4 ms·
> He refused to pay, and the matter was ultimately dropped. A description of the ultimate disposition is what's missing from most of these "huge bill" stories.
by mindslight 8y ago
> He refused to pay, and the matter was ultimately dropped.
A description of the ultimate disposition is what's missing from most of these "huge bill" stories. I'm glad to see it was stated here that he straight up refused to pay, as he should have. And really this should be standard advice repeated in all of these healthcare-cost articles, perhaps along side references to form letters people can send to repudiate fraudulent charges. Barring an actual contract to render services, a hospital's position is the same as a busker playing an instrument at a subway stop!
But what really needs to start happening is for these hospitals to start being prosecuted for (attempted) fraud. You shouldn't be able to send fake bills to people in bad faith, and when you're called out just back off and have everything be fine.
- jpatokal 8y agoYou can refuse to pay, but they can still send the bill to collections and wreck your credit. Also, the hospital did actually perform work here, the crazy part is that they're billing the innocent suspect instead of the police here.
- mindslight 8y agoBut the hospital has no contract whatsoever with the suspect. All work was performed at the behest of the police. I can't just send you a bill for replying to your comment (saying it was done "for you") and have you be obligated to pay it! It seems like a collections agency that keeps pushing an invalid debt is part of a conspiracy to commit fraud. And a report to the surveillance bureaus that "wrecks your credit" would be straightforward slander. Most of the behavior here is best described by some very basic crimes. Why are we letting these organizations off the hook?
- lovich 8y agoThey're richer than regular people and can use that money to influence the laws that are made and influence prosecutors from going after them. It's a glib response, but is there any other explanation that fits the observable data? If a random citizen performed the same actions against these organizations, does anyone here believe the citizen would get away with no issues?
- yayana 8y agoThe crazy part is that a doctor willingly violated the Hippocratic Oath in a state that could do virtually nothing to him for following the ethics of his profession. Mr Jackson should use civil rights group lawyers to go after that doctor.
- yellowapple 8y agoPer the article, the hospital did refuse, at least at first, probably on those grounds.
- yayana 8y agoPer the article, the police then got legal rights against the patient's right to refuse, which means nothing to a doctor when it comes to an obligation of inaction.
- cwkoss 8y agoThere should be statutory fines for a business falsely claiming that someone owes them money, or claiming they owe an incorrect amount.
- brianpgordon 8y agoThe entire medical billing industry's standard practice is to shotgun out first-draft bills that bear little resemblance to reality and hope people are dumb enough to pay. I'm sure they save a bunch of money by not having to fix their buggy processes. Instead they get to outsource their work to patients who have to figure out the bills on their own initiative and come up with specific objections because their credit is on the line. I've had all of the following happen to me in the last few years: - I get a bill in the mail for an ER visit and it's ludicrously high. I call the hospital and ask if a human has seen it or if it was just auto-generated. They tiredly take down my name as if this is the tenth time today, and promise a human will look into it. A week later I get a revised bill for a fraction of the original amount. - I get a check for over $400 from the same hospital in the mail one day. A photocopied "to whom it may concern" note on a little slip of paper explains: "It has been determined that an overpayment is owed to you. Please see the enclosed check. Thank you." No other explanation or even a perfunctory "sorry we kept your money interest-free for a year." - I get a medication partially covered by insurance and partially covered by copay assistance from the drug company, so that I pay nothing. A couple of weeks after starting it, I get a bill in the mail from CVS for a couple of hundred dollars. Oops. It's a billing error and I actually owe nothing, but now it's my responsibility to sort everything out between the various parties. - I get a call out of the blue (flagged by Android as a suspected spam caller) from someone claiming to be a collections agency trying to collect a few hundred dollars for a blood test I don't even remember at first. They say they're the second collections agency who inherited this bill. I never got anything in the mail and this is the first I'm hearing of it, so I'm naturally suspicious, but they have all of my information and describe the blood test and it does sound familiar. I tell them to send me a bill - obviously I'm not going to give out my credit card number to a random caller. They call back the next week, again wanting me to settle the debt over the phone. I ask for a bill. They say they sent one. But I've still never gotten anything in the mail. Now I'm anxiously watching my credit report and hoping the reporting agencies will believe me when I tell them I was never billed. Everything about this is a gigantic clusterfuck. The last thing we need is even higher healthcare costs, but this industry's behavior is so completely and hopelessly broken that if someone puts a shareholder-crushing mountain of additional patient protection regulation on the ballot, I'll vote for it out of sheer spite. But seriously, we desperately need single-payer to cut through this rainforest of billing bureaucracy. This is less like a functioning society than like a Kafka novel come to life.