7 ms·
Apple confirms some iPad Pros ship slightly bent, but says it’s normal
- gnulinux 8y agoI don't understand... Apple is supposed to be the company that produces premium technology, their products supposed to signal status, it's supposed to be the epitome of aesthetics. How come in the recent years they're doing these easily preventable mistakes? I don't think Apple doesn't have a well-paid QA team. They probably do. So they found this bug and decided to ship it?
- mental1896 8y agoThey probably found it too late and couldn't stomach the idea of recalling it right before Christmas.
- falcolas 8y agoI imagine that, much like LCD screens, the "failure" rate for a reasonable production batch is too high to reject every slightly bent iPad. Still sucks, and I believe it's reasonable that that the iPad pro could still be profitable even with a high reject rate, but not profitable enough.
- psychometry 8y agoTheir obsession with thinness and lightness has stretched their manufacturing QC beyond its breaking point. Almost all of the widespread hardware problems Apple is experiencing these days could've been avoided if they would just allow themselves an extra millimeter or gram here and there.
- Guereric 8y ago>Almost all of the widespread hardware problems Apple is experiencing these days could've been avoided if they would just allow themselves an extra millimeter or gram here and there. That's a bold claim. Can you back up it?
- izzydata 8y ago>That's a bold claim. Can you back up it? They made similar products in the past that were thicker and not easily bendable. That seems to speak for itself.
- pazimzadeh 8y agoThat's true, although their thinnest products always had a small surface area as well (iPod nano), so less torque could be applied which probably contributed to the durability.
- ken 8y agoApple also changes materials and processes all the time. Despite being thicker (and shorter), the iPhone SE bends more easily than newer iPhones like the 6S [1], 7 or 7 Plus [2]. [1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bWRnDVcfA3g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bWRnDVcfA3g [2]: https://www.squaretrade.com/press/SquareTrade-Labs-iPhone-7-Generation-Makes-Splash-Water-Resistance-Still-Falls-Hard https://www.squaretrade.com/press/SquareTrade-Labs-iPhone-7-...
- eridius 8y agoEvery device that supports 3D Touch is highly resistant to bending, because AIUI the way 3D Touch is implemented basically puts a metal plate inside the phone. This is why the iPads never got 3D Touch, because they’d end up too heavy with a metal plate that large.
- scrooched_moose 8y agoIt's basic engineering mechanics. All bending equations come back to the second moment of area [1], which for a rectangle is b*h^3/12. Double the thickness and your object becomes 8 times stiffer. Second gen 10.5" iPad Pro (can't find dimensions for 3rd) is 6.1mm. Change that to 7.1, and it becomes (7.1)^3/(6.1)^3 = 1.58x stiffer. Not indestructible, but a massive improvement for a small change. 1) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second_moment_of_area#Rectangle_with_centroid_at_the_origin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second_moment_of_area#Rectangl...
- samfriedman 8y agoThe bend can be thought of as exactly that: a unique differentiator that adds status and flair to an already desirable item. For a manufacturer as highly lauded as Apple, the opportunity to acquire a one-of-a-kind iPad with a bespoke chassis camber will surely be sought after by consumers. If anything, we should be congratulating those involved for their ability to bring organic design inspiration to the highest echelons of computing; and affordably too!
- jeklj 8y agoUgh
- Isamu 8y ago>easily preventable mistakes Considering that iPads are machined to very high tolerances, they are extremely flat as built, at least early in the process. Also many of the later steps in construction are highly automated, relying on custom fixtures that would tend to detect an out-of-tolerance part. That suggests that bends in the final product happened late somehow, possibly from mishandling in shipping and final packaging. Depending on your quality inspections at that point, a certain number of out-of-tolerance devices might make it though (because early on all iPads are checked individually, but maybe not re-checked as late as in packaging.) Apple is also known for holding its manufacturers to high quality bars that sometimes are often difficult to meet. So they are under pressure to both meet the agreed upon standards, but also ship tremendous quantities of product without high amounts of rework, the costs of which they, the manufacturer, would have to eat, not Apple.
