7 ms·
It is worth noting that the Holborn London Underground experiment described in the article only took place on one of the systems longest escalators, where it's
by bobthepanda 8y ago
It is worth noting that the Holborn London Underground experiment described in the article only took place on one of the systems longest escalators, where it's unlikely that many people were walking up the full length anyways so there was wasted capacity.
I feel like it would hold less true for a 3m or 4m escalator that most people would feel comfortable walking up.
- lostlogin 8y agoIt does acknowledge that. “A 2002 theoretical study suggested that when escalators reach more than 60 feet high, fewer people will climb them, leaving ample space to carry standing passengers.” Not quite sure what a ‘theoretical study’ means in this context though. They link to their previous reporting on the study, but the link provided there to the actual study is dead.
- bobthepanda 8y agoI would assume that a 'theoretical study' would involve some type of passenger flow modeling, which TfL often use to measure expected passenger flows in projects like the Bank upgrade, layout of Crossrail stations, future upgrades like Camden Town, etc. The problem with modeling is that it assumes all your inputs are correct, and there are so many confounding factors in the operation of a Tube station that there's no real replacement for a real study. I only put in the disclaimer about height because while it's mentioned with the theoretical study, it's not mentioned with one of the only actual experiments, and Holborn is a 23m long escalator, which you wouldn't know unless you use Holborn. These findings wouldn't be very helpful in New York, for example, where most stations are so close to the surface that you're only traveling one or two stories.
- eeeeeeeeeeeee 8y agoI’ve definitely seen this dynamic at long and steep escalators at airports — people won’t walk it. But it completely changes on the normal sized ones, which are a lot more common.