4 ms·
> We will soon begin blocking access to our service from IP addresses associated with an embargoed country. Users who travel to a sanctioned country may not be
by Wowfunhappy 8y ago
> We will soon begin blocking access to our service from IP addresses associated with an embargoed country. Users who travel to a sanctioned country may not be able to access Slack while they remain in that country.
Is Slack legally required to do this? As long as they aren't knowingly accepting payment from these countries, shouldn't they be in the clear?
How are other tech companies dealing with this? Does Google block access from embargoed countries? Does Windows refuse to work?
- pests 8y agoNo it only does Google do it themselves but if you host at GCP then they automatically do it for you as well.
- da_chicken 8y ago> Is Slack legally required to do this? Yes, absolutely. Breaking sanctions is not just illegal, it's a criminal offense. There have been sanctions against Iran since roughly when Trump withdrew the US from the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action [1] in May of this year. The CFO of Huawei was arrested in Canada per a request by the US because of their dealings with Iran [2]. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joint_Comprehensive_Plan_of_Action https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joint_Comprehensive_Plan_of_Ac... [2]: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-12-05/huawei-cfo-arrested-in-canada-as-u-s-seeks-her-extradition https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-12-05/huawei-cf...
- aaomidi 8y agoThe CFO was arrested in relation to Iran but not because of it. She was arrested because she lied to banks and sold American made technology to Iran. Slack is actually not required to do this as IM applications are exempt from sanctions.
- briandear 8y agoIs Slack just an IM application?
- jkaplowitz 8y agoThe wording of the exemption applies only to personal communications and requires the service to be available at no cost to the user. There are plausible readings that Slack goes well beyond the exemption. Still, even though the sanctions rules may apply, I'm glad Slack is reversing their overbroad application of these rules.
- jldugger 8y agoIf a company like IBM or Amazon were to adopt slack, would that potentially require Slack to ban things? Both have government contracts, and could potentially export sensitive software to Iran this way accidentally.
- dogecoinbase 8y agoNope -- the stipulations of the licensing policy on Internet freedom in Iran are still in effect: https://www.treasury.gov/resource-center/sanctions/Programs/Documents/internet_freedom.pdf https://www.treasury.gov/resource-center/sanctions/Programs/... See specific of the current application of the rules here: https://www.treasury.gov/resource-center/faqs/Sanctions/Pages/faq_iran.aspx#gld1 https://www.treasury.gov/resource-center/faqs/Sanctions/Page... "Specifically, section 560.540 of the ITR authorizes the exportation from the United States or by U.S. persons, wherever located, to persons in Iran of services incident to the exchange of personal communications over the Internet, such as instant messaging, chat and email, social networking, sharing of photos and movies, web browsing, and blogging, provided that such services are publicly available at no cost to the user."
- jkaplowitz 8y agoThat says "personal communications". Slack is aimed at businesses, not personal use. It also requires "no cost to the user." Very well may not exempt their business model, though some room for argument exists. Of course, any sanctions regime that does still apply wouldn't require the collateral damage of Slack's excessive initial ban.
- nulbyte 8y agoCorporations and other business entities are persons. Also, the license applies to services for a fee. Also, exchanging information isn't embargoed.
- jkaplowitz 8y agoThe "corporations are people" thing is exaggerated in a lot of understandings, and I doubt corporations are deemed capable of "personal communications". Still, personal communications might be found to cover the communication among persons at the companies. But Slack does support a lot more than just people chatting with people, like bot and app/SaaS integrations. Those clearly aren't personal communications and frequently accomplish more than just exchanging information. Good catch that the license does have provisions for fee-based services as well. However, the person I was replying to quoted the one for no-cost services, so that's what I focused on in my reply.
- ehsankia 8y agoI used Google Maps and most other google apps fine while in Iran. Youtube and some other sites are blocked, but that's actually from the Iran side. Of course these are all free services, I assume I could not have actually paid for any paid services. EDIT: I know that Google AppEngine and probably Cloud are blocked, because they provide foreign nation with "computing resources", but that's also its own different bucket.
- curiousgal 8y agoI honestly don't see the point of blocking simple users because of a political conflict, i.e. between governments. One answer that jumps to mind is that those governments are merely a representative of those users but in the case of Iran, we know what happened when people elected their leaders, so it's kinda hypocritical from that regard to punish users because of a leader we placed.
- skywhopper 8y agoYes, I work for a SaaS provider and we maintain blocks on access from a short list of embargoed countries.
- bastardoperator 8y agoCan’t publically trade your stock if your house isn’t in order.
- morpheuskafka 8y agoI thought embargoes didn't apply to information anyway? You're still allowed to text someone in Cuba or even call North Korea, so how come Slack is banned?
- dylan604 8y agoTexts/SMS/voice calls etc are not encrypted. The NSA slurps that data up like a sponge wrapped in Brawny wrapped in a ShamWow. There's a huge list of why we can't export/sale things to certain countries, but encryption is one of them. Things that seem "innocent" enough like a hardware video box might qualify as embargoed because it has the ability to decode SSL network traffic. Can't let that tech get in the hands of the "enemy".
- roblabla 8y agoEncryption is not considered ammo since forever now. And slack doesn't have E2E encryption, and is an american company. The NSA can just knock on the front door and ask for the data, same as they would for an ISP.
- morpheuskafka 8y agoBut what encryption does Slack actually ship? If it just uses SSL then that is being done by the browser not the Slack JS code.
- toast0 8y agoMy understanding is that there is a general license for telecommunications with embargoed countries, so I suspect that this is not legally required, but perhaps Slack doesn't care to fight for it. Phone calls, SMS, and the like work fine enough to embargoed countries (although North Korea doesn't allow that, except to a very limited set of phone numbers, mostly consolates), and that likely involves payments between phone companies in the embargoed countries and in the US. I'm aware that Softlayer (IBM) blocks traffic to embargoed countries by default, but has a process to allow traffic, given documentation of exemption.
- Gibbon1 8y ago> Is Slack legally required to do this? No, the reason is Saudi Arabia told them to. > The Crown Prince also invested $45 billion into a SoftBank subsidiary, the Vision Fund, which made subsequent investments in a number of US tech companies. The Vision Fund made significant investments into Slack, DoorDash, and Nvidia. Slack declined to comment and DoorDash did respond to a request for comment as of publication.
- NelsonMinar 8y agoI'd ask you if you had any evidence for this claim, but of course you don't. You have a very odd view of how investments work. Perhaps MBS went straight from ordering Kashoggi's execution to getting a random Iranian banned from an Internet chat system.