6 ms·
Uber loses latest legal bid over driver rights
- thatoneuser 8y ago“Drivers... want to keep the freedom to choose if, when and where they drive.” “If drivers were classified as workers they would inevitably lose some of the freedom and flexibility that comes with being their own boss." Lol. These companies are still pushing this blatantly false propaganda that you can “make $25+ an hour” and that you’re free to just pop in and out if the system whenever you want to achieve that. Here’s the reality - you’re only going to make that kind of money on a few select hours. Namely - late nights, early mornings, and weekends (again mostly nights). The reality is most hours of the week you may be looking at making <$15 an hour, and that’s before you consider wear and tear, gas, extra insurance, tickets (given enough time you will get fined doing this kind of work one way or another), and all the other little costs that come up (bring tissues and water bottles and candy for your passengers!). There’s virtually no freedom in this unless you’re literally just trying to make beer money for a night and work for 2-3 hours a week. If you depend on this for consistent work (read: not a career, but a full time fill in between jobs) - you’re going to be raked over the coals. You don’t get a choice in when or where you work. Hell you don’t even really have the choice to decline rides unless you’re willing to drive all the way to a person (up to 15 mins away), THEN the app tells you where you’re headed, and at that point you probably have a person standing there looking at you. You can drive away and cancel, but these companies know that the empathetic nature of most people makes that extremely painful. Plus you’ve wasted your time and gas (unpaid) getting here, so you’re paying for this “freedom”. You can’t set boundaries for where you work - you might end up hours from home and again, you now have to subsidize the cost of getting home again. So basically every claim these companies make about the value they give to their workers is bullshit. You don’t control “if” you drive, any more than you control “if” you eat. You don’t control where you drive... pretty much at all. And you don’t control “when” you drive unless you’re willing to work below minimum wage. I would love if these assholes get buried and have to pay back all the drivers historically for the wages they deserve and give compensation for the psychological manipulation they’ve orchestrated. I can’t believe that in 2018 we still permit these shenanigans that systemically restructure themselves to squeeze through clearly illegal employment methods that would be handled in any other industry.
- deogeo 8y ago> "If drivers were classified as workers they would inevitably lose some of the freedom and flexibility that comes with being their own boss." Does the law actually mandate that employers offer less freedom and flexibility if someone is classified as a worker? Because from my vague familiarity with it, it does nothing of the sort, and this statement by Uber is misleading well beyond the point of lying. After all, isn't it precisely the lack of said "freedom and flexibility" that got their contractors classified as workers in the first place?
- thatoneuser 8y agoGood point. I think the underlying message they’re conveying is “as an employee you don’t get freedom, and that comes with fair compensation/benefits”. The implication being that the pay/benefits for them is not as good, but compensated by “freedom and flexibility”. However as you astutely point out, they don’t actually provide those things.
- gpapilion 8y agoUltimately Uber would choose to limit workers in a wait state since an idle driver is not profitable and now a major direct cost.
- cjlars 8y agoI'm many US states, loss of flexibility is the likely outcome. For example, in California you cannot pay someone for a shift lasting less than two hours. You can send them home if there's no work, but you still owe them at least two, if not four hours worth of pay. So if a driver wants to knock out a few trips while he/she has some time to kill, that would functionally be illegal due to the cost burden. Current employment law assumes scheduled shifts, so the "drive when you want" option would likely fall apart when Uber is given the legal right to dictate that X number of drivers will be working peak hours.