6 ms·
Sending astronauts to Mars would be stupid, astronaut says
- EamonnMR 8y agoSame could be said for sending people to the south pole, but people did it anyway.
- cowmix 8y agoOr the moon.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- assblaster 8y agoWe brought those astronauts home after the mission. What's the point of a suicide mission to Mars?
- wpietri 8y agoThis seems like a reasonable point to me. We went to the moon a long time ago. Most people alive today were born after we abandoned the moon. If we're even hazily serious about Mars, it seems like we should spend a couple of decades practicing on the moon. Mars does have a bit of atmosphere (0.6% of Earth's), but with a travel time 100x larger, minor issues quickly turn fatal.
- simonh 8y agoWhy do you think it would be suicide? Very risky yes, but the plans being proposed do include provision for returning the crew to a Earth.
- assblaster 8y agoIf your chance of getting to Mars, landing successfully, then taking off, followed by journey to Earth, then re-entry to Earth is over 50% mortality, then it's a suicide mission.
- dahdum 8y agoAnders went to space in ‘68. I think he’s lost the spirit of adventure he must have had to do so. Putting a human on Mars will be one of the pinnacles of human achievements, even a small ultimately failed colony an unbelievable achievement. I support both wholeheartedly.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- pdonis 8y ago> Anders went to space in ‘68. On Apollo 8, which got to orbit the Moon but not land there. Anders didn't get any further Apollo missions, so he never got a chance to actually land on the Moon. I wonder if that might be coloring his opinions.
- turingspiritfly 8y agoSo this is the part I don't get, re: "What's pushing us to go to Mars?", some time ago someone said the same of going to the Moon. There was no good main reason for going to the moon, other than the US and the USSR having who's got a bigger dk war. The reality I feel, is this time we do have a good reason, to actually kick start off-planet habitable zones that we'll reap the benefits years and years into the future
- anonymouzz 8y agoI don't understand these naysayers. I'm not trying to be mean here, but is there anything more to that than an old guy complaining about how it was awesome in his time and age, and how we get everything wrong nowadays? I'm genuinely asking - are astronauts talking about space programs similar to actors and celebrities taking about moral or political issues? I.e. just famous but not so smart people? Also, Elon's take on this three years ago: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8P8UKBAOfGo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8P8UKBAOfGo
- hnmonkey 8y agoI disagree somewhat with what this astronaut is saying, but generally speaking I think astronauts are supposed to be quite intelligent, especially about issues related to space. I was under the impression that each of them had excellent skills and knowledge in at least one area that benefits their missions and of course strong understanding of space-related things. So, to answer your question I don't think it's the case that it's similar to celebrities talking about moral and political issues in any way. I assume that he's pretty well informed but just has a totally different view that's less forward-thinking than others of his astronaut brethren.
- ineedasername 8y agoThey're supposed to be quite intelligent about a very specific scenario: operating a specialized vehicle in launch, low/zero gravity, and landing. I wouldn't look to them for understanding or insight into the geopolitical or economic role their missions might be a part of. When listening to experts it's always very important to remember precisely what their expertise happens to be.
- Johnny555 8y ago"What's the imperative? What's pushing us to go to Mars?" he said, adding "I don't think the public is that interested". I think it's the opposite -- the general public is much more interested in sending humans to space than yet another unmanned mission. I agree that robotic missions give the most bang for the buck, and should continue for the foreseeable future, but as far as the general public goes, a manned mission is much more glamorous and more likely to keep Nasa funded.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- greglindahl 8y agoPoll shows more public support for NASA science programs than human exploration (June, 2018) https://spacenews.com/poll-shows-more-public-support-for-nasa-science-programs-than-human-exploration/ https://spacenews.com/poll-shows-more-public-support-for-nas...
- Johnny555 8y agoFrom the article, it sounds like most people support NASA science programs closer to home, climate resource and planetary defense (against asteroids). The article doesn't talk about preference for planetary expiration via robots vs humans. In this article from Pew, people prefer human exploration vs robotic exploration only, 58% to 41%: http://www.pewinternet.org/2018/06/06/majority-of-americans-believe-it-is-essential-that-the-u-s-remain-a-global-leader-in-space/ http://www.pewinternet.org/2018/06/06/majority-of-americans-...
