4 ms·
I believe that eugenics is a good idea.
by cperciva 16y ago
I believe that eugenics is a good idea.
- forensic 16y agoThis is pretty much the great unmentionable of our time. Everyone knows the current breeding situation is a problem. Everyone knows they aren't allowed to talk about solutions.
- rms 16y agoBy "breeding situation" do you mean population growth or the right to produce children that are genetically modified?
- forensic 16y agoTo be honest, I mean everything relating to the conscious control of reproduction. Both on an individual level and a social level. Individual: Abortion, genetic modification of fetuses, aborting sick fetuses, etc Social: Overpopulation. The fact that the poor and stupid significantly outbreed the intelligent leading to all kinds of downward spirals. The welfare system that encourages it's beneficiaries to breed as much as possible - and even to induce disorder into their children to maximize revenue. For instance moms on welfare who have produced several kids with fetal alcohol syndrome, not even to bring up issues like nutritional deficiency. There are welfare moms who literally have bred 10 children with induced mental handicaps - and they are financially rewarded by society the more they do this. On a wider but less extreme level, there are psychologically dysfunctional parents who breed at a higher rate than the psychologically sound. I've spoken with many social workers and teachers and others on the front line of this issue and there is a silent but taboo agreement - the use of force in controlling breeding is essential to the future of humanity. There is also the wider point that the stupid and poor propagate themselves while the intelligent and wealthy prefer not to. This comes down to economic incentives. Society would benefit from eugenics programs that specifically encourage successful people to breed and discourage unsuccessful people. Right now the incentives are literally opposite of this. Anyway this is a big topic with many many facets. But speaking to domain experts and reading widely on the topic, it is very clear that some form of what has classically been described as eugenics is necessary for the success of society. (I'm kissing my karma goodbye right now.)
- lukev 16y agoI disagree, because the "poor and stupid" who reproduce a lot are not necessarily genetically poor and stupid. Education, socialization, lack of opportunity, and environmental effects such as drugs and alcohol play a far bigger role in what you see as "poor and stupid" than genetics do. I see no reason why a healthy infant from 10 generations of white trash has any less genetic potential than an infant from 10 generations of people who attended Ivy leagues.
- forensic 16y agoIf all healthy infants from white trash were raised by ivy leaguers I wouldn't complain. It's not only about genetics, it's also about upbringing. Having said that though, it's pretty clear that IQ is related to parentage.
- tomotomo 16y agoEven if it was a good idea, considering the pace of technological development today do you see more benefit in one generation of practiced eugenics versus the advances in technology during that generation? Also, which of your arguments still apply to the world's most populous country?
- konad 16y agoWhen everyone is a superman, who will clean the toilets?
- rms 16y agoRobots
- revorad 16y agoWhat toilets?
- dfranke 16y agoBarring rms's answer being correct, the same people who do now: the people willing to do a good job for the least money. One likely economic outcome of a successful eugenics effort would be that tedious, mindless jobs would be among the best-paying rather than the worst.
- bobds 16y agoPerhaps in the future, when we have a better understanding of genetics. Right now it seems we can't account for unintended consequences.
- zmmz 16y agoAs the department I work for is currently on a big ramp up of staff, I do a lot of interviews. If somebody told gave me that as an answer or told that to me when describing themselves I doubt I could keep a straight face. It's never happened that I didn't keep professional with an applicant - but in this case I think I would not be able to control my laughter. No harm intended, I have my own pretty borderline views, just that one of my "character traits" is that I find radical views that are beyond my comprehension (in this example, very right wing views) absolutely hilarious. Another example would be extreme free marketeers.
- _h4xr 16y agoWould you laugh at someone who thought that it was a good thing for humans to selectively breed plants and animals? We certainly couldn't maintain our population without them. Would you laugh at someone who had a preference for a desirable spouse? That's a common form of eugenics: people prefer healthy, sane, productive mates. There's obviously a difference between preference and policy. But my guess is that you're willing to reap the benefits of eugenics without considering the ethical implications.