3 ms·
I want libertarians and anarchists to read this kind of stuff and start to consider that maybe cities are organizations that compete and cooperate, just like co
by EGreg 8y ago
I want libertarians and anarchists to read this kind of stuff and start to consider that maybe cities are organizations that compete and cooperate, just like companies and unions.
Disneyworld is a city owned by a corporation, next door is a democratically run city. The Disney corporation has a sort of democracy of sharholders too, which elects a board etc.
Businesses renting space in DisneyWorld are not much different than businesses setting up a taxable nexus in a city or state. In both cases, force is used by the “landlord” to extract rents/taxes and if you don’t like it, you can go somewhere else. It is a “free market” of cities and states.
The exception is states where you are not allowed to leave. That is indeed a major difference.
But overall, libertarians and anarchists often single out “THE STATE” or “THE GOVERNMENT” for special thrashing, when governments are simply management teams of organizations, and the difference is mostly of scale. If anything, a democratically run city is more benign than a city which is run top-down.
- atom-morgan 8y agoMost libertarians and anarchists I've talked to do and have considered this.
- stale2002 8y agoThis argument only works if you are a person who believes that every inch should be effectively owned by governments. So it is not competition. When you purchase land, it doesn't really belong to you. It belongs to the government, as you still have to pay their fee, which can increase at any time without you having a choice. It would be wonderful if it were possible to buy land, and that land actually belonged to you. This is unfortunately impossible, though, so it makes no sense to talk about competition. It is not a free market.
- EGreg 8y agoNot exactly. Land is owned by organizations, governments are just who is running the organizations — a chess club is not the same as its president and secretary. When Walt Disney World purchased land, it could actually administer an entire city there. What you are talking about is called Sovereign Ownership (alloidal title). Like the Royal Family in England has a bunch of grounds where there is no higher landlord. Theoretically they can murder people there and the police can’t do anything about it. States on the other hand don’t own land in the way that you’re saying. There are overlapping jurisdictions and laws, and compacts, in practice. Many of the states were commonwealths (eg Virginia) of cities before they joined the union. The history of states is just people and organizations joining forces into larger legal organizations.
- stale2002 8y agoIf at any point in time a different group can force you to pay them money for the privilege of living on a plot of land, then you don't own that land. Instead, the group that is charging you rent is the one who owns the land. And this true even if they call that "rent" by a different name, such as "property taxes". Using the examples you give, Walt Disney does not own that land, as a different entity could raise rent in them at any point in time. > The history of states is just people and organizations joining forces into larger legal organizations. It doesn't matter. If this super organization has the ability to charge rents on all of the group under it, then the super organization is the one who owns the land. The smaller organizations do not.
- EGreg 8y agoIf that’s how you choose to define ownership, fine. So what?
- stale2002 8y agoYour original argument was about libertarianism and how cities are like landlords that compete against each other. That idea is ridiculous. This is not compatible with libertarianism, and is a bad analogy. This is because it is not even close to a free market. A free market would be one where people actually can truly purchase land and compete. But that's not possible. At the end of the day the land is not owned by you, it is owned by the super owner. That's all. It is not actually compatible with libertarianism or anarchism, because there was never any choice involved in this. Nobody can truly decide to pick up and leave, and form their own competing government. You can call this good or bad, just please don't pretend like this is a market. This is why governments do indeed deserve special thrathing, criticism, and to be specifically singled out, where as private groups do not.
- EGreg 8y agoPrivate groups are just smaller. Cities are larger and have more things going on. I can go live in this building or that. I can go live in this city or that. Can I buy an apartment in a building and own it 100% without the building having any say? What if the building is a condo? I own the apartment, in a sense. I bought it. But I still have to abide by the rules of the building. Does this make apartment housing not a market? You’d have to define the term “free market” before others can independently verify whether something is a “free market” or not. It seems to me that if you rigorously defined your terms and entertained direct analogies between what privately administered jurisdictions and publicly administered ones, you’d find there isn’t anything uniquely special about a democratic city government vs disneyworld’s management.