8 ms·
Scientists say dolphins should be treated as 'non-human persons'
- alanh 16y agoHell, yes they should. We’ve known they can identify themselves in a mirror for years. They are even known to sexually pleasure each other outside of procreation. (If I recall the study correctly, the scientists introduced the dolphins to a mirror, and then placed an object on the dolphin’s back, out of its sight, with suction cups; the dolphin swam to the mirror and contorted to view the object.) We should really stop poisoning their habitat. It didn’t use to be the case that most fish had such high levels of mercury. Edit Wow, this comment just went from +7 to +4 in a minute… I guess some people feel very threatened by the idea that humans are overly dismissive of other species.
- mike_esspe 16y agoI think the problem with mirror test is that elephants and magpies pass it too.
- snth 16y agoWhat's the problem with that? Maybe elephants and magpies are smart.
- LaGrange 16y agoHumans pass it as well. Maybe we tend to underestimate even more species.
- soiz 16y agoAs humans had previously been defined as "tool-makers", when Goodall telegraphed [Louis] Leakey to report that the chimps were modifying twigs in order to "fish" termites out of holes in rock-solid termite mounds, it provoked the now famous response: "We must redefine man, redefine tool, or accept chimpanzees as human."
- Zaak 16y agoThere are few animals that pass the test. The great apes, bottlenose dolphins, magpies, and asian elephants for example. All of these animals have a large brain-to-body-size ratio, complex social interactions, problem solving ability, and a relatively long period of parental care for their young.
- lowglow 16y agoWhat about an art test: What other species makes art for the sake of art?
- alanh 16y agoIs your goal to create a test that only humans pass because we already know humans are the only worthwhile species? Sort of begging the question, isn’t it? (Edit: I don’t mean any offense — just suspicious of human heuristics.)
- jpwagner 16y agoNo offense, but this comment is awfully condescending considering the interesting question it's in response to. I think Alan's claim of the motive of the original question is unfounded. *edit: reworded for clarity
- chc 16y agoI don't see how it's condescending. Either you're seeing something I'm not or you're mistaking a rhetorical device for condescension. The idea of art being some kind of moral threshold does seem very arbitrary. Edit: Incidentally, I'm not one of the people who downvoted you.
- jpwagner 16y agoI would be totally with you if lowglow's question was: "what about a long division test?" or something similarly snarky. but art is an interesting cultural phenomenon that very likely occurs in some form in many animals. Alan's supposition that there was some bad intent in posing the question is absurd here, in my opinion.
- chc 16y agoArt is an interesting cultural phenomenon, but not something that even all humans are very interested in (unless you define it very loosely). I wouldn't be surprised to see animals produce some form of art, but neither would I surprised to see a species as intelligent as humans — or even more intelligent — that didn't give a hoot about art. Let's reframe the validity of this test in terms that we don't have thousands of years of cultural baggage around: If an alien species arrives here and teaches us all sorts of miraculous things, would we feel compelled to conclude that they are not intelligent beings if they aren't very interested in the works of Rothko? It seems particularly likely to me that an aquatic species would not have art at least until it was very advanced, since they don't have the tools or media for creating it that, say, a caveman did.
- LiveTheDream 16y ago> Edit Wow, this comment just went from +7 to +4 in a minute… I guess some people feel very threatened by the idea that humans are overly dismissive of other species. This adds nothing to the discussion. Stop worrying about a tiny, short-term karma swing. As I write this response, the parent has 12 points. /rant
- russellallen 16y agoAlthough science can help us know the facts before we make our decision, how we should treat dolphins is not a scientific question but an ethical and moral one.
- jamesbritt 16y ago" how we should treat dolphins is not a scientific question but an ethical and moral one." How did you decide that science and the scientific process should be excluded from ethics and morality?
- zackattack 16y agobecause science is about objective facts. facts are objective because they can be verified by different minds if they use the same processes. ethics and morality are EMOTIONAL, vary widely between individuals, and must be arbitrarily decided upon by an entity representing tribal leadership.
