25 ms·
This seems less ambitious than Berlin in a lot of ways. One big difference is that Berlin aimed for network transparency (like X, but ideally done even better),
by _delirium 16y ago
This seems less ambitious than Berlin in a lot of ways. One big difference is that Berlin aimed for network transparency (like X, but ideally done even better), while Wayland is local-only. That might simplify enough things to make it more likely to succeed.
For me personally, now that nx makes X's network transparency actually usable, I'm not in a big hurry to go back to a non-network-transparent windowing system with a screenscraper like VNC layered on top. But I could see that not mattering for a lot of users, so it's probably the right choice.
- mahmud 16y agoThis seems less ambitious than Berlin in a lot of ways. Worse is better, and whoever ships a working prototype is best. Sacrificing network transparency for local performance should be a no-brainer, given the use-cases.
- FooBarWidget 16y agoThe bottleneck in X has never been network transparency. Local access has been accelerated through Unix domain sockets and shared memory for as long as I can remember. It looks like Wayland also has a client/server architecture which makes me suspect it's can be made network transparent just like X is.
- loewenskind 16y agoIt does make for a ridiculous API though. No one writes X for this reason, but I suspect it would speed things up a lot if everyone writing for the platform didn't have to go through multiple layers of better APIs to talk to the actual display subsystem.
- sedachv 16y agoWhat is the "X API"? Are you talking about Xlib? XCB? The protocol? Does this critique include XRender? There's really two parts to modern X programming: the window and event stuff, and XRender. The window and event system isn't bad, and it's fully asynchronous, which is a really big deal. XRender obviously can't be used for drawing by hand (that's why you have Cairo), but it's a really good design for a drawing protocol that supports a lot of possibilities for hardware acceleration.
- FooBarWidget 16y agoWhat API? There is no API, there's a protocol. Switching from TCP sockets to Unix domain sockets requires changing about 3-4 lines of connect code, but everything else remains the same. You get a lot of localhost performance for free with almost no changes.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]