5 ms·
‘Going where the customer is’: Marketers are coming for messaging apps
- arvidkahl 8y agoSounds like message-based advertisement is essentially crowd-sourcing a gigantic Turing test. Looking forward to trying to figure out if my chat partner who casually mentions another product or service is a sales person or a ML model.
- gumby 8y ago> Marketers want to put ads everywhere — on boats, in Ubers and even inside fortune cookies. Can't wait for good ambient AR so we can wear IRL ad blockers.
- ufo 8y agoYou are assuming that we will be able to install an adblocker to it. I would bet that it would be more common to have AR devices inserting ads instead.
- amiga-workbench 8y agoAnd they'll sequel until somebody legislates against it.
- door5 8y agoWhy not just ban all commercial advertising in public spaces and online? I don't think anyone thinks advertising is a public good, why do we tolerate it?
- TeMPOraL 8y agoI'd very like that, but then again, how much of "public space" is actually public? Most meatspace ads tend to hang off someone's private property. And on-line world is really closer to private than public, as most content is served from privately owned machines.
- xoa 8y ago>I'd very like that, but then again, how much of "public space" is actually public? It's not simply a matter of raw percentage, it's also a matter of advertising value (eyeballs) which is a different question. A significant amount of the most valuable space is publicly regulated, such as along highways. So for example in the US four states ban billboards entirely (Alaska, Hawaii, Maine and Vermont), and it's really nice even just driving through them. For Maine and Vermont (since they share land borders with the rest of the contiguous 48) it actually makes for quite the state border transition in some cases, where leaving you suddenly cross and instantly face a pile of advertising. It doesn't have to be that way though, and as a quality of life goal it wouldn't be wrong for people in other states to give it some thought. Constant ads IRL may somewhat fade into the background just as in other contexts, but that doesn't mean it has no impact.
- walterbell 8y agoDo other states earn tax revenue from billboards? Why did those four states ban billboards?
- gumby 8y agoThey banned them on aesthetic grounds. There was a move in the 1960s led by the wife of President Johnson to get rid of them. One success was, I believe, a freeze on erecting new ones on interstate highways. I don't know how well that worked, but they don't seem to be the worst offenders.
- onlyrealcuzzo 8y agoOutdoor advertising is obnoxious and not very affective compared to targeted advertising. I wish cities that are advertising hubs would ban them, to further their lead in developing a newer more effective, less obnoxious ad industry.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- gumby 8y agoI'd be in favor, but it would be hard as some public things are funded that way (e.g. toilets and bus shelters) which would cause some resistance. Still it's a good cause.
- Big_crimpin 8y agoAs each day passes, I wish more people in marketing would put as much effort into something that benefits society instead of eroding it.
- adetrest 8y agoWhile I agree that marketing and advertising is bad for the world, suicide is no joke. Words can have big consequences, especially online when they can reach so many and you can't see who reads them.
- Big_crimpin 8y agoFair point, edited.
- josteink 8y agoMake that a messaging service I won’t use.
- mikenew 8y ago> Canning said he expected Facebook to continue leading the way with chatbots and ads in Messenger, along with WhatsApp I think Facebook has truly pioneered the worst form of advertising. Compare it to YouTube. YT puts ads at the beginning of videos, and tries to make the ad as relevant to the video's audience as possible. They're still ads, they're still annoying, but at least they are clearly and obviously ads. It also incentivizes good content. Both the audience, the content creator, YT, and the advertiser benefit from the videos being as high quality and engaging as possible. Facebook does the opposite. The vast majority of the advertising spend on Facebook is to "boost" a post, which just means that Facebook biases the algorithm to cause the post to be more visible to more people than it otherwise would be. This means that 1) that post pays money to displace other content. Content that the viewer would have enjoyed more. Generally it's organic content from actual friends. 2) that post is in no way marked as an advertisement. The viewer does not know that someone is paying money to influence them. Something as simple as "<friend> likes <company>" can be shown in your news feed just because that company is paying money to show you that. It's as if someone paid your friends to say things like "wow, I love McDonalds" when they're around you. Except that both you and your friend don't know they only said that because McDonalds paid for it. It's deeply manipulative. And there's really no line between advertising for some company selling a product and advertising for a political candidate or platform. The fact that they want to expand into private conversations is genuinely scary.
- lotsofpulp 8y agoHow do you know the YT content creator isn't paid for saying or showing something in the video?
- mikenew 8y agoThey often are. But it's not something that's fundamentally built into the platform like it is on Facebook. YouTube receives no benefit from it so they certainly don't promote it, and the audience discourages it too because they feel like they're watching dishonest content. So yes, it happens, but it's outside the control of YouTube. Facebook fully embraces it. They've built their entire platform around it.
- SpaceManNabs 8y agoOne of the many reasons in why I aggressively push all my friends to use Signal.
- xte 8y agoI do my best to avoid messaging apps, for people willing to contact me I have mail (with proper tons of aliases and filtering) otherwise plain SMS.