- joeyo 16y agoI've always been a little uneasy with the idea that we should assign rights (or personhood, or whatever) to animals in a graded way in proportion to their intelligence. It implies that humans should be deprived of those same rights when their intelligence doesn't meet some similar threshold.
- jpwagner 16y agoIsn't a threshold defined by one line? I guess you are arguing that implementing a threshold later evolves into a continuous gradient. I disagree.
- alanh 16y agoEmotional capacity is another axis that matters a lot. But we do deprive people of rights if they are really lacking, mentally. We put crazies in madhouses (are bad at doing so accurately). We deny minors most rights of self-determination (more than strictly based on intelligence, but the idea’s the same). Heck, to sign your will, you have to represent that your noggin isn’t fried. Edit (response to pyre): I never said we treat unintelligent people the same way we do animals. Psychologically we don’t even like to disrespect dead people (intelligence: 0). I’m just saying that intelligence does affect the rights we afford other humans.
- pyre 16y agoSo, if you are deemed unfit to make decisions for yourself, can we send you to the slaughterhouse to end up in a shrink-wrapped package at a supermarket? Taking away your ability to sign a will is a lot different than the way we treat animals/non-humans.
- joeyo 16y agoI absolutely agree that emotional processing is an important component of intelligence. But I'm still not convinced that it's a good way of ascribing rights. Regarding your examples: we certainly do act in the interests of the insane, mentally disabled and children. But that is not because they have fewer rights or have less personhood. We act for them because and in defense of their rights. We do this because they are unable to protect themselves and need guardians to defend them from abuses to their dignity, bodily integrity, etc.
- DavidAdams 16y agoI watched the excellent documentary "The Cove" a few weeks ago, and I highly recommend watching it. Though the film did fill me with dread and outrage (as intended), ironically, the portrayal of the brutal slaughter of dolphins by Japanese fishermen convinced me that dolphins are not nearly as smart as many people would like to convince us of. Here's why: Imagine there were one particular mountain valley tucked away in some corner of the world, and while human beings could range all over the vastness of this earth unharmed, if they ventured into that valley they would be killed. In that valley there was a race of essentially invincible beings that would herd any wayward human beings into a side canyon and spear them to death. How would the human race react to that? Let's assume that mounting a military attack and killing the invincible beings weren't possible. Well, first of all, we'd put up signs and fences and maybe even sentries to warn people not to go into that valley. We'd tell our children about the danger, and pass the knowledge of the invincible murderous monsters on, generation to generation. If people did go in there and got killed we'd cover the event in detail on TV, as a warning to others (like Shark Week). Even really stupid people would know not to go into the "valley of the stabby monsters." Well, if Dolphins are so smart, and they have such good communication and advanced social structure, then why haven't the many dolphins that have personally witnessed the slaughter at "The Cove" and escaped (the movie shows dolphins escaping) managed to warn other dolphins not to go there? Honestly, if dolphins were anywhere near as smart as humans and were anywhere near as ruthless, they not only would have prevented the slaughter, but would have mounted a commando raid wherein expert jumping dolphins would have trained to jump out of the water, knock the fishermen out of their little boats, then beaten and dragged them down into the cove until they were drowned. And I'm being serious about this. Human beings wouldn't put up with that shit. Other observed dolphin behavior, such as dolphins killing each other and attacking sharks to defend swimming humans does prove that they have the wherewithal to act in both self-preservation, and in the defense of others, even to violence. But they still get speared in the cove. That tells me they're not that smart.
- ck2 16y agoLack of collective memory does diminish an intelligence rating. Humans didn't have recorded history for tens of thousands of years (maybe a million depending what science you follow, frontal lobes and all that) and were doomed to repeat the same mistakes (heck we still do the same massive mistakes with lots of recorded history).
