3 ms·
> when things point down, I'm also happy because I know that means I'm about to get a really good deal on shares which I can later sell for lots. That's not ho
by dragontamer 8y ago
> when things point down, I'm also happy because I know that means I'm about to get a really good deal on shares which I can later sell for lots.
That's not how recessions work.
When a general recession happens, there is a high chance you will lose your job. So when the stock market goes down, you are forced to withdraw money from your stocks to pay your mortgage / rent, or other living expenses.
And that's why people hold onto bonds: so that you have something to sell during a recession. If you are 100% into stocks, you won't have anything to sell when the recession starts. Bonds often go up during a recession (but not always: 2008 Municipal Bonds + Corporate Bonds went down. But US Treasuries did go up, so anyone holding onto Treasuries in 2007ish would have done well during the recession)
--------------
Lets start with a hypothetical recession, where the general unemployment rate increases from (currently) 3.7%, to 10%. With 3x as many unemployed people as right now, a measured drop in enetertainment services (Netflix, Movies, Cruises, Vacation spots, etc. etc.) usually happens.
So expect Netflix, Disney (vacations + movies), AMC, Sysco (Restaurant company), malls, shopping areas to all ALSO lay off staff.
Which will eventually have an impact on the tech industry: Netflix buys fewer computers from Amazon. Microsoft slows production / maintenance of Windows. Tech Companies start to fire free-lancers and contractors (and focus on core staff only).
The hardest hit places lose lots of people. Ex: Detroit had a MILLION people leave the city and surrounding area during the 2008 recession. Property values drop dramatically, rents fall. Landowners lose their income streams and are unable to sell homes or find new tenants.
THAT is a recession. A huge number of things (stocks, real estate, even employees) in the USA loses value and are shed off. If you're worried about your stock account numbers, you aren't really in a recession yet. People are worried about their actual jobs and daily livelihood during recessions. In effect, the ones who can afford to buy up the stocks were the lucky ones, who weren't hit by the recession.
--------------
By definition, a recession is over after a year or two. Which is why people say you need to keep your emergency savings in cash.
A depression may last longer than that: several years or even a full decade. (Ex: the entire 1930s)
So the only way you have money to spend on the Stock Market, is if you saved up money beforehand. IE: You have some bonds to sell, or you managed to predict the recession and hold onto cash. Your job income isn't necessarily safe during a recession (or worse: a depression)
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- kqr 8y agoThis was a very sobering and well-presented perspective. You bring up some critical points I hadn't considered, and I'm very thankful for it. I have quite a bit of emergency savings in cash, but you shone a light on the whole long-term vs. short-term, high-risk vs low-risk thing that I had previously understood on a mathematical level, but not how it would apply to, well, me.
- marketgod 8y agoLook up Bogleheads and their Lazy Portfolios, this may help you understand some different scenarios. https://www.bogleheads.org/wiki/Lazy_portfolios https://www.bogleheads.org/wiki/Lazy_portfolios