3 ms·
However, given that judges and a large share of the political pool is drawn from lawyers, I feel that a bit of restraint, understanding and leaning towards impa
by tracker1 8y ago
However, given that judges and a large share of the political pool is drawn from lawyers, I feel that a bit of restraint, understanding and leaning towards impartiality at least from the point of considering all sides is incredibly important.
At the point one becomes a social advocate, they probably shouldn't be running for judicial office at the very least, and maybe reconsider any ambitions of public office at all.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> At the point one becomes a social advocate, they probably shouldn't be running for judicial office at the very least, and maybe reconsider any ambitions of public office at all. Judges (and, a fortiori, judicial candidates) remain citizens and do not surrender their right to participate publicly as citizens; there is a certain degree or restraint and separation of advocacy and judicial role, but (while there is room to debate application in specific cases, and clear places where the existing norms have failed to be applied) there are well-established norms of conflict avoidance and recusal/removal from particular cases that address this. I don't think stronger basic norms are needed here, though more vigrous enforcement of existing norms. As for non-judicial public office, social advocacy is very much what the electorate looks for in candidates for those offices and how it judges them, the idea that anyone involved in social advocacy should avoid such offices is, well, unusual, and it definitely needs more of an argument than you've presented.