7 ms·
Americans Don’t Understand How Bad Climate Change Is or What They Can Do
- NPMaxwell 8y agoThis article, given the option of describing temperature increases as from "3 degrees to 7 degrees F", chooses to report them as "1.5 to 4 degrees C". It's as if the thinking is, "Yeah, Fahrenheit makes these numbers look bigger and almost every American is thinking about the heat on a hot summer day in Fahrenheit, and would love to avoid adding another 7 degrees to a 100-degree day, but ..."
- foobar1962 8y ago> This article, given the option of describing temperature increases as ... "degrees F", chooses to report them as... "degrees C". Could it be because every other civilised country on the planet uses the metric system and wouldn't know wtf 3-7 degrees F is? > almost every American is thinking about the heat on a hot summer day in Fahrenheit Which sounds worse: going from 36C to 40C or 97F to 104?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- NPMaxwell 8y agoI hadn't considered that the point of this article was to communicate outside of the U.S. Sure. For the rest of the English-Speaking world, use Centigrade. For the U.S. market, Farhenheit works better. At first look to an American, 104 is SEVEN greater than 97; 40 is only four bigger than 36; 36 is slightly over freezing; and 40 is noticeably more comfortable. You might think that Americans are going to think about ratios and worry that 40/36 might be greater than 104/97, but 1) calculating ratios like that is not a common U.S. thing, and 2) by using an arbitrary end point, Farhenheit discourages applying ratios to temperatures. On second look, for an American, those numbers should not be attended to at all, because they are shrouded in the ambiguity of what you will get after you do the math. About half of Americans can't do multi-step math even with pencil and paper (according to the National Adult Literacy Survey of the National Center for Educational Statistics in the U.S. government). There is nothing misleading in translating to to Fahrenheit. Why sacrifice rhetorical advantage by trying to make Americans more "civilised"? (Mind you, on that front we're already doomed, spelling it "civilized".) What this brings up is endowing Huffpost with automated localization.
- foobar1962 8y ago> I hadn't considered that the point of this article was to communicate outside of the U.S. Sure. For the rest of the English-Speaking world, use Centigrade. The article started with “Americans” and not “We” so I assumed it was written for an international audience. I think the general theme of the article is pretty global and not just applicable to Americans. I can see the same thing happening here in Australia. A small temperature change won’t have much affect on anything, really, except where it does. Those places will be where the temperatures hover around freezing point of water (in whatever units you choose). Regions that usually have mild frost or snow in winter won’t get that any more. That will have a huge change on the flora and fauna. Plant species that cannot tolerate frost will invade and displace the natives. In Australia the warming effect is being felt already by wine growers. Regions previously too cold for grapes are being converted to vineyards. Regions currently growing cold-climate grapes are being replanted to warmer climate varieties.
- pmiller2 8y agoWhat can one individual do when 25 corporations worldwide are responsible for 51% of carbon emissions, and 100 corporate entities are responsible for 71% of emissions? [0] —- [0]: https://www.sciencealert.com/these-100-companies-are-to-blame-for-71-of-the-world-s-greenhouse-gas-emissions https://www.sciencealert.com/these-100-companies-are-to-blam...
- ReptileMan 8y agoThose corporations have owners, stockholders and customers. The problem is that climate change requires substantial sacrifice from everone. And everyone tries to twist things in such way that the others will do the sacrificing.
- alacombe 8y agoSubstancial == lowering your live style to the level of Bangladesh, if you want a to be sustainable, that is.
- adrianN 8y agoOr, if you live in the US, you could lower your lifestyle to European, say an UK citizen. That would cut your CO2 footprint more than in half and buy some precious years to roll out more sustainable technology.
- closeparen 8y agoLive a non-car-oriented lifestyle in a city, show up to zoning/land-use hearings to support buildings that will enable as many others as possible to do the same. The auto and energy industries don't pollute because it's fun. They do it in the course of fulfilling our demand for suburban lifestyles.
- alacombe 8y agoDo you realize the infrastructure required to support your "green" urban living ?
