2 ms·
I wonder how many stories suffer "mutations" that break them from their previous incarnations. The article mentions "The Smith and The Devil", and speculates th
by pavel_lishin 8y ago
I wonder how many stories suffer "mutations" that break them from their previous incarnations. The article mentions "The Smith and The Devil", and speculates that metal-working technology would have been around at the time of its origin, but I'm not sure if that's any more likely than the profession of the protagonist changing over time.
At the very least, in Russia there are many tales of Ivan outwitting the Devil, regardless of his profession. Maybe that's just a horizontal transfer and the story taking advantage of a previously unoccupied memetic niche...
- krapp 8y agoMany of these stories were part of oral traditions before being written down and "canonized" by certain authors (sometimes to Christianize existing pagan folklore, as happened with Norse mythology) so mutation seems likely across generations and local cultures.