- chooseaname 8y ago> Apple is also known for holding its manufacturers to high quality bars that sometimes are often difficult to meet. So they are under pressure to both meet the agreed upon standards, but also ship tremendous quantities of product without high amounts of rework, the costs of which they, the manufacturer, would have to eat, not Apple. According to Apple: >The bend is the result of a cooling process involving the iPad Pro’s metal and plastic components during manufacturing, according to Apple Apple is ultimately responsible. They designed this device. Their materials people knew how flexible this chassis would be. I find it highly unlikely they didn't know it would bend until manufacturing ramped up.
- jeklj 8y agoTheir claim that this is normal and expected reeks to high heaven. These people are persnickety beyond belief and they just... don't have a problem with this? I don't buy it.
- kllrnohj 8y agoApple uses premium materials & packaging but they historically have not had very good engineering quality. This goes back years and years, too, it's not a recent thing. Apple frequently does "Exchange and Repair Extension Programs" for these mistakes. I think it's unfair to blame their QA team, either, as some of the issues should have been obvious without QA. Like the recent 6-core macbook pros that didn't receive a thermal capacity or VRM upgrade in response to using a CPU with a higher power usage. It's just not really a thing Apple does. They focus their engineering on the parts you physically see & touch, not the ones you don't. They just deal with that later with repair & replacements programs or crude workarounds.
- chemmail 8y agoYou refer to Apple like only one person works there. There are hundreds of thousands of engineers making hundreds of products with thousands of suppliers. Have you even opened a few devices yourself? The engineering in most other phones are pretty trash compared to how easy it is to work on Apple mobile devices. Their iPads are the most reliable things ever made. I have almost never seen a truly dead iPad while anything Samsung tablet that does not power on goes in the trash. If you have an Apple mobile device you will find TONs of people willing to fix it. Other brands? Good luck. Their computing devices though...
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoThere are only 100K total employees at Apple. Engineers number a small fraction of that. And not hundreds of products - the total is much less than 100, and only that high because of the different configurations of the same product. The reliability thing is true.
- kllrnohj 8y agoiPads may be Apple's unicorn then because right now there's an extended repair & replace program for the iPhone 6 plus, iPhone 6s, iPhone 7, iPhone 8, and iPhone X. The narrative that it's reliable & well-engineered doesn't at all match the fact that nearly every single phone they've made in the last few years needed a special warranty program for a common issue. And that's ignoring things like antennae-gate & bend-gate, too, these are issues that Apple themselves are considering common enough to necessitate a special program to handle. Perhaps there are tons of people willing to fix Apple products because tons of people need their Apple products repaired? That market doesn't really exist if the devices were "the most reliable things ever made" Like it's great that Apple will at least do these programs for the issues, but they also don't have a strong reliability record here, either.
- ken 8y agoI'm sure everyone at Apple is very well paid. (Aside: I truly wish the canard that people who are not well paid must not be good at their jobs would finally die.) There's a story I heard from a former coworker who worked at Apple QA during the time of the first iMac (take it as you will). The infamous puck mouse had hundreds of reports filed against it. They were vetoed, from above. So I would probably agree that Apple has a QA team, and that the company knew about this decided to ship anyway. I disagree that any of this is just "in the recent years", though. The Titanium PowerBooks fell apart easily. The 2013 Mac Pro has no internal expansion, but it's far from the first Mac to suffer from that. For any problem I hear about Apple's hardware today, I can think of other examples of it happening years or decades ago. Lacking a real escape key seems odd on the new MacBook Pro, but the (otherwise cute if big) Apple Adjustable Keyboard had the same problem (and not even the TouchBar as an excuse). And so on.
- scarmig 8y agoIt's not a bug, it's a feature!