- dahfizz 8y agoAs Americans, what can we really do? China's emissions dwarf our own[0] and the same is generally true for other kinds of pollution (plastic in the ocean comes largely from China, etc). The entire country of America could disappear tomorrow and it would not be of huge consequence to climate change. [0] https://www.forbes.com/sites/rrapier/2018/07/01/china-emits-more-carbon-dioxide-than-the-u-s-and-eu-combined/#40e9fbe5628c https://www.forbes.com/sites/rrapier/2018/07/01/china-emits-...
- ReptileMan 8y agoYou could try making the dirty tech economically inferior on its own terms. Then the clean will be adopted with blazing speed. Nobody burns oil and coal because they like the smell.
- zamalek 8y agoIt's rapidly approaching that point already. The problem is politicians and it seems as though we are powerless to change that.
- ReptileMan 8y agoUSSR showed that when politicians and economy colide heads on politicians lose. Reality always wins at the end. Supressing superior technology is extremely hard. If you succeed it is just not superior enough.
- PavlovsCat 8y agoPeople can't claim powerlessness before they even tried. It's an excuse to not even try.
- adrianN 8y agoBut they might just burn oil and coal to save jobs.
- alacombe 8y agoLower EV prices to $10k with a 250 miles range and refill time below 10 minutes (pretty much the standard european/asian small car) and I'll buy one right now. The technology just isn't there currently...
- captain_crabs 8y agoWhen this topic comes up, I always come back to this: http://worrydream.com/ClimateChange/ http://worrydream.com/ClimateChange/ If you haven't - give it a glance!
- qwerty456127 8y agoAlmost nobody does, not just Americans.
- PeterisP 8y agoPart of the blame lies in lack of resources for understanding the impact properly. This article is a good example - it includes an infographic (https://img.huffingtonpost.com/asset/5c1a989924000019008c8835.jpeg?ops=scalefit_720_noupscale https://img.huffingtonpost.com/asset/5c1a989924000019008c883...) listing vague global effects such as "Heavy rainfall up 7%" or "sea level rise 50cm" or "Crop yields in tropical regions down x%". That's not anything that's going to get a common person to think "oh, that's absolutely horrible" - 7% of heavy rainfall or 50cm sea level rise doesn't sound scary, and they don't care about crop yields in tropical regions if they don't live there. What is needed is publicly available information on how climate change is going to affect them - not global averages, but local impact. If you just say "oh, it's going to be vaguely really bad after a long time on the other side of the globe" then people reasonably won't choose to make any sacrifices to prevent that. Let's assume the currently likely scenario of 4 degree C average warming by 2100. The article quotes Ed Maibach, director of the George Mason University Center for Climate Change Communication, that he finds it "to be nothing short of terrifying". Okay, let's elaborate and present the actually terrifying predictions to the people - where can I get them? Given that 4 degree global warming scenario, what's the predicted local warming in Texas? Given the global sea level rise, which parts of Florida are going to flood by 2100? Given the predicted changes in rainfall, what is going to be the effect on crop yields in Midwest? 2100 is too far away to be meaningful for most people, what is the realistic bad case scenario by 2050 or 2070, what are the mid-term impacts? Don't just say "it's terrifying" but actually terrify people with data! And not just any data, but data that's relevant to them personally; a Midwest farmer doesn't care about crop yields falling in tropical regions (or might even prefer it, less competition=higher prices) and vice versa - to meaningfully convince a person living in Florida you need data about how Florida is going to be affected; to convince a person living in London, you need data about the expected impact on London. Is there such data available?
- mturmon 8y agoTimely data is available for the US. The fourth National Climate Assessment just released its report on impacts last month (https://nca2018.globalchange.gov https://nca2018.globalchange.gov). This “impacts” report is based on the science NCA report from last year, so if you want the science drivers, see that one. For the first time, both reports are highly regionally decomposed (again, across the US). One example if you want alarming: “Recent economic analysis finds that under a higher scenario (RCP8.5), it is likely (a 66% probability, which corresponds to the Intermediate-Low to Intermediate sea level rise scenarios) that between $66 billion and $106 billion worth of real estate will be below sea level by 2050; and $238 billion to $507 billion, by 2100.” (https://nca2018.globalchange.gov/chapter/8/ https://nca2018.globalchange.gov/chapter/8/) The report has much, much more.
