3 ms·
Well, here is why I think Jesus very likely existed and taught: The Church today follows the teachings of Paul, that the Law is obsolete, nailed to the cross a
by EGreg 8y ago
Well, here is why I think Jesus very likely existed and taught:
The Church today follows the teachings of Paul, that the Law is obsolete, nailed to the cross and no longer binding. The Church teachings give the Chuch great authority in determining what people should do, church leaders are called Father etc. The Church was supposed to be for all nations.
And yet... Jesus is described in the gospels exactly saying the opposite! “I came to save the lost sheep of Israel.” When a young man asked how to be saved, Jesus said “follow the Law”. He always taught to follow the law, and never once said it would be obsolete after his crucifixion.
Why would the Church invent a person so inconvenient to their own dogma? It is the ultimate criterion of embarrassment — of the very canonizers themselves!
They only would have done it if the original founder of the Way realy existed and was a Jewish teacher who taught Jews. Why else would they invent something so seemingly at odds with their own teachings that people throughout the centuries (like Thomas Jefferson) called Paul “the great corruptor of Christianity”?
I would further say that the original Church of Jesus existed in Jerusalem and was led by his brother James and also by Peter. They told Paul that rumors have come that he is teaching Jews to turn away from the Law, and told him to pay for some purification rites to show this is not true. Paul obliged. They also penned a letter to Gentile Believers which Paul was to take to them, invoking the Holy Spirit and instructing them in essentially the Noahide Laws. Paul in his letter to the Galatians however said they had “nothing to add” to his message excep that he “remember the poor, something I have been eager to do all along”.
In short, the founder existed, the Church existed, and would have been the dominant Church if not for the Judaic wars and the destruction that happened as a result.
I think that Christianity as we know it today, came from those beginnings and then spread to other churches.
- grumpydba 8y ago> Jesus said “follow the Law”. He always taught to follow the law, and never once said it would be obsolete after his crucifixion He said the law would not change until all is accomplished. After drinking the vinegar, before dying, he said "all is accomplished". Paul's teachings are thus consistent with this.
- EGreg 8y agoNo, that's only if you read the English translation. In the original Greek, the two words are very different. The original context is from Matthew 5:18, which could potentially have been written in Hebrew: "17 “Do not think that I came to destroy the Law or the Prophets. I did not come to destroy but to fulfill. 18 For assuredly, I say to you, till heaven and earth pass away, one [a]jot or one [b]tittle will by no means pass from the law till all is fulfilled. 19 Whoever therefore breaks one of the least of these commandments, and teaches men so, shall be called least in the kingdom of heaven; but whoever does and teaches them, he shall be called great in the kingdom of heaven. 20 For I say to you, that unless your righteousness exceeds the righteousness of the scribes and Pharisees, you will by no means enter the kingdom of heaven." Notice a few things: 1) Heaven and Earth have not yet passed away, many Christians ignore this part completely, but it needs to be explained why it was mentioned. It would seem the obvious reason is that "all will be accomplished" around the time that Heaven and Earth will pass away, including spreading the gospel to everyone. In another place Jesus says "And this gospel of the kingdom will be preached in the whole world as a testimony to all nations, and then the end will come." 2) Notice that even those who ARE in Heaven will be called Least if they set aside even the smallest commandment and teach others to do so. Thus, even Christians need to be concerned with the Law. Literally nowhere did Jesus even bring up the idea that the Law will be obsolete. That is an idea originated by Paul.
- i-am-that-i-am 8y agoMy understanding is that Jesus was talking specifically about the moral law, that which is "written on our hearts."
- EGreg 8y agoThat is a distinction made later, it's nowhere in the Bible even. Certainly never mentioned by Jesus. He explicitly said people who don't follow even the smallest commandment are to be called least in the kingdom of Heaven. No distinction between moral law or not. And look at James 2:10 he says the same thing, written AFTER Jesus was on the cross!
- 8y ago
- cabaalis 8y agoI'm not a religious scholar but I am religious. > Jesus said “follow the Law”. He always taught to follow the law, and never once said it would be obsolete after his crucifixion. I've always interpreted those conversations to be Jesus attempting to spread an idea that the religious institutions of the time had lost sight of the message of love and peace in return for control and power. If you read it with Jesus speaking knowing that members of his audience are members of those power groups, you get the sense that he is very, very carefully choosing his words.
- mbfg 8y agoIf you were a maximally powerful being and wanted to explain important concepts to all mankind, would you use such incredibly nuanced wording to do that (if you are even right)? That seems like a horribly terrible plan and implementation.