- sebazzz 8y agoJeremyRigsEverything showed that you need substantial force to bent an iPad. Isn't this just a single batch that had some bad luck in the factory?
- Johnny555 8y agoIt didn't look very substantial in the video posted here earlier: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hUBsxCcJeUc&t=385 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hUBsxCcJeUc&t=385
- sebazzz 8y agoI have seen that video. Look at the color of his thumbs as he bends the tablet, they are quite white so I think the force is larger than you think. Of course, without comparison, it is hard to tell.
- gnulinux 8y agoAre you trolling? That person bends a $500 machine with 2 thumbs. This is unacceptable.
- CydeWeys 8y agoThese iPads can easily be bent in half with bare hands: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hUBsxCcJeUc&t=385 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hUBsxCcJeUc&t=385 Doesn't bode well for them holding up in, e.g., a backpack or briefcase that ends up being sat or stepped on. Or even just being shoved into an overhead compartment or beneath a seat.
- reaperducer 8y agoThese iPads can easily be bent in half with bare hands Why would you want to? I just don't understand the way people treat their tech devices these days. I see millennials putting iPhones in their back pockets and then wondering why the screen shatters when they sit down. You are putting a piece of glass against your butt and sitting on it! I remember when flip phones, digital cameras, floppy disks, and even Atari 2600's were handled with care. Because they would break, and were expensive to replace! Do people act this way because stuff doesn't cost enough? Because paying for stuff with credit makes it seem like it's free, and therefore not worth anything? Or has the magic just gone out of tech for the average butt-storing phone user?
- Techonomicon 8y agoDid you happen to watch the video? He didn't try very hard to break it. It's not like he put it over his knee using all his strength.
- vorpalhex 8y agoYou shouldn't have to treat a $1000 device like it's going to turn into dust. Sure, don't chuck your phone at concrete walls, but in general a phone needs to be able to take a spill occasionally or have someone sit on it because those things happen in real life. It sounds like Apple has sacrificed too much in the name of being thin, and really botched their structural integrity. Devices exist to be used, not kept in a museum.
- isostatic 8y ago> Sure, don't chuck your phone at concrete walls A friend of mine had her horse stand on her phone. Carried on working for the next few days until it needed recharging, found some mud in the connector, cleaned that out, lasted another few years. The nokia 3210 had a lot going for it.
- macjohnmcc 8y agoThis seems like a cop-out to me. I love Apple products but dismissing manufacturing issues as something we should accept as okay is just wrong. I recently bought the iPhone XS Max so I'm not anti-Apple but I expect premium quality for a premium price.
- mjlee 8y ago> The bend is the result of a cooling process involving the iPad Pro’s metal and plastic components during manufacturing, according to Apple. So it's a manufacturing defect. Calling it a "side effect" instead is just semantics.
- eridius 8y agoA manufacturing defect implies it’s an unexpected outcome. This is an expected outcome.
- qyv 8y agoReally? So apple intended to ship non-flat tablets? What is the rational for intentionally making only some of these non-flat? What advantage or innovation does the non-flatness of a certain percentage of ipad's allow? I mean it totally seams plausible that they simply neglected to mention how non-flat tablets are the next big innovation when they were announced. Or, perhaps this is just damage control because it is fucking embarrassing on a "premium" device.
- singularity2001 8y agoexpectation != intention
- eridius 8y agoYou’re confusing “designed” with “expected outcome”. Obviously Apple didn’t design the iPad to be pre-bent, and presumably they’re not thrilled about this. But that doesn’t mean this isn’t an expected outcome of the manufacturing process. It’s not a desired outcome, but it’s one that I guess Apple decided was acceptable in order to meet the other goals they had for the process.
- memco 8y agoI accidentally sat on my 2017 iPad and bent it a bit. It was fairly easy to bend it back. Depending on the extent of the bend it might be possible to straighten these out as well. Of course this isn’t ideal, but it should be possible to create a procedure to iron out the bend.
