I would say your comment was the unfair one. Sure, it cannot tell the weather without internet. But it can still do plenty of more important home automation fun

I would say your comment was the unfair one. Sure, it cannot tell the weather without internet. But it can still do plenty of more important home automation functions, namely automation. No one owns one of these home assistants for it to tell the weather. You get it for controlling other devices with your voice and this can do that without access to thr world wide web.