9 ms·
Being Fit May Be as Good for You as Not Smoking
- Qw3r7 8y agoNo shit
- kris-s 8y agoIn aggregate it seems pretty clear the science is in for living a healthy life: get enough sleep, exercise, don't eat sugar. It's obviously more complicated than that, especially at the individual level, but if you aren't hitting those three you're missing out on some serious quality of life improvements (both in the short term and long term).
- sambull 8y agoCan't obsesses over the get enough sleep and exercise thing. Even more important working a sedentary office job mixed with a always alert/ops style job (some of us may be familiar with). Realizing when to let a problem be organizational rather than a personal sleep deficit is also key in those positions. They'll say your a rock-star for trading your sleep and life for their bottom line. It's debt impounding interest and unless your luckier than a power-ball winner they won't be there when that payment is due.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- matchbok 8y agoSuch a shame that the "healthy at any size" BS is so popular these days. Literally killing people.
- Afton 8y agoHAES is not BS. Here's the deal. For lots and lots of people, being not fat is very very hard. So hard, that even though there is enormous social pressure that they've had basically from ~12 years old to however old they are, they still haven't managed to become non-fat for any significant length of time. HAES is a reaction that says "What if we accepted that some people are just going to be fat, and then tried to come up with ways of being as healthy as possible given the circumstances". You may not like the packaging that HAES comes wrapped up in, and the most vocal proponents of it are often the least interested in making it palatable to you. But it's not BS. Consider that there is essentially nothing that medical science has for people who are chronically fat except a gastric sleeve. Shit is hard, yo.
- diminoten 8y ago> being not fat is very very hard Irrelevant. It is not more healthy to be fat than it is to be not-fat because it's hard. Acceptance is not going to change a damn thing about the health risks inherent with being fat. You have all my sympathy. One of my closest friends is a very large guy, and I want him to be around when we get old, but the stats tell me that's less and less likely every year he stays obese. Me accepting him (and I do) won't keep him on this planet. :(
- soneca 8y agoDamage control might be a smart way to improve health.
- diminoten 8y agoThe data doesn't say it is. Sure you can improve on other axes, but weight is a leading indicator of mortality. I wish you were right, it'd be great to be able to be obese and healthy, but that just isn't how it is.
- soneca 8y agoThat's not what damage control is. I am not claiming that there is a way to be fat and absolutely healthy. I am saying that there are ways to be healthier while being fat. That is damage control, like the ones applied to drug addiction. And that is proved to be a good decision in some cases.
- diminoten 8y ago> And that is proved to be a good decision in some cases. No it hasn't, because it doesn't exist as you describe. It exists as I've described. Everything you can do, while obese, you can also do while not-obese.
- Afton 8y agoWhy do you think I'm fat? I'm not > Irrelevant. It is not more healthy to be fat than it is to be not-fat because it's hard. Acceptance is not going to change a damn thing about the health risks inherent with being fat. You are entirely missing the point. The issue is "given that I'm going to be fat, perhaps I should work with what I have, rather than beating myself up over the fact that I'm fat". Once you do that, you can start to look at what else you might change about your life that would improve your health.
- LeoPanthera 8y agoIt's not "popular". It's a strawman created by anti-feminists. It doesn't really exist in the real world.
- Afton 8y agoIt's really not. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fat_acceptance_movement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fat_acceptance_movement
- learc83 8y agoA Wikipedia article on the subject doesn't mean that it's not a strawman.
- Afton 8y agoI don't know what to say. It's not a global media conspiracy. For decades there have been actual fat acceptance activists and communities. Good luck.
- learc83 8y ago"Doesn't exist" was hyperbole. If you want to be literal, what the OP was saying is that it's an extremely small fringe group that isn't large enough to matter, and the response to it created by internet outrage culture makes it look like a much bigger issue than it actually is.
- LeoPanthera 8y agoYes that was my intention. Please note that I didn't say "doesn't exist", I said "doesn't really exist", which is not the same.
- NotAnEconomist 8y agoI've noticed that they don't actually believe "Healthy At Any Size", because they routinely skinny- or fit-shame people. So I've started referring to them as "Healthy At My Size", which is their real argument -- that their overweight size is healthy. It also yields a more appropriate initialism.
- learc83 8y agoIt's not popular. There are far more people making fun of fat acceptance than there are people who are making the claim that being fat is healthy. There are plenty of people who are against body shaming, unrealistic beauty standards etc... Very few who think that being very overweight is actually healthy.
