3 ms·
There is one thing that really stands out in the choice of words in this article that makes me feel strange about it: Estimating the value of Facebook. > [Face
by Legogris 8y ago
There is one thing that really stands out in the choice of words in this article that makes me feel strange about it: Estimating the value of Facebook.
> [Facebook's] benefits are hard to measure
The Introduction reads like Facebook was the first of its kind and invented the social web. It's kind of like how mainstream media talk about Apple as the inventor of the smartphone and the tabled. It's as if there was no Facebook or Apple, there would never have been any other actor to take that space in the market.
It's like these companies are deities in people's minds. Apple sure has its prophets, but Facebook is probably felt as a more paternalistic and malevolent superego god.
I mean, I would not be surprised to see this kind of narrative in some click-driven blog. But in a peer-reviewed research article?
If this is really how most people think even in academic circles - that it is Facebook or nothing - then there's a huge disconnect and I have grossly underestimated the amount of awareness-spreading needed if we don't want to fully lose the open web.
- vasilipupkin 8y agoit's just that the study is surveying people who already have a Facebook account. So the value they are talking about is not some abstract theoretical concept of value - they are talking about value in the context of quite literally - how much dollar value do people place on having a facebook account.
- Legogris 8y agoI get it, but to me that's like estimating the value of Honda by asking people who drive a Honda how much they would have to be paid to not be able to drive a car anymore. The difference being that there are alternatives to cars while Facebook has a monopoly on the social graph of many users. I think one could argue that Facebook is a monopoly on online communication for large parts of the social graph right now, especially as they also own WhatsApp and Instagram.