- cvaidya1986 8y agoWe are going to be a space faring civilization.
- mgamache 8y agoFTA: "I think the space shuttle was a serious error. It hardly did anything except have an exciting launch, but it never lived up to its promise," Few people are willing to call the shuttle a failure, but it was. It cost much more per mission than estimated and was supposed to lunch every two weeks. It averaged approximately one every 3 months. The payload was supposed to cost $635 per pound, but ended costing $27,000. You need a critical review of NASA if they are going to be effective in the future (Humans or no). This article may read as overly negative, but there is a lot of Pollyanna reporting regarding NASA.
- admax88q 8y agoI mean it did go to space, numerous times. Just because the budgeting projections were way off doesn't make it a failure.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- bostonpete 8y agoI think the point is that we didn't need it to get to space. There were cheaper alternatives.
- mgamache 8y agoRight, the Russians were sending LEO payloads for < $2500/pound. Event our own old rockets were much cheaper.
- na85 8y agoI don't understand the cost argument. NASA is allocated less than half a percentage point of your federal budget. $20B is nothing to the United States Government. You could double their budget and DOD would still be spending 16x more. NASA is cheap. Direct your ire at Rockwell, not NASA.
- ptero 8y ago
- Abishek_Muthian 8y agoConsidering it was the success of the Soviet's Sputnik missions which rallied up American public to support for the Moon mission; I don't see why the progress of manned missions from China, India, Japan shouldn't create positive sentiment again within USA. With commendable growth of private space organisations within USA, it's perhaps inevitable that an American would be the first to land on Mars; which politics apart would still be a giant leap for mankind in general.
- monochromatic 8y agoIf a decent-sized asteroid hits the earth, humanity simply ends. That is an unacceptable risk. We become multi-planetary for survival.
- mo1ok 8y agoTrue, but it's going to be hard to convince a small group of people to live a miserable, unrewarding live in an unforgiving desert in the off-chance humanity ends in sudden catastrophe.
- monochromatic 8y agoElon Musk is already working on that problem.
- gpm 8y agoUh, no, it's not. There are a great number of people who say they would be willing to live on mars under those conditions basically just for the novelty of it. There are a great number of challenges with colonizing mars. Getting a small group of competent people is not one of them.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoSome people would see that as a highly desirable vacation from the overcrowding here on earth. To each his own.
- jumelles 8y agoRobotics have improved exponentially since the moon landing - where before humans may have been necessary, autonomous landers etc. are now cheaper and more capable. Why risk the lives?
- ryanmarsh 8y agoMany would love to risk their lives. I would. Some of us think like explorers. If I lived a long time ago I would rather have died alone with arrows in my back as an explorer of the American West, than in a warm bed in my old age having never explored or tested fate. "The fear of death follows from the fear of life. A man who lives fully is prepared to die at any time." — Mark Twain
- melling 8y agoI had this same discussion 4 years ago on hacker news. I couldn’t convince anyone. Perhaps if some of the people realize how much time has past, they’ll realize that we can move much faster with robots: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8540462 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8540462
- Teknoman117 8y agoLife risk aside, the rovers are in many ways significantly less capable than humans. For instance, it took decades for us to send a rover than could "see" just a bit into the martian rocks by hitting them with a laser or using a small drill. During the moon landings, you just had an astronaut hit one with a rock pick and look inside. It took decades for us to be comfortable sending a rover with a small shovel which could only dig a few inches into the martian soil. During the moon landings, you just had an astronaut with a shovel... So far, no robot we've sent has been better at tool use than a human. Sure, they don't require life support or consumables, so their longevity is extraordinary, but man, there are so many things that took decades to test for with the robots that a single manned mission would've been able to solve in a few days.
- melling 8y agoYou’re assuming that we can’t make better robots. For the same amount of money as sending humans to Mars, we can develop better robots. Those robots will also be useful on earth of course. From HN in 2014: Someone dying is devastating. Trying to conquer space a handful of people at a time is the slow and dangerous way of accomplishing this task. We should be building machines to explore the solar system. This can be done for a fraction of the cost, time, and it will allow him to allow us to iterate quickly. In 100 years, more humans will live off earth if we iterate with machines, etc now than if we move slowly trying to reduce the risk in order to keep humans safe.