- vokep 8y agoYou claim this, but now if you goto a department store, you'll find the mannequins are all a little bit heavy, as in, overweight.
- learc83 8y agoIf you go into department stores, the vast majority of mannequins aren't clinically overweight unless you are specifically shopping in a plus size store. Even if this were true, your argument doesn't follow from the evidence. The existence of clothing for overweight people doesn't imply that people believe that being overweight is healthy. It only implies that overweight people exist, and someone wants to make money selling clothes to them.
- justtopost 8y agoDuck 'vanity sizing' sometime.
- learc83 8y agoGoogle 'average mannequin size'. The average female mannequin is underweight, not overweight. One study did a survey and found that 100% of the female mannequins they examined represented a clinically underweight woman. Vanity sizing is a thing because female sizing completely arbitrary and stores want to make women feel better about their weight. If anything this is evidence that fat acceptance hasn't caught on--if it had, people wouldn't be ashamed to wear a larger size. Regardless, I'll say it again--the fact that overweight people exist says nothing about the assertion that many people believe that being overweight is healthy. 1. https://jeatdisord.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s40337-017-0142-6 https://jeatdisord.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s40337... This 2017 study did a survey and found that 100% of the female mannequins they examined represented an underweight woman.
- 0x8BADF00D 8y agoDepends on your genetics. If you don’t have high blood pressure, dyslipidemia, or diabetes, and you’re clinically healthy, it’s fine. Some people are ectomorphs. I have friends who are hardgainers, and believe me, it is a struggle for them to bulk. You have to eat a massive surplus of calories per day and most of that has to be protein. Conversely, some people are endomorphs. It’s very difficult to cut (in my case). I need a big caloric deficit relative to others, and do cardio on my rest days in order to keep my body fat at a reasonable percentage. Eugenics should be actively encouraged. We have the technology to make it so many will never have to suffer metabolic issues or chromosomal abnormalities.
- bitexploder 8y agoWhat is a "big calorie deficit" relative to others? I am just curious because the general physiology is pretty simple and I have read some things that pretty thoroughly debunk endomorph vs. ectomorph. It is must more useful to classify based on muscle fiber composition. People with a lot of fast twitch muscle fiber build muscle quicker, etc.
- 0x8BADF00D 8y agoWhat is a "big calorie deficit" relative to others? For me, I’ve found 400-500 below my maintainence works best. > It is must more useful to classify based on muscle fiber composition. People with a lot of fast twitch muscle fiber build muscle quicker, etc. I agree with you here. I needed labels to bin the two (very general) categories of body composition types, so I chose those two.
- bitexploder 8y agoMakes sense. I have had my RMR tested and I am dead average. I have never had success with small deficits because I am not disciplined enough to maintain -700 net cals per week or whatever.
- thosakwe 8y agoDo we really have to go through this on this site...? The point of the body positivity movement is literally crystal clear - to end shaming of people for the size of their body. There's no "BS" to it. People's health is their own concern. Whether or not someone decides to change for a healthier lifestyle, there's nothing wrong with them at least loving their self throughout the process. It's also really not that popular of a sentiment. Just ask any overweight person the things they hear on the regular. Come on now.
- CuriouslyC 8y agoPeople's health is their own concern to the extent that they do not burden society with their health care costs, nor the people in their life due to their poor condition.
- learc83 8y ago>burden society with their health care costs That's every single non-optimal health decision though. You shouldn't have gone into construction because now you need a knee replacement. You should've used a treadmill desk instead of sitting for so long. If you'd just had a child before you were 30 you probably wouldn't have gotten breast cancer etc...
- tachion 8y agoIt's not true that people's health is their own concern. Especially not when my taxes pay for your treatment when you've deliberately not taken care of yourself and not when your lack of regard in this manner promote similar thing happening to other people (children, for example).
- lordCarbonFiber 8y agoIf you're actually concerned about "your taxes" you should celebrate the over weight and otherwise unhealthy. The lion's share of health care costs are end of life treatments; don't have to worry about those if you die of a heart attack at age 45.
