4 ms·
Well, I don't speak Greek and understand the historical meaning of Greek terms even less, but I think Jaynes' thesis is that every term we now associate with th
by the_af 8y ago
Well, I don't speak Greek and understand the historical meaning of Greek terms even less, but I think Jaynes' thesis is that every term we now associate with the mind and with inner emotions was meant in the Illiad to be more like a physical or even an external command of "the Gods" (see his discussion of psyche and thumos).
That is, while it's now obvious to us these were emotions, the authors of the Illiad didn't perceive them as such -- or so I understand Jaynes argued -- and instead they thought they were either physical things (much like a stomach ache) or a command of "the Gods".
If you speak Greek, what's the exact term for "rage" as written in the Illiad?
----
edit: ok, found it. Jaynes claims this:
"Even the poem itself is not wrought by men in our sense. Its first three words are Menin aedie Thea, 'Of wrath sing, O Goddess!' And the entire epic which follows is the song of the goddess which the entranced bard 'heard' and chanted to his iron-age listeners among the ruins of Agamemnon's world."
I find it a bit disappointing because even if the singer didn't ascribe feelings to men, he must at least understand the meaning of "wrath" itself. And it seems to me it must be hard to understand this emotion unless you can feel it.