4 ms·
Tunneling is currently so expensive that there are few companies doing any innovation on how to properly utilize them. A big part of the problem is actually dig
by jillesvangurp 8y ago
Tunneling is currently so expensive that there are few companies doing any innovation on how to properly utilize them. A big part of the problem is actually digging them in a way that is cheap and scaleable. Another part of the problem is the organizations doing the digging and doing the exploitation are typically have misaligned incentives and goals.
For example, expanding subway systems is currently in the hands of very badly run semi government institutions who are arguably quite bad at even utilizing the tunnels they have. E.g. the new york subway system is famously less efficient than ever due to the fact that they keep reducing the speed at which trains travel through it. Digging new tunnels is relatively rare for them; and when they do dig new tunnels, they tend to just use them exactly the same way as their existing tunnels, which is not very efficiently. Also, like most government infrastructure projects, progress is slow and things tend to go way over budget.
Musk's approach is twofold: 1) turn tunnel digging into a scaleable business. 2) provide concrete things to do with these tunnels that are not backwards and stupid that he can sell. For example, if you have autonomous vehicles, you don't need a lot of expensive infrastructure inside the tunnels to get from A to B. Infrastructure like rails, signaling equipment, power lines for the trains, etc. It so happens he has a business for autonomous vehicles already. He sells the whole package. That's why he's emphasizing the use cases.
This is classic Musk, he thinks end to end an he might actually pull it off.
- Luc 8y agoYou're comparing a difficult but real situation with a perfect but hypothetical one. Things always are wonderful when they're research projects that don't need to conform to real-world limitations.
- TheAceOfHearts 8y agoNew York subway system is probably the best we have in the US, but it's laughably bad when compared to the top players. I've traveled to Japan and during my trips I've been amazed by their train system. It was always on time and it ran incredibly frequently, so missing a train usually wasn't a big deal. Although I haven't visited there, I've also heard incredibly positive things about China's trains. My point here is that there's still a lot of room for improvement, even if you limit yourself to trains. It doesn't seem like such a stretch to extend it a bit further to this new emerging system.
- dwild 8y ago> difficult but real situation His first argument is that it's currently too expensive to have any innovation. This tunnel cost 10 millions $. Sure it's usage is still hypothetical, but you can't say this won't be much more accessible to innovate. I'm in Montreal, our subway barely changed in the past 30 years. I was lucky, I was affected by one of the only change they did in theses 30 years, 3 more stations on an already completely full line. That came with a 745m$ price for 3 stations that sure allowed people further to take it, but it didn't increase at all the actual capacity. It's hard for any of our administration to even consider any major expansion because of that. If making smaller projects now make sense, maybe we will see more innovation in the technology, in how they are handled, etc...
- ABCLAW 8y agoMaybe I can provide a bit more context re: Montreal. Montreal's metro throughput is not gated by the tunnel capacity. It is gated by the amount of trains in operation. Adding additional cars on the 'already full line' would increase the line's capacity. Neither the orange nor the green line are close to full. The issue with the orange line extension isn't that the lines are full. It's that 1) subway costs are heavily subsidized at the municipal and provicial level, 2) they were extended to Laval which funds the STL, not the STM, and 3) there was no revenue or cost sharing agreement between Laval and Montreal to subsidize the STM in proportion to the burden placed on the STM by Laval riders. This issue with cross-subsidization also lies at the core of the municipal agglomeration which occurred in Quebec metropolitan regions. Montreal won't consider additional subway expansion not because of financial and infrastructure cost reasons, but because of political ones, much in the same way that internal negotiations regarding the dual super-hospital projects were intentionally sabotaged for political reasons.
- jillesvangurp 8y agoNot so hypothetical now that they delivered the first tunnel. I'm guessing that might help him land a few more deals for more tunnels. My understanding is they already closed a few such deals.
- jfoster 8y agoIt's funny. About 15 years ago, people would say the same about electric vehicles. You know the guy who made those work in appealing ways? Same guy.
- xvilka 8y agoApart from pointing at Asian nations building subways in almost every big city, it might also worth a look to the Arab Peninsula, with also very high speed of digging and building required infrastructure. It is only US who is behind at this sadly.
- jillesvangurp 8y agoThis is a problem in Europe as well. The new North south line in Amsterdam cost over 3 Billion to complete and took well over a decade to build. China is indeed digging at huge speed. My understanding with the Boring company is not that they are doing anything particularly special but merely doing things in a way that facilitates economies of scale. So, they standardize designs, equipment, logistics, etc. and they use automation. If you do a one off tunnel with a machine that will only be used for that tunnel, that doesn't make sense. If you are planning to do many tunnels that makes a lot of sense.
- ben_w 8y agoMinor quibble, one thing I would definitely want in these is power. Not only because you can bet someone’s battery will die inside, but also as a way to synergise: fast recharge your Tesla while you ride this really cheap tunnel.
- smileysteve 8y ago> if you have autonomous vehicles, you don't need a lot of expensive infrastructure inside the tunnels to get from A to B. Infrastructure like rails, signaling equipment, power lines for the trains, etc. 2 lanes of 3 rails that are grade leveled should be relatively less expensive than paved, with rebar grade leveled; especially over time, with the increased wear that liquid has.