4 ms·
I am quite okay with making a disney exception because a few years after it was made people might suddenly gain some common sense and say "no that's stupid" I
by munk-a 8y ago
I am quite okay with making a disney exception because a few years after it was made people might suddenly gain some common sense and say "no that's stupid"
I don't understand why life+20 years is a thing though, even life seems excessive.
Let an artist profit for twelve years off their work and then release it for free use. The vast majority of money will have already been made and the innovation of their work will have worn off.
- dannyw 8y ago12 years copyright, 20 years moral rights sound good to me.
- anticensor 8y ago3½ years of copyright (with royalties, transferable once) plus renewals every six months up to 21 years with moral rights along with copyright term and up to lifelong after copyright expiration (no monopolies, non-transferable authorship, attribution only) would be the solution. This will satisfy all the industry and academics, bar Disney.
- zjaffee 8y agoThe reason why we let copy written works remain that way is because then the profits of the artists work will always get eaten up by bigger companies. This is especially true in the digital age. Instead of artists profiting, corporations from netflix to amazon to spotify would profit instead of actual artists, and at least for big brand characters, Chinese toy companies would be able to undercut those who spent the capital building the brand around a given character. So much of the American economy and brand is cultural exports, and this would absolutely destroy a huge chunk of that.
- hakfoo 8y agoThere's some precedent for this-- I think the UK has a specific cutout providing a perpetual copyright for a few specific works that were willed to charities.
- TheRealPomax 8y agoBecause artists have family, and if that brilliant writer wrote a book a year before they died of cancer or old age or a stupid accident, I'm okay with his family getting the proceeds. The world can wait a decade or two. A generation or two, different matter. Also, and here's the dark part: if it's just 20 years, rather than "life" or "life plus X", people WILL start getting assassinated just to get their copyright to expire faster.
- TeMPOraL 8y ago> Also, and here's the dark part: if it's just 20 years, rather than "life" or "life plus X", people WILL start getting assassinated just to get their copyright to expire faster. Nah, the assasination would happen if it's `min(life, 20 years)` or `life + 20 years`; there's no reason to hire hitmen if it's simply `20 years`, regardless of whether or not the author is alive.
- munk-a 8y agoI do admit, though, that after I wrote that I considered that we'd probably start seeing a lot of movies 21 years after their books were published.
- benj111 8y agoIf I die suddenly do I have some right to demand that my employer/customer pays my family some amount of money. You are probably right that that's the intent but if so make it a fixed 20 years. Your second paragraph seems to be saying the opposite of what you want it to?
- bediger4000 8y agoAt least in the USA, the legal justification is to promote progress in science and useful arts, not to give someone/some entity a monopoly on use an idea. If someone writes a great book and then up and dies (John Kennedy Toole, "A Confederacy of Dunces") I'm not sure that giving any entity a copyright promotes any kind of progress in science or useful arts. Toole can't write another book. Yes, this is legalistic, but just giving some entity ownership over representations of anthropomorphized rodents doesn't really make a lot of sense either.