5 ms·
The article implies that if cities could unilaterally annex twrritory they would and that presumanly would result in nicer city shapes (boundaries) as well as m
by mc32 8y ago
The article implies that if cities could unilaterally annex twrritory they would and that presumanly would result in nicer city shapes (boundaries) as well as more importantly better and cheaper services due to elimination of redundancies. Interestingly the article claims both rich and poor people are reluctant to give up their enclaves/ independence due to power, momey, and other aspects such as education.
- robertAngst 8y agoMy city is one of the best in our area. Best schools, safe, and has a high property tax. 10 miles south of us is Detroit. Where the Detroit voters re-elected Kawammi kilpatrick despite having constant public corruption. Do I want those voters to impact my schools? Do those voters want to spend 9,000$/yr on property taxes? Its far too simplistic to think that there is only redundancies at play.
- dayofthedaleks 8y agoGlad that the Voice of White Flight Suburbs could chime in. Edit: Also, it looks like Kwame Kilpatrick hasn't stood for office in more than a decade. Exactly what axe are you grinding, here?
- ghaff 8y agoDetroit has some of the highest public school spending per student in the country with some of the worst outcomes even for an urban area. It's a pretty common pattern that cities spend more per student than suburbs and the schools are "worse" (by just about any quantitative metric). And, yes, it's historically been a big reason for families who could afford to do so to leave cities; the alternative in their minds was to put their children in private schools.
- monocasa 8y agoSo I have several family members who work in under privileged schools, and what they pretty unequivocally say to this argument is that it's one of those "it's expensive to be poor" kind of things. These kid's parents work two or three jobs, so we give them subsidized after school programs. Their housholds are food insecure, so we give them breakfast and lunch so they can focus on schooling and not their empty stomachs. So much of this spending is just to try and bring these students closer to parity in the moment, but despite all of that, they don't get any that before they enter school in kindergarten, so they're sort of perpetually behind. It has next to nothing to do with government waste, or throwing good money after bad despite what that terrible "Waiting for Superman" movie told all the white flight parents looking for validation.
- ghaff 8y agoTo be clear, there are all manner of reasons why the schools for a poorer population often need to spend more money per student than an upper middle class suburb. At the same time, as you suggest, the best money can probably do is to bring students and the school as a whole closer to parity. It's not surprising that many people who can afford to do so opt out of urban public school systems one way or another.
- devdas 8y agoIt would be interesting to include all private/parental expenditure on children in the cost of schooling as well.
- AlexB138 8y agoWhat do you think this kind of comment is adding to the conversation?
- radames30 8y agoYou think the parent comment adds something more worthwhile?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- radames30 8y agoNot sure why your comment has been flagged while the equally loaded parent comment has not
- anothergoogler 8y agoYour kids might learn to spell an un-American name like Kwame if you raised them around those scary poor people.
- scarejunba 8y agoKinda douchy to spell his name like that on purpose. Kinda ignorant to do so by accident.
- Spooky23 8y agoSuburban towns are more likely to be more lean and get by without things like large professional police and fire forces because they lack the social problems of the cities. The structure of city government is usually better defined and resistant to change, and would “win” over the annexed towns. Usually there’s a ward structure that benefits a certain type of political machinery. The backbone of suburban politics are usually powered by things like volunteer fire departments, schools or other orgs. Those types of organizations will fight hard because unionized city organizations have more people and seniority, etc. No sane person would vote for annexation who isn’t part of a city.
- jeffbax 8y agoActually one of the latest episodes of the Impact is about how aggressively annexing ended up serving those within the city very poorly. https://art19.com/shows/the-impact/episodes/99ffb9d5-58d6-4405-84e8-ee33a18db854 https://art19.com/shows/the-impact/episodes/99ffb9d5-58d6-44... > The incredible shrinking city > For decades, Memphis grew by bringing its suburbs into the city limits. City officials thought this suburb-gobbling policy would be an economic boon-- that it would bring in tax revenue. > Instead, the policy was an economic disaster, especially for the majority black neighborhoods in the city's core. In this episode, we’ll tell you about the consequences of Memphis’ sprawl, and the city’s plan to fix its past mistakes. This article should not be treating it like such a panacea, because it certainly went poorly for Memphis
- Spooky23 8y agoAgreed. Like anything else in government or politics it depends on all sorts of things. Even a place like NYC that did it’s annexing 100+ years ago feels the problems. When I was growing up in Queens, anyone we interfaced with in city government locally was a castoff banished to the provinces or a political idiot. The consequences of that can be seen all over.