4 ms·
I'm still very surprised that any of this is true. This definitely seems like a booby-trap device situation to me, and I wouldn't risk leaving it out in front o
by pavel_lishin 8y ago
I'm still very surprised that any of this is true. This definitely seems like a booby-trap device situation to me, and I wouldn't risk leaving it out in front of my house.
- recursive 8y agoI'm not. I would. It's pretty harmless. The chance of serious injury seems lower than that of crossing a busy street.
- justtopost 8y agoGlitter in the eye is not harmeless, I know someone blind in one eye as a result. There is genuine liability here, even if not super obvious.
- recursive 8y agoCrossing a busy road is not harmless. I know of someone that literally died attempting to do it.
- yourapostasy 8y agoHopefully covered by the same laws that protect banks that use dye packs. Porch bandits are entering private property that is not theirs and not by invitation, then stealing private property. Instead of pot smoking convictions, I'd rather see more prison time for porch bandits caught by dye pack-like bait packages.
- pavel_lishin 8y agoI'm not shedding tears for people who break their legs trying to jump a fence into someone's backyard so they can steal their TV, but the laws are what they are. I can't exactly put down Home Alone style traps in my house; I'm not sure why this is any different.
- jrockway 8y agoI think the difference is degree of injury. Having glitter in your car is a lot different than having a bullet through your face, which is where the booby trap case law comes from.
- tjoff 8y agoYes, but... What if the passenger opened the package while the car was being driven, and the commotion with the glitter and fart bomb (and perhaps a exaggerated response by the passenger) might contribute to an accident. Maybe the smell and the shame might make the thief stressed and make bad decisions in traffic. Both scenarios might seem silly, but I think they are in quite a different legal light when there is intent to disrupt.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ufmace 8y agoIt's about the degree of harm. Spreading glitter and fart spray in somebody's car doesn't really hurt anybody, and it's very unlikely anyone would prosecute over it, no matter what the circumstances were. Breaking someone's legs is very different in the eyes of the law. Booby traps are generally illegal because they are indiscriminate. It may be justified self-defense to hurt somebody, even to a crippling or lethal level, if you knew it was necessary to save your life or prevent some other serious violent felony. Booby traps could harm anyone, regardless of their intent. If you were to set up a shotgun trap to fire on anybody who opens your door wrong, for example, it might kill a burglar or rapist. Or it might kill a fireman, cop, paramedic, pushy salesman, handyman, etc. Even if you don't want some of the previous in your home, you can't shoot them to keep them out, at least not without requesting them to leave and going through a chain of escalation first. Even booby traps that aren't that harmful could cause a lot more damage than expected if somebody very old, very young, disabled, or otherwise more physically vulnerable happens into them. So you can (at least in the US) defend your home yourself with an appropriate amount of force, including lethal force if the situation calls for it. But only because it's you making a reasonable judgement about the appropriateness of the force involved. You can't set a booby trap to harm anyone who goes to the wrong place, regardless of who they are or what their intent is.
- smileysteve 8y agoThere are obvious design decisions that make it safer than it could be; if the glitter were powered by an explosive device or had glue in it, it would obviously be more effective though less reusable.