- rsync 8y ago"Such a shame that the "healthy at any size" BS is so popular these days. Literally killing people." I don't wish ill health or discomfort on anyone but ones physical condition, appearance and personal health are one's own business. Provided that you rise to a minimal standard of civic responsibility... I owe it to you to be able to run for help. I owe it to you to be able to perform chest compressions for 3-5 minutes. I owe it to you to be able to carry or drag an adult a few hundred feet to safety. I owe it to you to be fit to join a group standing in physical defense of others. If you can't do those things, you have something to answer for - regardless of the diet/fitness/health/appearance fads of the day.
- pm90 8y agoI don't think its healthy at any size as much as not shaming people for their body sizes, which are different issues. We can and should continue promoting healthy living habits while restraining from shaming those who aren't there yet.
- bitxbitxbitcoin 8y agoBad reading is killing people. The relevant info is still there it is just hidden: Being fit and not smoking is healthier than being fit or not smoking separately.
- paulcole 8y agoWhat in the article led to this comment? There's no mention of"healthy at any size" in the article and no mentions of "fat", "obesity", or "overweight."
- gammateam 8y agoSince the title obviously doesn't make sense The article's summary of the study said that being unfit is as bad for you as not smoking. Thats very different than just replacing every word with the negation. Its almost like a machine learning algorithm made this title as the most attention getting group of words
- aaaaaaaaaab 8y agoBut the being rich beats both in terms of life expectancy.
- newnewpdro 8y agoLife is immeasurably more enjoyable as a fit, healthy person. Even if it had zero impact on longevity, it's an obvious win.
- kawfey 8y agoIt's hard to explain that to an unfit person who would argue it's immeasurably more enjoyable to eat whatever you want, whenever you want. Sometimes only after they develop heart disease or diabetes, or other obesity-related health complications do they realize maybe it wasn't such a good idea to never exercise and frequently supersize.
- newnewpdro 8y agoIt's always hard to convince an addict of practicing anything vs. their addiction. This is an entirely different issue in my opinion. Explaining it is easy, these folks generally understand, it simply doesn't matter because they're hooked. This situation is pervasive, it's no different than people being addicted to activities unnecessarily burning fossil fuels, despite their rational understanding of how it's slowly ruining their habitat.
- mattlondon 8y agoAny data on that? I am not convinced that it is "immeasurably" so. Being fit is not going to change some of the most unpleasant things in a lot of people's lives. A commute is still a commute. A bereavement is still a bereavement. A boring job is still a boring job. Debts are still debts etc etc. Being fit is not going to change any of those, so I am not sure how life gets immeasurably more enjoyable if you are as fit as an Olympian but your partner just died and you've got to go work in the Amazon Fulfilment center 90 minutes bus ride away to pay for your medical/student debts and still just about have enough left over to pay for basic food and heating. But hey I can run 100m in under 10 seconds so wow my life is immeasurably better as a result!</sarcasm>
- newnewpdro 8y ago> Being fit is not going to change some of the most unpleasant things in a lot of people's lives. A commute is still a commute. A bereavement is still a bereavement. A boring job is still a boring job. Debts are still debts etc etc. It changes your baseline level of comfort and happiness, every single one of these things is less unpleasant than it would be otherwise. Speaking from experience as a formerly obese person, now capable of hundreds of pushups and running numerous miles in my 40s. It seems every moment of every day is better this way, except perhaps the sometimes annoying unwanted attention from the opposite sex.
- _underflow_ 8y agoI remember seeing a similar, slightly-less-semantically-awkward title being posted recently. Something along the lines of "Not Exercising just as bad for you as Smoking"
- Fricken 8y agoA thing that bothers me is that in the popular consciousness the defacto way to get fit is to hit a 24 hour fitness gym to count to ten alone under flourescent lights. You're not very likely at all to engender a lifelong fitness habit doing that. Do things that engage you emotionally, mentally, and socially. Do things that are fun, and adventurous. Compete, even if it's at a beer league level. You need more robust and tangible fitness goals than looking good in the mirror in 6 months. Fitness gyms hate you. They want your annual fee and then they don't want to see you again until next year. It you're trapped in the mindset that keeping fit is some kind of chore that you have to add on to an already busy life, you're doing it wrong. When you see people in their 70s who are still kicking ass, it's because using their body is at the centre of their life, not at the margins.
- konschubert 8y agoOn top of that, isn't reducing calory intake much more important than the little amount of calories burned in the gym? Of course there are plenty of reasons to do sports. But my understanding was that for losing weight, it's mostly about how much you eat.