- DanielBMarkham 16y agoScience is all about how things work, not how we should act. The researchers argue that their work shows it is morally unacceptable... See, this is what we get when we confuse science and activism. Should a "researcher" have any more weight with the public about what they consider "morally acceptable"? I think there is some meat to this story: we need a more nuanced scale of what is morally acceptable or not that includes various forms of intelligence (without the same logic being used to treat disabled people poorly) I can't emphasize enough how important these issues are. Dolphins are obviously highly intelligent creatures. But such a discussion needs to happen from a neutral and reasonable standpoint. Asking folks who are deeply in love with their subject to tell us what's morally acceptable or not is whacked. Doctors shouldn't treat themselves, lawyers shouldn't have themselves as clients, accountants shouldn't audit their own books, programmers shouldn't peer-review their own code -- and scientists shouldn't advocate on the topics they are deeply attached to. This is just common sense. EDIT: Just to be clear, there are at least three problems with scientists-as-activist. 1) The public gets to make the decision on these issues. This means that any communication from scientists has to have as its goal informing the public, not persuading it. In an article like this, it is not clear to the public where the discussion of science ends and where the discussion of advocacy begins. This confusion, aside from being unethical in any profession, is a poor use of the public's resources. 2) The end result of such advocacy has a direct impact on the scientist's lives, creating a moral hazard. This is like when your chiropractor tells you that you have a bad back -- and need many more chiropractor visits. Maybe true, maybe not, but when a professional judgment can also be self-serving it creates mixed incentives and doubt, which is bad for any group of professionals 3) Morality is not science: you cannot add one and one and get "moral" or "immoral". When a conclusion like this is put forth by a scientist, it glosses over all sorts of other questions which other professionals are interested in, like when life begins, or what constitutes sentience. To make a statement about morality is -- at the very least -- to jump into areas for which you are not trained. As a professional, once again, it's your job to make it clear which things you speak about are part of your work and part of your opinions. The most important thing a scientist can say is "I don't know" That's not even getting into the entire issue of just being too close to something to make a good call. Or -- if you think such behavior is okay -- the use of scientists as pawns to have proxy battles over other larger political causes. These are not new standards. Other professions have been living inside of them for years. Ask your accounting consulting firm whether it's moral for you to invest in Indonesia and you'll get a very careful reply which will boil down to "I am not the person to ask that question of"
- iuguy 16y agoThis is solely my opinion, and I could be (and would love to be proven) completely wrong, but as I understand it we as a race are the most incredible predators on the planet. There is no animal on this earth that could survive a full onslaught by a group of humans. We win, put simply. Now for dolphins to turn around and say so long and thanks for all the fish is a great thing. I like dolphins. There are people here who think eugenics is a good thing. What will dolphins do for them? Sadly, the eugenics side will probably live. As long as what we produce is on the scale of Dr Julian Bashir I only have a minor problem. If we're producing Khan Noonien Singh then I have a major problem. Going back to the problem, I believe that dolphins are great creatures but not on the same terms as us. I'm sorry if you view it differently. I think Dolphins are great in their own right, therefore don't need our help to become intelligent but should have a supporter definately.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- Tyrant505 16y agoDoes intelligence somehow determine the significance and importance of pain? Is it less real?
- JulianMorrison 16y agoIf you consider intelligence in terms of IQ tests, they're pretty smart. If you consider it in terms of optimizing power, the ability to shape the future to their goals, a quadriplegic low-IQ human with a eyeblink controlled typing screen obliterates them. I would consider them pre-people at most, ripe for uplift.
- puredemo 16y agoI wonder how brain-computer interfaces and neuroprosthetics might change this in the upcoming years. Seaquest was right!
- tremendo 16y agoI'm all for the humane treatment of animals. Humans are animals. But doesn't "person" imply "human"? Does a human need to be intelligent to be a person? what about someone with extensive brain damage, wouldn't (s)he still be a person? Why muddle definitions?
- fleitz 16y agoIt's a very interesting philosophical question about what implies a person and if such a thing can be lost, and when personhood is gained. It was once very easy to lose personhood, for example being unable to pay your debts, or losing in combat. It seems that for the present personhood is gained at birth and is never lost. For better or worse, corporations are also treated as persons.
- known 16y agoAnd give them voting rights.
- waynecolvin 16y agoIf dolphins became legal persons then how would you take one to court? If one ever broke into your house or something.