3 ms·
I'm not sure that social advocacy should be a goal of the legal profession. I understand that most politicians tend to have degrees in law, however when you ta
by tracker1 8y ago
I'm not sure that social advocacy should be a goal of the legal profession. I understand that most politicians tend to have degrees in law, however when you take on a political stance and display it, it seems to me that this has the net effect of weakening the role of lawyers and justice in general.
I've always thought that public defenders, and prosecutors should be a pool of publicly paid lawyers that have to take on cases of all kinds. That the respect for the basis of personal liberty and being able to objectively argue for either side of any given narrative is of paramount importance.
I think too many of the current twenty-something generation appear to be far more concerned with feelings, virtue and equality of outcome than they are thinking critically and doing what is most right for all involved. Less self, more service.
- zozbot123 8y ago> I'm not sure that social advocacy should be a goal of the legal profession. So, no Gary Becker, no Richard & Eric Posner, no Guido Calabresi, no Ronald Coase? That would be pretty awful, if you ask me. Lawyers and jurists can provide a useful perspective on the social sciences.
- gamblor956 8y agoSocial advocacy has always been the province of lawyers. You owe your civil rights to lawyers. The codification of human rights into meaningful rights was done by lawyers. Hell, the very concept of individual property rights that underlies Western Civilization was the work of lawyers. And it was all driven by lawyers concerned about virtue and equality of outcome.
- remarkEon 8y ago>equality of outcome See that’s where you lost me.
- tracker1 8y agoEquality of rights means that every person has the same rights. Equal protection under the law means that every person is legally treated the same in terms of how they are treated by the government. Rarely happens in practice. Equality of opportunity means that the most qualified person gets the job. That the person with the best grade gets the grant/scholarship. Equality of outcome means that someone who works very hard gets the same (housing, income, lifestyle) as someone with no job who sits around playing CoD all day. It means that you get service distribution lines. It means that people will randomly disappear when they complain about the conditions. It means over 150 million dead (from communist regimes so far).
- tareqak 8y agoI don't understand how focusing on virtue and equality of outcome is not more service for the benefit of all. Critical thinking would probably be a tool whose use could be orthogonal those two just like feelings.
- tracker1 8y agoSo, you feel that someone who is brilliant with a given skill, who uses his trade for benefit of society should have the same outcome (same amount of income, same housing, same quality of life) as someone with below average intelligence who sits around and plays video games all day?
- tareqak 8y agoNo, but I don't think the latter individual should starve, or be unable to afford healthcare, or be forced to work in unsafe work conditions, or be forced to work multiple jobs because any single on that this person can get doesn't pay enough. I think the minimum that both individuals should expect to get from various levels of government should be the same, and that minimum should be of sufficient level so that the least fortunate can work towards something better when the time and situation permit without being forced to subsist in poverty and the mindset that poverty locks people into.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> I'm not sure that social advocacy should be a goal of the legal profession It's generally not (outside of, perhaps, access to legal services, and the fact that legal advocacy is, itself, a proper subset of social advocacy.) OTOH, lawyers don't stop being citizens, and social advocacy (in the broad sense) is a right and important role of citizens in a liberal democracy.
- tracker1 8y agoHowever, given that judges and a large share of the political pool is drawn from lawyers, I feel that a bit of restraint, understanding and leaning towards impartiality at least from the point of considering all sides is incredibly important. At the point one becomes a social advocate, they probably shouldn't be running for judicial office at the very least, and maybe reconsider any ambitions of public office at all.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> At the point one becomes a social advocate, they probably shouldn't be running for judicial office at the very least, and maybe reconsider any ambitions of public office at all. Judges (and, a fortiori, judicial candidates) remain citizens and do not surrender their right to participate publicly as citizens; there is a certain degree or restraint and separation of advocacy and judicial role, but (while there is room to debate application in specific cases, and clear places where the existing norms have failed to be applied) there are well-established norms of conflict avoidance and recusal/removal from particular cases that address this. I don't think stronger basic norms are needed here, though more vigrous enforcement of existing norms. As for non-judicial public office, social advocacy is very much what the electorate looks for in candidates for those offices and how it judges them, the idea that anyone involved in social advocacy should avoid such offices is, well, unusual, and it definitely needs more of an argument than you've presented.