6 ms·
> the government pulled the plug on 1 billion euros ($1.1 billion) in annual subsidies I know the politics of countries outside the US are quite different, but
by exabrial 8y ago
> the government pulled the plug on 1 billion euros ($1.1 billion) in annual subsidies
I know the politics of countries outside the US are quite different, but I'm a huge fan of things like this statement. I truly think the best place for that money is to never leave the taxpayer's pocket.
- jswizzy 8y agoHayek would agree. It's better to let resources be used efficiently than to create artificial demand via subsidies.
- pgeorgi 8y agoHaving worked in the odd megacorp (and those tend to run the show), "efficient use of resources" isn't the first thing that comes to my mind when it comes to the private sector.
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoMaybe not. But giving money to those who are too inefficient to compete, even by the standards of the private sector, seems almost certain to be wasteful.
- briandear 8y agoHave you ever worked in government?
- ACow_Adonis 8y agoI've worked in both. And i've got an economics education :P My experience tells me entity-scale is the main variable that determines efficient use of resources (all other things being equal), rather than private/public sector divide. Which makes sense if you think about it: once you get away from small groups and sole individuals being able to give all things their attention, a private company has to effectively re-implement a form of government to operate internally.
- michaelt 8y agoThe main variable that determines efficient use of resources all other things being equal, you say?
- kodablah 8y ago> entity-scale is the main variable [...] Which makes sense if you think about it While it may arguably be the main variable, and definitely the main variable within a sector, it shouldn't be used to discount the importance of goals/motivations/incentives. Although there are plenty of examples to the contrary in either direction, I think most also with experience would agree there is more waste and less accountability on one side compared to the other.
- ACow_Adonis 8y agoIncentives, culture, mechanics, motivations, personalities, beliefs, scope, competition: all of those things play additional parts. And there's good governance and strategy and bad governance and strategy that applies at all those institutions at all levels and size. I can't really agree with the "more waste and less accountability on one side compared to the other", but that's primarily because the terms/measurements are so poorly defined and they differ so much country to country, state to state and with subject matter, and as I said, I believe that as institutions grow/mature, private industry must implement government anyway. I guess what i'd rail against most is the idea that its the private/public idea itself that plays the significant part in efficiency and productivity: the idea that subsidising private industry, public-private partnerships, or privatising certain public roles or firms/industries somehow magically, by itself, makes things "more efficient". If i were to reflect back on my own career, of the three top efficient organizations, two were medium-sized government departments, and the third was a small team non-profit of about 5 on a small government funding arrangement. Worst three were all private industry: big corp, big consultancy, little firm (although, admittedly, funded by government). Private industry had a huge problem with people being motivated by profits, rather than doing the job: hence directly incentivizing a seeking of inefficiency if not in a fully competitive market (which in the real world, is most markets these days, and certainly most markets with players of any scale). There's a couple of throw-away populist lines I could give about the secret of efficiency I've observed, but i'll chose three: motivation/incentives, devolve responsibility down to the person best able to make the decision, and preference hands off and less work over more (which, to me, is almost the secret success of efficient free-market economies, the ability to just step back and use organic structures to just let things happen).
- dev_dull 8y agoOr simply walked into the DMV.
- yongjik 8y ago1. Say "government is inefficient" and refuse to allocate resource to fix it. 2. Be angry that government is inefficient. 3. Goto step 1. Have you been to (the equivalent of) DMV in other countries?
- BenderV 8y agoHave you been to France?
- BenderV 8y agoGovernment spending > 50% of GDP. Is it efficient?
- kerkeslager 8y agoThat depends what benefits you get from it. Efficiency is a fraction: cost over benefit. You can't just whine about cost and use the word "efficiency". That's cost, not efficiency, and you're completely ignoring the entire point of money in the first place: to be spent to achieve benefit.
- icantdrive55 8y agoDon't forget free healthcare, education, work/privacy laws that put most countries to shame, decent homless shelters. They live longer. They are happier on every metric compare to Americans. I never berate France, once I realized just how terrible we do things here. (Up, or down vote me; I think I'm shadowbanned? And yes--to lazy to check myself.)
- aetherson 8y agoThis seems weird, if we're talking about the same definition of efficiency, which I would say is the resources, denominated in money, needed to produce a given result. So let's say that the government produces one driver's license per $100, and I'm angry that it costs that much. Your proposal is that I will be happy if I instead spend $120 per license?
- chiefalchemist 8y agoLet say you're correct, then it's all the more reason __not__ to over-subsidize something. It's one thing for a gov to toss some money at something to encourage R&D, the growth of a technology and/or market, etc. That makes at least some sense in some cases. The problem is these "temporary" gov programs never end. And then eventually they live long past their prime. Furthermore, as the become the new normal they tend to create unintended consequence. For example, farm subsidies for corn drove down the price of high fructose corn syrup. That made the sweetener ubiquitous. Similar can be said for home loans and student loans. Once these programs take on a life of their own, the market becomes distorted and eventually bad - unforeseen - things happen.