- pteredactyl 8y agoIncoming: Green Fascism.
- kristopolous 8y agoRequiring people to be responsible for their impact on the world? Incorporating externalities in prices so products are accountable and not subsidized by the public through their health, cleanup, and environmental costs? Clear labeling on the total lifecycle impact of a product? Banning harmful hazardous chemicals with impact lifecycles in the tens of thousands of years? Is this the dreadful fascism you speak of? Even the fiercest AnaCap doesn't think products should be intentionally deceptive and lie to the consumer on the assumption collective society will pay for the harm...
- alacombe 8y agoYes, everything you enumerated is by definition anti individual freedom.
- kristopolous 8y agoFreedom to destroy the commons, lie to people, poison the population, swindle the community, and offload your trash onto others? Really? That's what your stand for? I'm not familiar with any doctrine of individual freedom that holds sacred dumping garbage into a river which everyone relies on and treating our atmosphere which everyone uses like a giant toilet while flipping everyone else the bird as some inviolable right. That's one of the real world issues with the property based libertarian philosophy. Nature, animals, plants, fires, pollinating insects, floods, the weather, none of these give a damn about who owns what property on paper. We have to treat it and care for it all collectively, there's no other way. I know it's hard but it has to be done.
- pteredactyl 8y agoTell me, you really think alacombe wants these things? 90% of the population would agree with you. That those things are to be avoided. Myself included. Unfortunately you've been brainwashed into thinking the government is the only entity equipped to fix these problems. When in fact they're the ones ensuring the problems continue. And idiots like you continue to support these false choices given to you by the government. And you probably continue to pay for it with ridiculous taxes. Thinking 'yea, they'll fix it'. Get over yourself. And your virtue signals. Realize 90% of the population wants the same things as you.
- alacombe 8y agoThe French just uprose en masse, sometime very violently, against measures said to be good for climate. So it's not just about the Americans.
- mosiuerbarso 8y agoTo my knowledge, the recent French protest wasn't quite as black and white as that. The fuel tax Macron was planning was going to hit the rural middle/working class and the poor the hardest. On average, many of these people have to commute around 30 miles to work at low paid service jobs. So their work commuting costs are a big part of their monthly bills. And then Macron came along and asked them if they'd kindly help with paying some of the costs of climate change. The proposed fuel bill didn't hit the people living in the cities as badly, because, on average, they're better paid, have better public transport options and live closer to their workplace. You can understand why people living in rural towns and outside the cites got a little-pissed off and decided to protest. The increase fuel tax was going to hit them way harder than those living in the cities. And those poorer people are being squeezed already, due to having a longer work commute, crap work pay, crap job options, and worse public transport options. Anyway, if you want more info on this listen to this video by the Mark Blyth. He can explain it better than I ever can: https://youtu.be/Sk87JHTyozo?t=641 https://youtu.be/Sk87JHTyozo?t=641
- ciconia 8y agoMost people living in the city (i.e. most of humanity) don't get climate change.
- ashildr 8y agoHalf of US-Americans voted Trump and there’s a bigger than 0 probability that they will, again. Whatever the result will be, the leading role the US had for many countries is gone and will not be restored. All hope is lost for that country, somehow the rest of the world will have to figure out how to avoid the worst in climate change without the US.
- british_india 8y agoHuman extinction by 2030.
- RickJWagner 8y agoAs a conservative American (who believes the climate is changing), I don't think the key to greater awareness is to make things seem more dire. IMHO, the key is to ensure that every bit of news about climate change is validated by unimpeachable sources. There have been more than a few incidents where claims about the amount of damage coming have been exaggerated-- this feeds doubts. News sources (Fox included) regularly carry items that describe the problem. If everyone believed what was written (even if they are only looking at Fox, nowhere else) I really believe there would be more concern.