- MagicPropmaker 8y agoMy Yoga Book (Lenovo) and Surface Book Pro (Microsoft) are perfectly flat, and they've been around the world several times.
- rjplatte 8y agoLenovo consistently blows me away with build quality. They're simply insane, especially the Thinkpads.
- SyneRyder 8y agoCan't say I'm having that experience with my Lenovo Thinkpad X1 Yoga 3rd Gen. The speakers are the worst sound I've heard in a laptop in a long time, the Dolby HDR screen isn't calibrated out of the box (it has a terrible +10% red tint), and it doesn't charge if the device is switched off - it has to be in sleep mode. I'm regretting my purchase. But that said - it's replacing a MacBook Pro that had to be fixed by Apple 6 times, each time for a faulty SATA flex cable that failed every two months so it couldn't boot from the internal drive. So far the X1 Yoga hasn't had that kind of problem.
- MagicPropmaker 8y agoAnd it's not bent, is it?
- bangonkeyboard 8y agoThe Magic Keyboard has exhibited the same problems since last year: https://mjtsai.com/blog/2017/12/07/the-magic-keyboard-with-numeric-keypad-is-apparently-bendy/ https://mjtsai.com/blog/2017/12/07/the-magic-keyboard-with-n... This is a pattern.
- oflannabhra 8y agoI am an ardent Apple fan, to the extent of sometimes defending them in public or private forums. This is maybe the most bone-headed, indefensible response I've ever seen from them. I get that these are really large, thin devices. I get that they are totally different than the iPad 2 someone might wrap in a case and give to a kid. But saying it is a feature, not a bug, is ridiculous. Their response has immediately made this twice as bad from a PR perspective. Unbelievable.
- eridius 8y agoWhere did they say “it’s a feature”?
- gnulinux 8y ago"it's not a bug, it's a feature" is sort of a phrase/meme referring to bugs that have been tried to not like a bug by PR departments. In this case, we see that this is a bug (iPads are supposed to be flat), but Apple claims "it's normal" to sell their device: classic "it's not a bug, it's a feature" attitude.
- Dirlewanger 8y ago"You're holding it wrong"
- tmd83 8y agoI sometimes what would happen if the Samsung battery kind of issue happened with Apple. I'm sure that they would give some logic and majority of users would still accept it. For the most people at this point it seems it's not what apple did wrong, it's what I did to cause their product to fail.
- Hermel 8y agoThe thin glass screen of our iPad Pro broke only three weeks after we got it. It fell onto the floor from a height of about 50 cm. Of course, the screen is not covered by the warranty and cannot be repaired. I would not recommend the iPad Pro to anyone who expects premium products to be at least as robust as the average tablet.
- whizzkid 8y agoJust a speculation; Apple must be working something really big for years with a lot of engineers shifted to that secret project. I am seeing lots of products not getting enough attention for the last 2-3 years. - Safari is moving really slowly and not improved a lot except security-wise. - iPhones haven't gotten a revolutionary feature for a long time. - MacOS did not get significantly better comparing to last 3-4 years. - Siri looks like a paused project. and so on..
- justtopost 8y agoOr just becoming bloated and complacent.
- whizzkid 8y agoVery possible and I would be sad in that case.
- gnulinux 8y agoOccam's (and partially Hanlon's) razor says they're just not as competent any more, instead of having been working on a "secret" project for the last 3 years. It's sad since they were the first $T tech company.
- foxyv 8y agoJust bought a Pelican case for my work Macbook since I bike and have to travel with it. I'm so scared of liquid damage to the diagnostic port just inside the vent. All it takes is one drop to short and kill the MUX chip. Mac products are stupid fragile.
- PascLeRasc 8y agoWhat backpack do you use? Both of my Timbuk2 bags have incredible water resistance. I've been out with them in dozens of thunderstorms - the kind where you get home and have to change out of all your clothes - and I haven't had so much as a notebook page get wet.