- anonacct37 8y agoIn my state (Utah). The government is attempting to roll back solar subsidies because "that industry should stand on it's own two feet". Conveniently neglecting to mention the massive tax breaks to fossil fuels. I wish everyone competed in a free market (for the most part), but the energy market is not that.
- paulddraper 8y agoThis comment is conveniently forgetting that Utah taxes gas. In fact, one of the ballot items was the increase this tax.
- freehunter 8y agoTaxing the use of something is different from subsidizing the production of that thing and are meant to encourage far different behaviors.
- munk-a 8y agoNo, the tax would end up eventually hurting their profit margins while the subsidies increase those margins. They encourage different short term effects but they're both contributing to the same effect. All that said, the subsidies in this case far outweighed the effect the tax would have had.
- narrator 8y agoA lot of that ptivate sector inefficiency is because big companies have the artificially cheap ability to fundraise thanks to access to the public markets.
- munk-a 8y agoThis is an amazingly carefully worded comment about the legal bribery allowed in the US.
- jkingsbery 8y agoWhile I think that's fair, the article hints at subsidies for other fuel sources which would also distort the market. Any idea what the energy market in Germany would have looked like absent subsidies entirely?
- chiefalchemist 8y agoI saw that as well. But I would think, that if you're going to pick a market to distort then renewables (i.e., the future) makes more sense than keeping coal alive. Also, as the article mentioned, there were political overtones to cutting out coal.
- akie 8y agoBetter for who?
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoFor the economy as a whole, which means for most people. For those employed by the inefficient business that will no longer be subsidized, well, it may not be better for them, at least not in the short run.
- hannasanarion 8y agoOnly if you define "better" as having the lowest price. Free mariets don't magically remove the disconnect between individual interests and collective interests (tragedy of the commons). The economic optimum is not guaranteed to coincide with social, moral, qnd political optimums
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoWell, I don't define "better" as having the higher price. From the point of view of the economy as a whole, efficient is better than inefficient, because it can produce more outputs for the same inputs. This isn't just abstract - people can use those outputs. Tragedy of the commons is an issue, but subsidizing a coal mine doesn't seem much like a tragedy of the commons issue to me. It seems more like your last words: a "political optimum", that is, something that produced votes, because the mine owners and workers want the subsidies much more strongly than the taxpayers want to not have to pay. That may be politically optimum, but it's not morally, socially, or economically optimum.
- programmarchy 8y agoSo you disagree with solar energy subsidies, then? Nations have other motives than economic efficiency. The state should lead the market to meet national goals like clean energy infrastructure. Coal subsidies are a way to increase military strength, or at least they used to be. War needs steel needs coal. That may no longer be the case with more advanced ways of creating steel without coal.
- duxup 8y agoWould it change if it subsided a policy you liked? Perhaps not for you, I feel like the augment about "hey we shouldn't subside that" is often tied to if someone likes it or not. But other subsides are ok...
- mikeash 8y agoIt’s no real surprise that people want to subsidize things they think are good and not subsidize things they think are bad.
- kodablah 8y agoCan be, as many people don't even want to subsidize things that they consider good (I'm often in that camp). But I think the surprise for many people is that good and bad are not the same for others as they are for themselves, especially wrt public funding.
- supercheetah 8y agoI'd rather see that money go towards paid training for workers like the coal miners in the article, and investment into the renewables industry they would be going into.
- matt4077 8y agoThat’s actually what happened. The long timeline also allowed them to adapt: everyone trained in mines in the last two decades earned an education that’s transferable to work outside the mines.
- johannes1234321 8y agoThere are different aspects in this, some which come to mind: * Coal is the main local energy source. Other sources have to be imported. Having coal mining gives some degree of independence from Arab Oil, Russian gas and Nigerian Uranium. * By subsadies over some time the economic change can be controlled to see degree instead of setting free about half a million mine workers, of which many had low qualifications, and a bunch of people in dependent industries free at once. The Ruhr area was fully dependent on coal mines as reason for the area's growth and hand hardly any non-coal related industry.
- b3orn 8y agoThat's approximately 20€ a year per taxpayer.
- nasmorn 8y agoBut it is also 700k per job
- Spooky23 8y agoThe government has a duty to promote the general welfare of the country. Stable markets are a big part of that. The idea of not subsidizing things is attractive, but the people pushing those ideas usually are really rooting for market instability, which benefits them directly at a cost to society. For example, much of the hoohah behind current US government trade policy is about eliminating domestic competition. In agriculture, for example, small/medium dairy is in the process of being erased.