- marricks 8y agoPeople here seem to value fat shaming so I think it’s valuable to mention it doesn’t help. Reposting a reply I made: Portugal legalized drugs and made them safer to use and... people were generally healthier and better off.[1] People have unhealthy habits because of issues in their life. Poverty, abuse, mental health issues, lack of access to healthcare and healthy foods. If you want people to get better you need to stop vilifying them, e.g fat shaming or war on drugs, and start accepting and helping them. Same for drugs, same for weight, hell, I’d say it’s the same for many “criminals” too. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drug_policy_of_Portugal https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drug_policy_of_Portugal
- towelr34dy 8y agoHave you been to Portugal? The stigma of a heroin user is strong there. You know why? Because we don't want heroin users. I'm a libertarian. 100% in favor of allowing people to own their own body (i.e. they can put in whatever they want) Being fat isn't a crime. There is no war on fatness. There is simply a stigma. A stigma to dissuade people. It works. It worked for me. I know other people who got their shit in gear because they were tired of not getting the respect they felt they deserve. I come from a hard background. The Healthy while Fat is just an excuse to want to gain acceptance of unhealthy behavior. No it won't work. Sure, cigarette smokers come from shitty backgrounds (I was one). But getting looked down on was a major reason for me to quit. Are there weak people who will forever smoke and feel bad? Yes. I have no answer for them. But I know we can't start accpeting cigarette smokers. Or more people will smoke. That is a totally different thing than using VIOLENCE to make it so someone can't access their vice. I 100% support people engaging in vices. I also think we should as a society be more accepting of vices. Because they have good and bad. Some of the best chefs I've known are fat. Some of my favorite music was made on heroin.
- Jarb 8y agoMaybe I'm misreading what you wrote, but how do you societally accept a vice while at the same time stigmatizing it?
- 8y ago
- vivekd 8y agoThe interesting part of this for me is their conclusion that that there is no such thing as being too fit in terms of longevity and health. This is surprising because a lot of athletic and fitness endeavours I've seen stress the importance of getting adequate rest days and not overworking. For example, in weight lifting circles, people often stress that lifting every day can lead to injuries and negative health effects. I wonder if this article calls that into question or perhaps they are just overlooking that the most "highly fit" people also take adequate rest days as a part of their routine. It's probably also likely that the more highly fit someone is, the more likely they are to have other factors that increase longevity - ie. it means they have the leisure time to exercise and maintain a high level of fitness, it means they likely watch what they eat etc. I wonder how much of this is direct causation vs correlation.
- paulcole 8y agoWorking out to exhaustion constantly doesn't make you more fit. Rest days are key to improving fitness. This doesn't conflict with "there is no such thing as being too fit in terms of longevity and health."
- honkycat 8y agoPeople do have different metabolisms. But, the "genetically obese" thing is not true. That does not mean we should put the blame 100% on these people, however. I encourage you to have empathy for these people. Because what it takes: Going to the gym, going hiking, getting physical activity, is not available for a lot of people. It is a huge privilege to live somewhere AND HAVE THE TIME to do these activities. Most people live paycheck to paycheck, a gym membership is a meal they cannot put on the table. Their houses are small and working out inside of them is miserable. Or they are working multiple jobs and they choose not to spend the 2 hours of free-time they have a day working out. Who can really blame them? Outside there could be violence, or the constant threat of being harassed by the police. Or, it could just simply be a paved-over wasteland where the community did not think that maybe people will want somewhere to walk around for a while. My anecdote: I used to live in Chicago, and I was a serial "join the gym and never work out" person. I got pretty overweight at 190 lbs, 5'10. I moved to Portland, Oregon. And something interesting happened: Portland is smaller, and getting to the gym means meandering down a few tree-lined lanes until I reach a huge converted warehouse that now serves as a gym. The gyms I had seen in Chicago were squat-ceiling converted office space. I found going to the gym MUCH EASIER, due to the quality of the gym and the environment around me.
- oftenwrong 8y agoEating less saves both time and money. You can save money by buying less food. You can save time by shopping for food less, preparing food less, eating less, and cleaning up less. You can eat less at home, at work, at the bus stop - anywhere, and while doing any activity. Anybody can eat less, no matter what their life is like.
- timbit42 8y agoEating less takes will-power. It takes more will-power than many people have. What they need is to understand which foods they can eat that will reduce their desire to eat as much and as often.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- parliament32 8y agoSo if I'm fit but I smoke they'll balance each other out, right?
- lihaciudaniel 8y agoLike Arnold... Yes