5 ms·
Same for companies like Amazon. Grow super fast and ignore tax laws regarding nexus so you don't pay sales tax. Need to point out that Amazon did not ignore ta
by gamblor956 8y ago
Same for companies like Amazon. Grow super fast and ignore tax laws regarding nexus so you don't pay sales tax.
Need to point out that Amazon did not ignore tax laws regarding nexus. They took advantage of a Supreme Court decision on nexus laws (Quill) that resulted in them not having nexus in most states. They were forced to change their stance because at some point it was clear that they had surpassed the Quill factors that had earlier protected them.
Moreover, you have the order of subsidies wrong. Amazon subsidized AWS with its retail earnings. The reason Amazon didn't show profits for years was because it reinvested its gross sales income in building up AWS and other ventures.
But the other stuff about third party sellers, etc. is spot on.
- sharemywin 8y agoWas AWS subsidized with retail earnings or they were flush with investor cash which allowed them to invest in AWS? They also bought a huge warehouse footprint, too.
- turc1656 8y agoIf you look at their SEC filings, it is clear that recently (I last looked early in 2018 or late 2017), the retail business was listed as having huge losses. Losses on the order of 15-20% of gross revenue! Meanwhile, AWS was highly profitable at this time and was the reason the company as a whole was finally booking profits with margins of a paltry ~1.3% or so, if I recall correctly. The retail business has never been profitable because of the huge costs of running all those logistics and warehouses and shipping (even with their rock bottom shipping costs). You may be right about Quill. I don't know enough about it. But regardless, at some point it's clear they surpassed the guidelines of Quill and became liable and are to this day not complying with the law in my opinion.