2 ms·
Personally I think that if organized labor is to have a chance to be remotely successful in Software engineering it needs to break away from the old assumptions
by Nasrudith 8y ago
Personally I think that if organized labor is to have a chance to be remotely successful in Software engineering it needs to break away from the old assumptions that don't hold any more including commoditization. They might have some luck if they established sufficient ground floors (limiting crunch time and death marches, setting rules for what they can be expected to be required for late changes - bonuses for rushes being fine, etc.) instead of uniformity.
I am not familiar with the fine details of labor but I suspect the Screen Actors Guild would be a better fit as a template. The actors are anywhere from minor extras to superstars.
- briandear 8y agoTotally agree. While I am traditionally anti-union (I have seen too many rubber-room situations and ridiculousness,) SAG or the WGA are actually good models for software engineers. It recognizes minimums, but doesn’t have maximums and “merit” is determined by whatever the market is willing to pay. So a superstar first time writer can make millions of their script warrants it, while journeyman script re-writes are assured getting paid scale. The teachers unions are exactly the opposite: you get more pay for seniority and the implication is that seniority necessarily means “more valuable” when that isn’t necessarily the case. Although I am economically very far right, I could get behind a WGA model for software devs. I would be happy to join such an organization. But a teachers union style union.. no way.