3 ms·
> Long ago when I had two young kids, they would sometimes pick fights, for example on long car trips. One might start singing, to which the other would complai
by hombre_fatal 8y ago
> Long ago when I had two young kids, they would sometimes pick fights, for example on long car trips. One might start singing, to which the other would complain. We might agree that singing is too much for such a small space. Then the first might start to quietly hum, which we might decide is okay. Then first might hum more loudly and triumphantly, while the second might writhe, cover their ears, and make a dramatic display of suffering.
I love this example of bad faith complaining.
There's something grotesque about adults doing this in internet comments. Like watching a grown man wear a diaper.
- perfmode 8y agoThe offended child is really complaining about the subtle and escalating transgression of the humming child. > Then the first might start to quietly hum, which we might decide is okay. Then first might hum more loudly and triumphantly The humming child scores low on the scale of interpersonal justice. Framing the offended child’s suffering as bad faith is, in a Wittgensteinian sense, to misunderstand their use of language. They aren’t playing the language game of the observer passing judgement. The observer is failing to steel-man the position of the aggrieved and instead chooses to focus on an apparent and ostensible fault.
- will4274 8y ago> the subtle and escalating transgression of the humming child Is humming a "transgression"? Music is typically considered entertainment. Why can't the other child put on head phones, hum a different song, or look out the window? It's exactly this phenomenon that OP is addressing. A fairly common behavior (humming to oneself) is portrayed as a "transgression" and you go so far as to say it is unjust, just because somebody else happens to not like it. You've thrown the authors framing, that certain actions are inherently annoying and unacceptable (singing loudly in a small space) while others are generally acceptable (humming softly to oneself) out the window.
- perfmode 8y agoContext matters. In a library, humming is a violation of the conventions of the space. In a music practice room, it is perfectly fine. In a car, the convention is ambiguous and dependent on the passengers. This is precisely why it is necessary to come to agreement on what is okay to do in the space. Again: The humming child was initially singing. So, to view the humming in isolation is to dismiss the fact that this is an iterative negotiation.
- will4274 8y agoBut they did come to an agreement. From the article: > Then the first might start to quietly hum, which we might decide is okay. You've thrown the agreement on what is okay out the window because somebody is offended.
- perfmode 8y agoThe humming child broke the agreement by increasing in volume after the agreement was made. Why did you omit the sentence that followed? > Then the first might start to quietly hum, which we might decide is okay. Then first might hum more loudly and triumphantly
- will4274 8y agoMm, I interpreted the second child as writhing already from the soft humming and increasing in writhing intensity as the humming volume increased.
- PavlovsCat 8y ago> Why can't the other child put on head phones, hum a different song, or look out the window? Why can't the humming kid not hum normally, instead of "more loudly and triumphantly"? > A fairly common behavior (humming to oneself) is portrayed as a "transgression" No, you portray deliberate annoying of someone else as humming to oneself. > You've thrown the authors framing, that certain actions are inherently annoying and unacceptable (singing loudly in a small space) while others are generally acceptable (humming softly to oneself) out the window. Because that's a "general" framing that is used to replace the actual context of the actual situation and the actual meaning of these actions.
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoThe writhing child is not writhing in pain. They are writhing in an attempt to attract adult intervention. They are not giving an honest account of their sufferings, but a dramatization. It's a plea to the emotions, not of the transgressor (and I agree that there is a transgression), but of the bystanders. The offended child's suffering is not bad faith, but the display is.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Sabinus 8y agoI love watching HN pull apart children's disagreements.
- woodruffw 8y ago> I love this example of bad faith complaining. I don't think this is bad faith: bad faith entails a sort of inauthenticity, while the children in this analogy are both authentic in their desires. They might be exaggerating for rhetorical purposes, but neither is acting in bad faith in the way that the term is normally used. An interesting analogy, but the only thing it captures for me is Hanson's abuse of a philosophical term of art.