4 ms·
I'd always thought of butter as being mostly odourless, until at some point aged 30+ I accidentally bought some that actually smelled of something - and, who kn
by tom_ 8y ago
I'd always thought of butter as being mostly odourless, until at some point aged 30+ I accidentally bought some that actually smelled of something - and, who knew! It was a huge surprise.
I have ever since always sought this out - unpasteurised salted French PDO stuff seems to be the thing to go for - but while I now know that it is possible to get butter that smells of something, and I now know I like it, I'm still not sure I'd class butter in general as something that smells of anything in particular.
This line of thought did remind me of this article I read a few years ago, though: https://slate.com/human-interest/2011/05/eating-cheese-in-china.html https://slate.com/human-interest/2011/05/eating-cheese-in-ch...
"Another said that the selection “smells like Russians”. “The difference,” he added, “is that the stinky things Chinese people eat give them smelly breath, while stinky dairy things affect the sweat that comes out of your skin.”"
(It's possible this is some genetic thing. I worked with a guy recently who would refuse to eat cucumber, on account of its strong taste and aroma, that would taint anything with which it came into contact! - meanwhile, I always thought cucumber rather watery and tasteless. Maybe very slightly gently peppery, if you got a good one that was particularly strong-tasting... by cucumber standards, at any rate.)
- colanderman 8y agoI also didn't think butter had a strong smell until I removed it from my diet entirely (became vegan). It's a strong and unique odor, especially when warm. I can often smell it well before I visually identify the source.
- n4r9 8y agoI found that part surprising. I think I know what butter smells like, but for it (and the rest of that list) to come above blue cheese and sulfur?? Incredible.
- taejo 8y agoThe list is the most smellable things by detection threshold, which is quite different from perceived intensity (many compounds have quite a low threshold above which they don't smell any stronger). It wasn't clear to me whether the author was aware of this distinction.