4 ms·
These iPads can easily be bent in half with bare hands: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hUBsxCcJeUc&t=385 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hUBsxCcJeUc&t=385 Do
by CydeWeys 8y ago
These iPads can easily be bent in half with bare hands: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hUBsxCcJeUc&t=385 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hUBsxCcJeUc&t=385
Doesn't bode well for them holding up in, e.g., a backpack or briefcase that ends up being sat or stepped on. Or even just being shoved into an overhead compartment or beneath a seat.
- reaperducer 8y agoThese iPads can easily be bent in half with bare hands Why would you want to? I just don't understand the way people treat their tech devices these days. I see millennials putting iPhones in their back pockets and then wondering why the screen shatters when they sit down. You are putting a piece of glass against your butt and sitting on it! I remember when flip phones, digital cameras, floppy disks, and even Atari 2600's were handled with care. Because they would break, and were expensive to replace! Do people act this way because stuff doesn't cost enough? Because paying for stuff with credit makes it seem like it's free, and therefore not worth anything? Or has the magic just gone out of tech for the average butt-storing phone user?
- Techonomicon 8y agoDid you happen to watch the video? He didn't try very hard to break it. It's not like he put it over his knee using all his strength.
- vorpalhex 8y agoYou shouldn't have to treat a $1000 device like it's going to turn into dust. Sure, don't chuck your phone at concrete walls, but in general a phone needs to be able to take a spill occasionally or have someone sit on it because those things happen in real life. It sounds like Apple has sacrificed too much in the name of being thin, and really botched their structural integrity. Devices exist to be used, not kept in a museum.
- isostatic 8y ago> Sure, don't chuck your phone at concrete walls A friend of mine had her horse stand on her phone. Carried on working for the next few days until it needed recharging, found some mud in the connector, cleaned that out, lasted another few years. The nokia 3210 had a lot going for it.
- reaperducer 8y agoYou shouldn't have to treat a $1000 device like it's going to turn into dust. I don't understand the link between price and resistance to damage. If I buy a Faberge egg for $4 million, I don't expect that I can sit on it without causing damage. A friend recently spent $20k on new windows for his house. I don't expect them to be baseball-resistant because they cost more than his previous, cheaper, windows. It sounds like Apple has sacrificed too much in the name of being thin I don't disagree with this. I'd rather have a little thicker laptop in exchange for a better keyboard. But because my laptop cost $4k, I don't expect that I can treat it anyway I like. It's a computer, not a rock.
- wilg 8y ago> I don't understand the link between price and resistance to damage. People expect tablets to be somewhat durable, and they expect the best tablets to be especially so.
- reaperducer 8y agoPeople expect tablets to be somewhat durable, and they expect the best tablets to be especially so. Then why is there a massive market for protective cases and screen protectors?
- scarmig 8y agoThe point is that plenty of manufacturers (including Apple!) have made phones that don't bend if you look at them crooked. And a reasonable hypothesis is that users will migrate to those phones, once/if Apple gets a reputation for unreliability. I'm not so sure, though, between the cult of Apple and consumers' well attested love of device thinness.
- dharmab 8y agoI carry my tech in a cyclists backpack which I wear when riding my bicycle or motorcycle. Increment weather, dust, high winds and extreme heat/near freezing cold are are normal conditions on my way to work. My current laptop was even able to survive an 80mph over-the-bars log roll. Why would I "upgrade" to a device that can't?
- solatic 8y ago> Do people act this way because stuff doesn't cost enough? Cars cost 5-20x+ the price, not to mention fuel and insurance, and people get into car accidents all the time. Cost has nothing to do with it. People aren't robots, they make mistakes. Good mass-market design is life-proof where possible. People will drop their phones, they will forget their phones in the pockets of the pants they just put in the laundry. Designers can either design for humanity as it is, or humanity as they wish it was, and the latter do all of us a disservice.
- CydeWeys 8y agoYou're missing the point of the video. It's not that you would intentionally bend it in half with your bare hands, it's that if it's so flimsy that that's trivial then it's flimsy enough to not withstand common accidental loads. I'm not going to buy an expensive portable piece of electronics that can't survive being in a backpack. I do own expensive fragile things, but they stay on a shelf in my apartment. No way in hell would I bring them out into the world with me every day where they can be easily destroyed. This isn't "millennials'" fault for being less careful with things; it's a simple failure of industrial engineering. And no, back in your day, people weren't more careful.
- kllrnohj 8y ago> I remember when flip phones, digital cameras, floppy disks, and even Atari 2600's were handled with care. Because they would break, and were expensive to replace! What on earth are you talking about? The meme of indestructible nokia phones came about because people treated flip phones terribly. People used to toss phones & cameras into bags all the time back in the day. And unsurprisingly they still do. If anything younger generations are better at this than older ones as they are used to tech being fragile instead of the indestructible tanks of a decade+ ago.
- reaperducer 8y agoThe meme of indestructible nokia phones came about because people treated flip phones terribly. Amazingly, there were other phones on the market besides low-end Nokias.
- jmull 8y agoWell, bend-gate for the 6 plus was fake. Any reason we shouldn't assume this is fake too?
- rhodysurf 8y agobecause there are tons of user reports of ipads bending very easily. Also hes pretty reputable
- FireBeyond 8y agoBecause Apple is agreeing? > Apple has confirmed to The Verge that some of its 2018 iPad Pros are shipping with a very slight bend in the aluminum chassis.
- jmull 8y agoNo, Apple is acknowledging these iPads ship bent due to the manufacturing process, not that they bend easily as the comment I responded to claims.
- reacharavindh 8y agoMay be Apple just made the first foldable tablet ;-) Seriously though, they should add a structural frame even if it means making it slightly heavier and thicker. This is just NOT premium stuff.
- isostatic 8y agoI wonder how long you'd last in an apple store, ask them "Are these strong enough for day to day use", then bend it with your bare hands.
- pasbesoin 8y agoDoes anyone at Apple pay attention to how these things are used, in practice? If you have kids -- for many, even if not -- they will end up being sat upon, even if they do not undergo being thrown around and other rough handling. Speaking of which, what happens when two kids are fighting over the tablet? They grab on, and... I don't have kids. I've observed my friends' kids interacting, upon occasion. So, I am wondering about this. Do cases provide enough added rigidity to these thinner models?
- Someone 8y agoSeems they could make it a bit stronger by glueing the batteries to the display (and, if that isn’t done yet, to the back plane), at the cost of repairability. In the end, though, there’s little you can do to make a device that thin very strong against bending forces (steel tubes around the edge would make it harder to bend the entire thing, but would use a lot of the volume, add weight, and wouldn’t help much against forces applied to the center of the display) I can see the lure of thinness and its associated decrease in weight, though. If you compare today’s iPad to previous generations, the weight difference feels enormous.
- kllrnohj 8y agoWell they also added structural weaknesses (charge port & microphone hole) to the center of the frame, at the point of highest leverage. Making it easier to bend in half than it should have been. Those should have been re-positioned (microphone hole) or strengthened (charge port).