8 ms·
Canada Prohibits Piracy Settlement Demands in ISP Copyright Notices
- gruez 8y agoseems to be a blogspam of https://torrentfreak.com/canada-prohibits-piracy-settlement-demands-in-isp-copyright-notices-181218/ https://torrentfreak.com/canada-prohibits-piracy-settlement-...
- walrus01 8y agoTechdirt is not blogspam, it's a 12+ year old and generally well respected site that covers issues of interest to those who support the EFF, and similar.
- freehunter 8y agoBlogspam is a blog taking content from the original source and reprinting it without any substantial improvement over the original source. It has nothing to do with the reputation or reliability of the blog, just the content.
- belorn 8y agoIf I remember right, torrentfreak is set to be severely penalized on HN by the mods. My memory is fuzzy, but I recall reading that around the time of piratebay/pirate party one of the mods said that they wanted to lower how long those stories stayed on the front page. Naturally they can have removed that by now.
- dang 8y agoWe changed the URL from https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20181218/16044141262/canada-outlaws-settlement-threat-letters-sent-through-isps.shtml https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20181218/16044141262/canad..., which points to that. This is in keeping with the site guidelines, which call for original sources. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- miguelrochefort 8y agoNow that rightsholders aren't allowed to settle a deal through ISPs, maybe they will go to court and ask copyright infringers to pay the full penalty. This could actually be worse for copyright infringers...
- msbarnett 8y agoExcept that in Canada, they can’t take the “infringer” to court without unmasking the IP, which they can only do via a legal battle in court with the ISP. The math doesn’t make that economical unless you’re going after an astonishingly large infringer.
- peeters 8y agoI don't think it requires going to court. This discovery is known as a "Norwich order", and while there's a burden of evidence to prove that the order is justified, it's not a "battle" and the ISP wouldn't be trying to argue against it. There was actually a very recent SCC case [1] between Rogers and a copyright enforcer, where Rogers was appealing a federal court decision that Rogers itself had to bear the cost of fulfilling these orders. If that stood, it would give copyright enforcers carte blanche to pursue copyright suits against minor violators. [1] Commentary here: http://www.mondaq.com/canada/x/750214/Media+Entertainment+Law/Who+Foots+The+Bill+NoticeAndNotice+Norwich+Orders+And+Compliance+Costs http://www.mondaq.com/canada/x/750214/Media+Entertainment+La...
- widforss 8y agoI don't know about your ISP, but I'm pretty sure my ISP would battle the hell out of anything concerning my privacy. Link in Swedish: https://www.bahnhof.se/press/press-releases/2016/02/24/bahnhof-bade-rattighet-och-skyldighet-att-neka-polisen-uppgifter https://www.bahnhof.se/press/press-releases/2016/02/24/bahnh...
- kwhitefoot 8y agoYes, but Bahnhof is very much an exception in the world of ISPs. I'm not at all sure I would be able to rely on my ISP, Telenor Norway, to the same degree.
- paul7986 8y agoI guess ppl in the US still download content? There are so many paid and non-paid streaming options to choose from it makes me wonder why download content?
- iforgotpassword 8y agoSo it will be truely mine.
- tyingq 8y agoNot just theoretical either. Verizon sold out to Frontier. Guess what happened to many of the movies I "bought"? Poof. Gone. No recourse either, unless I want to file in small claims court.
- vertexFarm 8y agoGonna take a wild guess how that adventure will unfold.
- acct1771 8y agoOh he'd definitely win a few hundred bucks.
- yjftsjthsd-h 8y agoStreaming is a huge pain compared to playing files on disk. Pick a service, navigate its messy UI, hope it has what you want, use the poor in-browser video player (or terrible, slow, buggy app)... Or search through a folder, double-click, done.
- my_username_is_ 8y agoAlso streaming requires reliable high-speed internet. This is easy to take for granted when you live in a major metro area, but for more rural users, high speed internet may not be available at all.
- walrus01 8y agoNow if we could just stop copyright third party enforcement companies from sending DMCA notices and automated threats to Canadian ISPs with ARIN IP space, where the dmca does not apply. Pretty much all go to /dev/null. It's amusing how fully automated American legal threats make the default assumption that everywhere on the internet is subject to American federal laws. The traditional email inbox abuse@ispname.com is supposed to be used for actual network operational issues which impact the health of a network (ddos, IP space hijacks, SMTP blacklists, abusive colo and dedicated server customers, etc).
- grawprog 8y agoI started getting those emails just after the law changed a few years ago. Multiple emails per day. My ISP was forwarding them from some lawyer in California. I couldn't block them because they were coming from the same email that sends my bill. They were for things i'd never downloaded or even watched. A whole bunch of 8GB files of movies i'd never even heard of. I called my ISP they said they were forced to send them to me and recommended I stopped downloading things.... First of all there's no way in hell i'm gonna download an 8GB video...period...second...i'd never even heard of those movies...so fuck that... I looked up the lawyer that the letters were coming from, found out he was some random copyright troll and had been harassing people in canada all over the place pretty much the day after the laws changed. So I found a fax number for their office and with a handy little script...I showed them what it was like to be flooded by bullshit. The letters stopped within a day and I haven't gotten one since.
- kuhhk 8y ago> So I found a fax number for their office and with a handy little script...I showed them what it was like to be flooded That is fantastic. What did the script do? Did you roll your own fax software, or use some third-party/open source binary? I'm curious because every 2-3 years I'm required to send some stupid fax, and I never really found a good (free) way to do it.
- grawprog 8y agoI found something that let me send an image as a fax. It was a while ago. I really searched for this. I don't think I still have it. I only ever used it for that and that was on an older computer. The script just used a binary to send an image I had prepared with some text asking them to kindly stop emailing me...well...maybe not so kindly and it sent the image as fast as a fax machine would allow. I imagine they ran out of paper fairly quick...or the machine locked up...but it seemed to work. It was some small project I found on github or something. I had to compile it. Sorry I can't be more helpful. I think I searched for send fax from linux and variatins of that.
- 8y ago