technology. CdTe cells were made in hopes of making cells cheaper by not using a "microchip grade" silicon, but the people behind the startup making them were completely wrong about economics of the process — the truth is completely the opposite. It is silicon cells' process commonality with the rest of semiconductor industry that makes them so cheap.
Hey, but thanks to those joke dudes called "venture capitalists" for spinning them up.
2. PV modules are made of Arsenic
No, only first generation of cells made in electronic fabs were made with Arsenic as N dopant.
No commercial process ever used it. PV cells are N doped with Phosphorus exactly for the reason that it is non-toxic, and because Phosphorus is simply better as a bulk dopant. It is much faster diffusing, and requires lower temperatures for dopant activation.
- MrBuddyCasino 8y agoGuy is a pro-nuclear activist: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_Shellenberger#Position_on_renewable_energy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_Shellenberger#Position... Doesn’t mean he is a sellout, but certainly not neutral.
- ThomPete 8y agoAnd neither a lobbyist unless that definition has lost all meaning.
- starbeast 8y agoWell, he has started several lobbying companies and been a lobbyist for a number of paying clients, so I think that the meaning of the word 'lobbyist' is still safe.
- ThomPete 8y agoCan you name some of his current clients that have interest in making solar sound bad?
- starbeast 8y agoI only just found out about him. Was only looking him up because you said that anyone who did could see he wasn't a lobbyist. Found out he was a lobbyist. Can you tell me his current client list, since you know so much about him? Then I will go and check it. Twice.
- ThomPete 8y agoI didn't say he wasn't a lobbyist I said he wasn't a lobbyist the way it was being used originally in this thread. You are being disingenuous now. You can simply google Michael shellenberger and you won't get lobbyist as the first thing. Here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7-7DIv3AU1o https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7-7DIv3AU1o If you are actually interested which I am sure you aren't actually.
- GuB-42 8y agoBoth nuclear and solar are good energy sources with almost opposite characteristics. Solar is good for small scale and it is highly variable. Nuclear works better on a large scale and is very stable. Is there a way to make them coexist in a way that doesn't need fossil fuel and where both technology are used to their advantage?
- pfdietz 8y agoThey actually don't coexist very well. That's because they are both inflexible, although in different ways, and the grid has a limited "inflexibility budget". Nuclear depends on being able to sell power most of the time in order to make enough money to amortize its large capital and fixed operating costs. But solar chews this up, destroying the market a good chunk of the time (longer if some short term storage is added). Even if solar (or solar+wind) are not covering demand all the time, they will be able to crash the price often enough to destroy nuclear's business case.
- GuB-42 8y agoSo basically, unless you have enough spots for hydro, you need fossil fuel to cover renewables. That's German policy. Lots of renewables backed by coal. No more investment into nuclear. I know there are some countries that burn trash and plants quite successfully but I'm not sure it can be done world scale. There are some outliers like geothermal, tidal forces, battery storage but these are even smaller scale examples.
- dwaltrip 8y agoWhy is this comment so far down the page? Is it factually wrong some way?
- ThomPete 8y agoHe is running for governor and a democrat btw. He used to be against nuclear until he actually did the effort of understanding the facts and came out for it. This made him persona-non-grata by the environmentalists. So if you want to talk about lobbyism... But thanks for proving the point. Claiming he is a lobbyist anymore than you are is exactly the kind of shaming tactics that are being used instead of arguments to silence people the majority don't wan't to hear..
- baybal2 8y agoI'm not a registered lobbyist.
- ThomPete 8y agoregistered or not is hardly the point. Using it as an argument against him is absurd.
- baybal2 8y agoUsing that argument is not absurd. You do not have to register as a lobbyist to lobby on behalf of yourself, but you do if you do so on behalf of somebody else, moreover do so for money (in USA, and many other countries.)
- pfdietz 8y agoI see Shellenberger is still claiming there that PV uses rare earth elements. What a baldfaced lie.
- macawfish 8y agoI'm actually a little repulsed that it took me so long to find your informed and concise rebuttal here. So this piece is a hit piece filled with blatant misinformation, on an investment news website.