- Svoka 8y ago> Musk and Bezos, they're talking about putting colonies on Mars, that's nonsense. Probably kind of people which were telling "They're talking about landing rockets, that's nonsense".
- assblaster 8y agoWhat is the cost:benefit ratio to long term colonization of an inhospitable planet?
- ryanmarsh 8y agoI imagine many had a similar view of sailing across the Atlantic before word spread of riches in the New World.
- cbanek 8y agoThey weren't just going across the Atlantic just because. They were looking for a new trade route with Asia. Discovering the New World was just a fluke.
- mo1ok 8y agoThe cost:benefit of colonizing the new world was immense and known prior to widespread colonization, esp. in the tropical parts. Settling mars is like colonizing the Sahara desert, except this time with no oxygen or camels.
- dwaltrip 8y agoI'm not sure which exact path for advancing humanity into space is the best. Perhaps there are better ways than colonizing Mars. However, in general, there are immense resources and energy sources in space that can benefit humanity. Pioneering space will also require many technological advancements that will benefit people back on Earth. There is also the question of learning about the universe. If, for example, there was bacteria on Mars, that would one of the greatest discoveries of all time. I don't think your comparison is fair.
- modzu 8y agothe last sentence from jim lovell is not something i'd heard before and makes you think. on his view of the earth from the moon (wow): "When I looked at the Earth itself... I started to wonder why I was here, what's my purpose here… it sort of dawned me," he said. "And my perspective is that God has given mankind a stage on which to perform. How the play turns out, is up to us."
- lowtto 8y ago> "When I looked at the Earth itself... I started to wonder why I was here, what's my purpose here… it sort of dawned me," he said. > "And my perspective is that God has given mankind a stage on which to perform. How the play turns out, is up to us." I think they are saying; that there's nothing out there that humans are capable of taking advantage of. If going to the Moon has any benefit, then it is to point out clearly that we shouldn't explore more and stay right here on earth, and taking care of whatever we mere human can take care of. If going to the moon is that hard and costly, then how does this compare going to the mars? Even if we did managed to, which few selected population can reap the benefit? Is it worth it for us to pay so much civilian money only for it to be a special planet for very few selected capitalist from earth? At some point, we just had to lose our interest in space exploration. Just because there's too much of this world to keep us busy with.
- friedman23 8y agoThe article is pointless, I thought there would be interesting technical reasons why sending humans would be stupid but it's simply that he thinks it's cheaper to send robots. We go to Mars because people with the means to send people there want to. It's as dumb as wanting to cross the ocean to travel to a new unexplored continent.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoWith 7 billion people on the planet and that number only growing, it seems likely that we either find more room for people somewhere or face a massive population die-off event at some point. The humane answer is look for more room to put this burgeoning population of humans. The other answer is likely a case of hell to pay for most people on the planet. Even those who survive will likely be facing serious hardships as a consequence. And, I mean, why the hell not? We're all just dust in the wind anyway, dancing on this earth for a short time. If some folks think going to another planet is cool and are willing to endure what that takes, why should that desire be deemed invalid? From what I gather, space programs are a unique combination of highly inspirational and requiring tremendous rigor and have, thus, fostered innovation the world would otherwise have never pursued. I imagine that has sufficient value to offset the high costs of space exploration, though I'm not actually willing to look up sources and try to prove that.
- lokedhs 8y agoThere are lots of deserts on earth that is pretty much uninhabited. If you are concerned about room for people, you can relax until these places are full as well. Even the most inhospitable parts of the Sahara desert is much more hospitable than Mars. Its also much more accessible. There are plenty of good reasons for humans to go to Mars, but getting access to more space for people isn't one of them.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoIf you are concerned about room for people, you can relax until these places are full as well. "Dig your well before you are thirsty." -- Proverb from somewhere or other. If we wait until we have completely run out of "room" -- and I am not really thinking of just warehousing people, but room to grow the food for them, etc and support the high quality of life that people in first world countries generally have and people in developing countries generally aspire to -- then you pretty much guarantee failure of that path. Developing options elsewhere takes quite a lot of time and resources. It won't happen overnight.
- 8y ago
- tzfld 8y agoI can understand the view from his perspective. What I can't understand is, how can you have a level of pragmatism to be excited and supportive mainly based on how cheap a mission could be.